"runner-up of season two/second album; Clay has one of the greatest voices! He sounds amazing on this entire disc that is packed with outstanding songs! I don't think he has ever sounded better! Highly recommended!"
"top 12 from season two/ensemble album; This is a very good disc! Every song is terrific, and the vocals match at least ninety percent of the time. Highly recommended for show fans!"
"runner-up of season three/first album; Diana's rich, pure, & powerful voice plus the great songs make this an exceptional album! Everyone (show fan or not) should own this! You won't be disappointed!"
"winner of season one/second album; I LOVE Kelly! She has a great voice and chooses the best songs. Some great songs are "Breakaway", "Since U Been Gone", "You Found Me", and "Behind These Hazel Eyes""
"winner of season four/second album; Carrie is an extraordinary artist with an incredible, beautiful, and powerful voice! Her music is always very fun, addictive, and/or inspirational. This is another great release from her and highly recommended!"
"fourth place of season five/first album; Chris was always one of the absolute best performers and vocalists from his season! He consistently did a terrific job, and his voice is absolutely incredible and breathtaking. Every song on her is very easy to get into and outstanding! I can't wait for more! I highly recommend this to everyone!!!"
"third place of season five/first album; Elliott is phenomenal! He has a great voice, and I love his soulful style. His debut is incredible with only one song that isn't overly great. He's here to stay, and I can't wait for more from him!"
"top 12 from season five/ensemble album; This is one of the best AI compilations. All of the songs sound great - even, surprisingly, "Takin' It To The Streets", which was beyond terrible and impossible to understand on the show. I would've chosen different songs for a few of them, but overall, it's terrific!"
"top 12 from season three/ensemble album; This is overall a great album. Voices are great, even Fantiasa's, which is extremely rare, and "Me & Mrs. Jones" is the one bad song here b/c it's so boring!"
"runner-up of season five/second single; Although not incredibly amazing, both of these songs are highly addictive and good. Her vocals are amazing, as she is one of the best new vocalists on the market! Highly recommended for her fans!"
"winner of season six/first album; Jordin is amazing! Her voice is incredible, and she shines on her debut album! Every song is powerful, beautiful, and amazing. This album should be a part of every collection!"
"runner-up of season five/first album; Katharine is a great artist and performer who should've won in the finale between her and Taylor. She has a beautiful voice, and her debut is great. There is a nice mix of upbeat and slow songs with only one bad song."
"runner-up of season two/first album; Clay is one of the best male vocalists in the music industry today! He sounds amazing on every single song on here, and every song is also excellent and highly addictive. I highly recommend this to everybody!"
"winner of season one/third album; Kelly is an amazing artist with a great, beautiful, and powerful voice. However, this isn't my favorite from her. She sounds great, and the music is great, but it may take a while to get used to the new sound. There is only one song that I don't like."
"runner-up of season five/first single; Katharine's voice is so beautiful! She sounds amazing on these songs, both of which are excellent! Highly recommended for her fans!"
"third place of season two/first album; Kimberley has an incredibly beautiful and powerful voice. She uses that strength here very well on this amazing debut. The songs are all relatable, addictive, and powerful. Highly recommended!"
"sixth place of season six/first album; This is one of the greatest American Idol finalists' debuts! Phil has an amazing voice that is very enjoyable, and he sounds great on every track. The music is a great mix of contemporary country and contemporary Christian music. Highly recommended."
"sixth place of season five/first album; I love Kellie's voice. She has a great strong country voice. Every single song on the entire disc is either fun and upbeat or slower and inspirational! Even people that didn't like her on AI like or even love this disc! Highly recommended!"
"winner of season four/first album; I LOVE Carrie! She has one of the purest and most wholesome voices in the market today! She is one of the two best winners ever & a terrific role model for everyone!"
"ninth place of season five/first album; Mandisa is a brilliant artist that should've gone further. Her voice is extremely beautiful and powerful, and every single song on this album is powerful and uplifting. She's another great role model!"
"winner of season one/first album; Again, I LOVE Kelly! I never saw the show but heard a couple songs. She rocks!! Great songs are "Trouble With Love Is", "Miss Independent", "Low", "Anytime", & more"
"top 12 from season four/ensemble album; the first season I've seen any of. My favorite is Carrie, then Vonzell, Jessica, and Anthony. Most of the songs are great, except Mikalah's (voice) & 2 others"
"fourth place of season two/second album; This is absolutely one of the greatest albums released!!! Josh is an amazing artist with an incredible voice and talent. Every song is amazing - fun, uplifting, relatable, etc. Highly recommended! Everyone should have this!!"
