5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awful Title, Great Book, June 27, 2007
This review is from: My Mother the Cheerleader (Hardcover)
"My Mother the Cheerleader" has what may be the worst title I've seen in a long while. It made me anticipate a high-school "romp" about sports or perhaps some sort of "Freaky Friday" role reversal between a mother and her child. Instead, "Cheerleader" is a thoughtful, wonderfully evocative memoir of growing up during the early years of school integration (the term "cheerleader" was coined by John Steinbeck to describe the screaming mothers protesting integration in New Orleans). It's a deft, subtle, funny, very moving book I'd recommend to everyone.
True, "My Mother the Cheerleader" is ostensibly a book written for young adults, in that it contains no graphic sex, no obscenities, and its 13 year old narrator is intended to draw us into a child's eye view of the world. But it's a book filled with very serious issues (racism, violence, alcoholism and abandonment) and rewards readers of all ages. Its portrait of New Orleans' Ninth Ward in the early 1960s is dead on, and the observations of its central character are precocious, but never unbelievable. What a wonderful, thought provoking book! Every time I thought, no, the author's gone too far, he won't be able to pull this off, Mr. Sharenow continued to amaze me. A look at recent history that will move and inform everyone. I highly recommend it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Teacher View, February 20, 2009
Some people mentioned not liking the title or that this is a "great book" but bad title. The title is very creative and really tells the point of view from which the book was written. I just wanted to set the record straight.
I recently read this book with my students, who will be submitting reviews as well. When I read this book, I knew I was interested in the issues of racial equality and the civil rights movement. I knew I wanted to address the many perspectives racism can be viewed from. I like the awareness for one young girl this book presents.
I do have to admit it took me a bit to get into the book. This isn't a cover to cover page turner. I really do like the character of Louise Collins. She is very real and I can picture her personality. There were some moments, though, I asked myself when I will get to the real good stuff.
Some of the details were a little "frilly" but in the end they help paint the picture of just how hypocritical the idea of "cheerleaders" are. One element to dig into is why these women were called cheerleaders in the first place. There is a lot of satire and irony at play. When teaching this book, it is necessary to point this out. I would have liked to read it together as a class and discuss the intended message in any given statement, since people experience this everyday.
I really liked having a chance to mimic and dramatize the mother's voice. I could tell it helped my students understand the culture of the south as well. I do wonder if anyone from the south would be offended by this portrayal, but I see it as a very true description of what I would imagine an OUTWARDLY fake, self-centered, drama queen, afraid to get old, would be like. After finding a certain detail, I couldn't help but feel sorry for this woman, who doesn't know what to believe, drowns her misery in men and spirits, and is a very alone soul.
The ending made me about want to cry and shout at the same time. It is so sad, but so true of our world and of this particular event.
To follow up with this book, using it in a class, I am showing Ruby Bridges and Jasper, Texas. These go well to help show the twisted circular oppressive nature or racism (that still exists today).
I normally don't like happy endings, but I wanted one in this book. I guess I wanted to show people aren't as evil as they seem. I want someone to have an epiphany, but I guess if that would have happened, Jasper, Texas wouldn't have happened.
Would I recommend this book? Yes, but with a lot of discussion and information about Civil Rights, the South, and the issue of Racism. Also, you must watch Ruby Bridges. The idea of what the cheerleaders does come to life. How sad.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
excellent read for teachers AND students, December 11, 2009
I was 10 years old in 1960 when this book was set. I grew up in Michigan so I wasn't aware of what was going on in New Orleans at the time. (I'm sure my parents were very aware.) I don't know why, throughout all my years of education, that I didn't learn about the cheerleaders, those mothers who yelled racist hate language to children trying to integrate 9th Ward New Orleans schools. Since reading this book and reading the chapter in Steinbeck's Travels With Charley about them, I've come to further believe that we cannot overlook the importance of studying racism and the effects it has on everyone. The main character, a 13 year old, comments that a lot of folks in her neighborhood just didn't think about segregation. It just was the way things were. Many characters in the book felt that integration was being forced on them by outsiders...not by the folks that lived in the 9th Ward. Other characters feld that the 9th Ward was nothing to write home about and that politicians probably felt that the parents wouldn't protest the forced integration being that they were living in a poverty area. I mentioned all this to my current day students in Michigan and they just don't understand/appreciate how federal, state, and local laws promoted racial hatred. Many of my students don't know who Ruby Bridges is. I will be teaching this book in January 2010. I was glad that the author included the titles of the songs so I can play the music when it is mentioned in the chapters. I'm glad he also mentioned streets so I can show them mapquest (I haven't tried GoogleEarth). There is a rape scene in the book that shows just how entitled adult bullies feel and how the police did nothing to prevent the KKK from creating Hell on Earth. Good mixture of issues: racial hatred, antisemitism, integration, segregation. This would make an interesting read aloud. Would be writing activity to create a readers theatre script. Sad and thought provoking book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No