Customer Reviews

Mustang: The Saga of the Wild Horse in the American West

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

As a wild horse researcher and advocate, I have mixed feelings about this book. Stillman writes with passion, and her lively style keeps the pace moving. I am encouraged that the book has brought national attention back to the plight of wild horses-and it is certainly time for an update of Hope Ryden's popular and intelligent 1970 book, America's Last Wild Horses. But I don't think this is that book. Stillman's inspiration for this project was the shocking wild horse shootings in Nevada, yet she uses that incident only to "bookend" the text, never really engaging with current attitudes or explaining such behavior. Instead, she gallops off into a re-hashing of western history from the perspective of horses, making a sweeping and unsupported case that every cowboy, Indian and cavalry horse of note were former wild horses/mustangs (by her own admission, she has a hard time appreciating any difference between wild and domestic horses, and this shows throughout). The main body of the book describes these general western contexts rather than wild horses and their histories per se, and too much space is devoted to topics like the Little Big Horn battle, which are not directly relevant and have been covered much better by others. Along the way she perpetuates misconceptions and down-right errors, such as claiming that immense wild herds developed from a few horses that strayed from Spanish explorers, Comanche, the famous Seventh Cavalry mount of Myles Keogh was one of many captured mustangs used by the U.S. Army, and that Plains Indians acquired most of their horses by capturing them wild-she even quotes a "horse taking song" in support of this idea, when it refers to the practice of taking horses from enemy camps (Plains peoples got most of their horses from trading and raiding, not "gathering"). She does not indicate her sources, and I have never seen or even heard of the "Mandan legend" about ice-age horses that she "quotes" from without attribution. These are just a few examples of her focus on the "saga" at the expense of research and experience, which is important because confidence in sources provides common ground for discussion and leads to informed understanding. Bottom line: this is a "feel good" book, meant to stir appreciation for horses, and judging from reviews, it has succeeded in that-at least among receptive readers who already love horses. For those with a background in wild horse issues, this book adds little new information or original thinking to the discussion. The average reader will find it a pleasurable, perhaps heart-warming and heart-breaking ride, but don't use this book as a reference for your next term paper.

Added Later: Yes, Stillman includes a good bibliography; sorry for the misunderstanding-I meant that there is no way to figure out the source of particular statements and interpretations, such as the passage bout the about the Mandan legend. Overall I am certainly supportive of this book; it is a well-written popular treatment of an important subject; but as a specialist on wild horses and North American ethnography, and as someone who teaches anthropology and writing to college students, I could not help but notice the issues that I mentioned.

In writing "Mustang," Deanne Stillman has given us an amazing new view of American history--the one that was made by wild horses. I have waited for years to read a book like this, one that tells the true story about America's wild horses--from their origins to their fight for survival today. With stunning and dramatic prose, Stillman recounts the making of this country and the fighting of our early wars by way of the service of mustangs. This part of the book reaches its height with her masterful chapter about the Battle of the Little Bighorn and Comanche, the famous horse that survived it, and a visit to the horse cemetery on the battlefield. In the last section of her book, Stillman takes a look at what we are doing to the horses that have served us so well, as she follows them in another battle--the one in which they are now fighting for their own lives. We travel with her to Nevada for a heartbreaking round-up and to places across the West where wild horses have been hunted down and shot. She also takes you to where they are still running free, with manes and tails flying in the wind. After reading this beautifully written book, you will look at this country in a completely different way and want to get involved in the preservation of America's wild horses. In fact, you will feel an urgency to do so. By the way, a moving epilogue covers burros, which are protected under the same federal law that protects mustangs, and are also under siege. Book bonus: it has pictures!

Wild horses have become a political football in Congress, with battles between those who want to protect them and those who are all too happy to eradicate them.

Senator Conrad Burns of Montana slipped a rider into a federal appropriations bill in 2004 which ended more than 30 years of federal protection for America's wild horses. Our fearless leader--yes, the one from Texas, of all places!--signed it into law, leading to approval to their slaughter for horse meat to be sold to foreign countries where it is still eaten.

Perhaps Senator Burns and his colleagues from states where the majority of these horses are held and who voted for this bill would think differently if they read this book.

The tragic story of the American wild horse comes to life in Stillman's beautifully written book. She traces the history from being heroes to being considered surplus to requirements.

When you think about the reverence of the horse in American literature and history, that it has come to this--that politicians from states whose fortunes were built on the back of these amazing animals are the ones who voted to destroy them--will make you ashamed to call yourself an American. It's no wonder the rest of the world thinks of us as the creators of the disposable society.

The author is such a gifted writer.

As an eight generation wild west (Montana, California) family horses have been a part of our families life since the 1800's.

The rich history of the horse that the author shares is history at its best. From Europe to Custer in South Dakota, to Wild Horse Annie who is a heroine in our family for her move to get the wild Mustang here in the west protected.

Our family and so many of our families have gotten wild horses thru the BLM Bureau of Land Management which is a Federal agency, since the 1980's.

While the book isn't a perfect history of the horse it is a great book on the subject of the wild horse protection plan.

One of the best treatises on the history and political events surrounding the wild horse of the West. Deanne made this book interesting as well as informative, and I read it through four times. Great book for anyone who loves wild horses and how their plight came to be as it is today.

This is a entertaining and captivating text. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and would recommend. Stillman covers the history of the Mustang from explorer's ships to Wild West gunfights. She seperates myth from fact and remains faithful to the phenomenal story of the mustang. Although some of the stories become long and drawn out while straying from the true theme, they are nonetheless deservedly told.

It's more about the history of the horse and the white man taking dominion of the West than about the mustangs. Entertaining reading and fun information about the horses of the West and the characters that used them. Mustangs, Feral Horses, and Horseman of the West would be a more descriptive title.

The story of the America Mustang is a exemplar of the hypocrisy of the environmental movement. These magnificent animals have been hunted down and eliminated from federally established herd areas specifically designated for their protection. Any reasonable person must ask why.

If there were any more references attached to the the Mustang Saga, Ms. Stillman would have had to write a new book just to cover them. I thought it was extremely well researched and just don't get where this guy is coming from.

A section of this book deals with the reputed sole survivor of Custer's Last Stand, a US cavalry horse called 'Comanche'. While it has long been common knowledge that many US owned horses (and a dog) survived the battle, it was particulary disappointing to read the author recycling the now discredited characterisation of Comanche's owner, Captain Myles Keogh, as being a "drunk". Keogh's fourteen year US military record is untarnished by any charge of drunkenness or dereliction of duty. These records still exist but, unfortunately, Ms. Stillman has taken the lazy route of using information published in a flawed early 20th century book on Custer's 7th Cavalry as her source rather than undertaking any research herself. This did not augur well for the rest of the book and so it proved. A disappointment.