Customer Reviews

The Mutiny on the Bounty

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

It is a shame that customers who cannot spell properly or pay attention to what they are purchasing should under-rate a fabulous book--or a fabulous author and illustrator for that matter--because of their own error. Patrick O'Brien, with an "e", is the author and illustrator of well over a dozen picture books for children. To imply that Patrick O'Brien is not the "real" Patrick O'Brian would be a funny comment if the reviewer then didn't drag down the book's overall rating. Sorry I'm not being very positive here, but I would not like to see a continuation of one person after another claiming how this is not the book they thought it was, when if you read the description, the reviews or any of the criteria that Amazon provides, you will understand completely who this book is intended for.

This beautifully wrought version of the tale of mutiny on the high seas blurs the distinction between picture book and graphic novel, creating a masterpiece of juvenile fiction that will bring drama, history, and adventure to even the most reluctant readers. This book, along with O'Brien's The Great Ships, would be an excellent addition to elementary libraries and classrooms

The mutiny on the ship Bounty, is one of the great adventure stories. The events surrounding the mutiny have inspired a number of great movies and countless books. There is a lot of history in this story. A children's version must include a lot more historical detail than one usually finds in comparable children's books. Patrick O'Brien does a fine job of retelling the story. However, what makes this book special are the illustrations. Naval illustration is one of the more difficult areas of book illustration. It requires a great attention to detail to make these sailing ships come alive. O'Brien is a skilled illustrator and does a first rate job. The Mutiny on the Bounty is a classic story and this book will serve as a wonderful introduction for any child.

Many children probably have not heard of the Mutiny on the Bounty. This picture book by Patrick O'Brien is a wonderful introduction to the infamous tale. The highlight of the book are the beautiful illustrations which accompany the text. The text and illustrations work hard to introduce the relevant background knowledge about sailing so that the reader can fully understand the tale told. O'Brien deserves commendation for his even handed telling of the tale, though the prose can become workman like at times. Overall this a book recommended for readers of nonfiction or children who would like to learn more about the ill fated voyage of the Bounty.

I like to read my sons abridged classic literature. Our ages range all the way down to kindergarten, so it is important to me that the books be beautiful and entertaining, as well as having a dynamite story to keep everyone interested. We have liked "Treasure Island" by Stevenson and N.C.Wyeth, and "Lassie Come-Home" by Eric Knight and Rosemary Wells.

Patrick O'Brien has done a superb job with "Mutiny on the Bounty" - the illustrations, the story, the action and suspense - it is a gripping book.

When I ordered this book, I thought it was the same person who authored the Aubrey/Maturin series -- which I loved. This however is not the same person at all. The book may be an excellent read for children but it is not meant for the adult adventure lovers who read the "real" O'Brian.

This book is not for the adult reader.
The style and the illustrations is definitely
for the young teenager,