Customer Reviews

My Country, My Country

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Given more recent events in Iraq, this wonderful documentary is already somewhat dated, made as it was during the months leading up to the first democratic elections in that country, but it marks an important moment in history as well and deserves a viewing for that reason alone. The central figure, a medical doctor in a Baghdad neighborhood, Dr. Ryadh is a member of a Sunni party, running for election to the country's new parliament. Tenacious in his commitment to his community, he is pulled in many directions by the needs of his patients, his prospective constituents, his friends and family. His story is played out against a background of continuing gunfire and explosions and an unending stream of complaints from those who have lost faith in the American presence and hope for the future. In one sequence a colleague's son is kidnapped for ransom by insurgents, and we watch as the father despairs of ever seeing him alive again.

Meanwhile, cameras visit other parts of the country, including Kurdistan, where anti-Sunni and pro-American opinion prevail. We also follow the months of behind-the-scenes preparation for elections and the precautions taken by contracted security firms, with commentary by international election observers. Branded by some as a "show" for the benefit of the White House and boycotted by Dr. Ryadh's own Sunni party, the election draws long lines of voters anyway, and we watch with appropriate amazement the risks voters take to participate in a process that is taken so lightly in the West. Assembled in a way more akin than most documentaries to the ideals of cinema verite, the film has no narration and leaves it to the audience to interpret much of what it is viewing. A fine and important work.

"My Country, My Country" is an opportunity to see Iraq through the life of an Iraqi doctor and his family. The camera perspective is personal and I felt as though I was right there with Dr. Riyadh. The airborne scenes and the country vistas complimented the intimate nature of the coverage of the people involved.

The consequences of the American occupation of Iraq are complex. The politics are complex. I didn't feel imposed upon by some moral message, but rather felt I had a chance to see the depth and interrelationship of viewpoints that allowed me to think for myself. This movie did not clear a lot up for me, but rather gave me a sense of familiarity with the people - a chance to see them as real people and not abstractions. I felt empowered by a far more unprocessed opportunity to gather information for thought.

I wholeheartedly recommend seeing "My Country, My Country" to people whose understanding of "Iraq" comes from nightly news reports or newspaper articles. I believe this documentary is an outstanding way to learn more about the circumstances of recent Iraqi history.

'hearts and minds', then you would know that after we lost the vietnam war, lost so many american soldiers there, the lesson never was learned by those who run our government, president or politicians on the hills. because these people never lost a son or a daughter in a self-righteous and self-serving war. a country full of one kind of people blinded by the 'patriotism' big word, but never understood those invasions and wars got nothing to do with 'patriotism' at all. we invaded other peoples' countries, destroyed their homes, killed their people by first using the excuse of 'fighting the communism' in vietnam, now we just change one word of such slogan, 'fighting the terrorism' to invade iraq. i just don't know who gave us the right to meddle other peoples countries and their lives under the big word of 'patriotism'. what patriotism got anything to do with this godforsaken unjustifiable wars. we ruined their lives but still shamelessly claiming that we're helping them, we're liberating them. we're repeatedly making the same mistakes and tragedies again and again to other peoples and to ourselves. that's why the peoples in other countries when they fought or fignt against us never changed their unique slogan : 'fighting the american imperialism'. and imperialism equals another word in their eyes: 'colonization'.
so far, we americans were blinded by the ridiculous patriotism custom tailored by the corporate friendly government, gave you a false belief that invasion of iraq was justified and the majority iraqi people were so grateful and appreciated what we did to them, by watching this my country, my country, we knew that country is not your country, it's other peoples' country and we absolutely have no right to interfere their own problems. if you are not convinced enough, then you must watch the oscar nominated 'iraq in fragments', to see how the general iraqi people really feel about our 'war on terror(ism)', it'd give you clearer picture what we did to iraq and the irqi people.
why we could never learn?

It is sad, especially if you have lived in Iraq years ago, in the "good old days". What we see in this documentary is what's left over from old Iraq. I used to compare Baghdad (before 1990) with Chicago or any other major city here in the US. Iraqis, especially the Baghdadis are not less than any other Americans, high quality life and way of thinking. They enjoyed rights and benefits we dream to enjoy here in the US; women enjoyed most of these rights and they were one of the happiest nations, I witnessed. What I saw in this film is what we and our foreign strategies created in this beautiful country. We uprooted this country from all its beauty and historical authenticity and genuineness by the name of democracy. Yes, I recommend this movie, but please look beyond the spoken words.

Laura Poitras is a very brave lady that has put together a very intimate and brilliant documentary of post invasion Iraq. This doco follows the daily activities of a local Dr. Riyadh and his family leading upto the local elections. The personal struggle of this man together with his frustrations and his hopes and dreams for his family and country are very beautifully depicted and most people would be able to empathize with. The total chaos that reigns in the background is very hard to not miss. Personally I found the portrayal of the whole situation on the ground in Iraq to be very disturbing. I can only imagine what it is like for the average Iraqi, allied troops, UN mediators, contractors and diplomats etc who have to deal with this horror on a day to day basis. Even today many months after the actual events of this doco I fear the situation is no better and if anything maybe somewhat worse. I thoroughly recommend this to any viewers interested in the current events of the region. It is a fair portrayal of the country and history without any political bias. Five stars from me!

I just saw this movie, and yes, I am a little late. But overall, I wasn't impressed. I feel like I've heard all this before and the movie didn't add much to my knowledge about the difficulties of living in Iraq post war. Of course life is hard there and people are being killed. One scene shows women talking about the Americans shooting outside of the mosque and coming into the women's prayer area. I feel their pain as I watch, but overall I found the movie to be a bit disjointed. You get brief scenes of American military making plans for the election process, scenes of UN election supervisors, and you follow a doctor/candidate throughout his country. There is no narration. The movie just keeps flipping from one scene to another. If a person doesn't know much about the war or war's effects on people, perhaps this is worthwhile. For me, it didn't add to my knowledge of the true face of the war.