Most Helpful Customer Reviews
40 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Well, I liked it!!!, May 31, 2010
I'm mainly writing this review in opposition to the 1 and 2 star reviews. For me, 1 and 2 star reviews belong to poorly-written novels and this was anything but. If you've read any of the reviews before this, you know that the heroine is not quite upstanding and honest with the hero, and the other reviewers can't seem to get past this. Well, personally, I have read worse. In the hands of a less-skilled author, I may have not been able to continue reading either. However, Anna Campbell has a way of making the unpalatable, digestible. I remember all the negative reviews about her first book, "Claiming the Courtesan" -- and I'll say the same thing that I said then in my review: the author is not asking the reader to condone the behaviors she writes about, but she is asking the reader to take in the entirety of the characters with all their flaws and see the consequences in their own lives and in the lives of the other characters in the novel.
Now, after reading all of Ms. Campbell's books, I'm starting to realize how much is written from the hero's point of view and how much she gets into the man's psyche (not unlike Mary Jo Putney). In all of her novels, her heroes fall quite hard and I almost feel sorry for them as they are left almost devasted by their love for the heroine. Such is the case with Diana and Tarquin. We go from meeting a man who, at the beginning of the book, is as hard and cold as marble to someone who at the end, puts their last shred of pride on the line for the woman he loves. I am always fascinated with stories and authors who manage to do this convincingly. Where, I think, Ms. Campbell could have spent a bit more time was in explaining how and why Diana came to love the property so much that she was driven to the lengths she sunk to become mistress of it; but, I know the hero understood "...he could never condone her actions, but he understood why she'd done what she had...she'd filled the wintry landscape of her widowhood with love for the house..."
Like all her novels, this one is a bit dark and angsty-- which is just how I like my romances! There's sex, but I felt that it moved the story along and was not just dropped in there to titillate the reader. It wasn't that there were so many scenes, just that the sexual encounters were somewhat marathon-like. But, given the goals and schemes of our heroine, they fit the novel.
Like most of Anna Campbell's novels, this is a "skate at your own risk" romance, but I, for one, am glad I took the chance. I read this is almost one sitting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I would have given three cheers if hero had ditched heroine!, June 5, 2010
This review is from: My Reckless Surrender (Mass Market Paperback)
I have loved Anna Cambell's books so far, but this one made me cringe with horror as the so called heroine was one of the most selfish, calculating, indifferent women Anna has come up with.I can say in all honesty that I despised her and would have felt relieved and vindicated if our hero abandoned her as would have been the case in an even remotely realistic story. Admittedly, we do not read romance for realism, that is why I require the main characters to be honourable, to have principles and be unwavering in their loyalty. Diana is a one dimentional character, selfishly seeking to ensure ownership of an estate through selling herself and perjuring. Is there anything admirable in that? As I will go into some details in an attempt to explain my objections, be warned that parts of the story will be revealed.
Diana brazenly asks Lord Ashcroft to have an affair with her as she claims to be interested in experiencing carnal delights, deprived to her since her husband's death eight years earlier. Lord Ashcroft is reluctant as he senses that the woman is concealing something from him but unable to resist her sexual charms, he capitulates to what proves to be an earthshattering experience for both of them. Diana has heard rumours that his Lordsahip is an incorrigible rake, susceptible to any petticoat with ample charms. She wants to become mistress of the estate she has lived on and cared for all her life on condition she give birth to Lord Ashcroft's child. Knowing him to be such a degenerate scoundrel, Diana presumes she'll have no problem bedding him and realizing her dream. Let's take a minute to consider her actions, even if we assume that Tarquin Vale (our hero's name) is indeed a scoundrel. Where are Diana's principles? Assuming that one person is immoral does in no way excuse our own immoral acts against him. Tarquin takes precautions against pregnancy but this scheming woman by lying through her teeth and persuading him she can't conceive, or is using her own means of contraception, traps him into having free sex. I found this unsavoury and disturbing. To make matters worse, even when Diana realizes that the man she has grown to love is not only honourable and sensitive but caring and deeply loving, she still persists with her despicable charade which was orchestrated by Lord Burnley, Tarquin's adversary and a heinous, heartless, reptilian character. Bear in mind that Diana was not in need, neither was there an exonerating motive for her to act as she did, other than greed, that is.
Diana does indeed suffer from a "guilty" conscience and "remorse" but when she perseveres on her course knowing full well that she will cause Tarquin unbearable pain with her treachery, then all this is an unconvincing, paltry excuse for the reader not to feel utter contempt for her. It failed in my case as that is exactly what I felt. It was irritating indeed, to be constantly reading about her flagellating conscience. She loved him! Sopme distorted, twisted notion of love! Particularly so, when Tarquin confided details of his life that would have had a real woman falling to his feet and asking for forgiveness and not plunging the knife deeper into an already open wound.
I do not want to reveal more, but I like being honest with my reviews and this is no exception. Though I love Anna's writing I hope she will spare us such heroines who deserve nether love nor devotion and who make the hero resort to groveling humiliation. Reality is full of greedy, grasping cheats so I prefer the fairytale to have heroes bigger than life, "worth dying for" who uphold their principles and values and who live in honour. That's the reason why I read romance, for the fairy tale and the improbable. Diana was so unworthy, so undeserving so undistinguished! Why?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sex, secrets and lies, lust to love, guilt and forgiveness. Oh, and did I mention sex?, May 25, 2010
This review is from: My Reckless Surrender (Mass Market Paperback)
(3 and a half stars but I'm rounding up for the good writing.) Yes, there's lots of sex in this and at first I felt it was gratuitous. Okay, maybe there is a bit more than necessary for development of the story, but at least it's done well so that you see the lust and rabbit sex developing into real, true love and it's not cold, clinical (and yet rather vulgar) sex like in Lisa Valdez's PATIENCE, for example. Premise of the story seems familiar to me, like a meld of a few books I've read in the past: A young widow (Diana Warrick) chooses a complete stranger to have an affair with, propositioning him by telling him she wants more sexual experience. Her goal (unbeknownst to him) is to get pregnant. Her pregnancy is a requirement for marriage to an aging, dying marquess, with the ultimate goal of becoming custodian of Cranston Abbey, where she lives with her father as the marquess' baliff. Tarquin Vale, Earl of Ashcroft, said to be a degenerate, jaded rake, has been chosen as her sexual partner, but it is not a random choice. That's all that can be said about that without spoilers.
Our H and H in this Campbell creation are not as tortured souls as in CAPTIVE OF SIN, her most recent previous romance, although you do have some minimal angst caused by childhood loneliness and family relationship problems. The back story of the two is revealed slowly, after Campbell has her readers hooked on (or turned off by, depending on the reader) the almost nonstop sex. Both H and H are interesting, complex characters and they need to be because they alone carry the story for most of the book. He, in addition, turns out to be likeable, unexpectedly principled, loving, generous and compassionate. She is a bit more of a puzzle, coming off a bit mercenary, opportunistic, closed off emotionally, although she does feel tremendous guilt about what she is doing. I was left feeling that her motivations for her actions should not have been strong enough for her to continue along that path for most of the book and found myself not liking her very much. Not so our hero. He has love strong enough and forgiving enough that he makes the book for me. There are some heartwrenching moments in this. Our hero and the author's writing make up for the undeserving heroine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
