First off, I will say that I bought this last year on clearance and saved it to use this year. As such, perhaps our expectations just aren't as high (since I did pay full retail)? I didn't expect a pony each day, so the sticker sheet days didn't disappoint us at all.
Anyway, here's what we got:
Day 1: Visible through the clear window, a Pinkie Pie Ponyville Pony
Day 2: A set of hot pink mary-jane style shoes for Pinkie Pie and a small plastic present box (that does fit the shoes, with removable lid). The shoes were just a bit challenging to get on, but have stayed on since even through play.
Day 3: A sticker sheet with about a dozen small/tiny stickers; ornaments, candy canes, stars, and holly. My daughter decorated Day 2's present box, a punch out Christmas tree and ornament from the back of the box.
Day 4: More stickers. This time 3 long strips of bulb lights to decorate the punch out tree. A little challenging since the stickers are long/skinny and 1 tore when my 3.5yo tried to peel it off herself, also would have made more sense for these to come before the ornament stickers since they're bigger and need more room on the little cardboard tree from the box.
Day 5: A little fabric stocking for the ponies
Day 6: 2 tiny plastic lollipops (1 pink, 1 teal)
Day 7: Another Ponyville Pony (actually, a unicorn this time), Sweetie Belle.
Day 8: A small plastic 'package' (w/ sticker mailing label) and a small sheet of 6 cardboard 'letters' to punch out
Day 9: A pair of white plastic wings for the ponies
Day 10: A purple plastic 'skirt' for the ponies
Day 11: 2 pink perfume atomizers and a tiny basket
Day 12: A pink & white striped pony hat
Day 13: A tiny white bird
Day 14: A tiny pink punch set, complete with punch bowl, ladle, and 2 cups
Day 15: 2 slices of cake on plates
Day 16: 2 cocoa mugs topped w/ whipped cream and a tiny tray (hard to use w/ mugs though)
Day 17: A pink plastic present box w/ cookies inside (permanently, formed on the bottom of the box)
Day 18: A pink plastic camera
Day 19: 2 tiny picture frames w/ pony pic stickers
Day 20: 2 tiny pony necklaces (1 white w/ a heart, 1 pink w/ a flower) and a ??? (it's a larger dark pink flower w/ a heart drop, and a 'post' in the back; not sure where it's intended to attach?)
Day 21: A small santa hat for a ponyville pony
Day 22: A set of shoes (4) to match the santa hat; red w/ white trim
Day 23: A little plastic carton of milk, a pink plastic 'glass,' and a little green plastic plate with 3 heart-shaped cookies permanently affixed
Day 24: Another Ponyville Pony - Minty this time!
I will continue to update til we've made it through the whole calendar, but so far we're happy with what we're getting (especially for what we paid).
Alright, done now and still happy! Between my girls we did this one and a LPS advent, and I have to say I think this one was nicer - less cardboard, more plastic (not that plastic's the mark of quality, but it'll hold up to play better than the cardboard of some of the LPS pieces). This one also had more 'sets' like the milk/glass/cookies and the punchbowl/ladle/cups. But, for the clearance price we got them for last year, I'm pretty happy with both of them!