From School Library Journal
Grade 6-9-Pete and his friends on Michigan's Mackinac Island find themselves fascinated by the legends and rumors about an old lighthouse on nearby Round Island and about its former keeper, who may or may not still be a presence there. Intrigued, the four teens pack a lunch, borrow a dinghy, ride over, and explore-and then find their belongings scattered and a note telling them to go away. Instead of being scared off, they decide to find out what is going on and, in so doing, become involved in a dangerous robbery plot. Readers who are unfamiliar with the area will probably miss some of the subtleties, but will still be able to follow the rather simplistic story line. Written in the style of a Hardy Boys mystery, the plot moves forward at an even pace; at the end, the ghost of the lighthouse keeper intervenes to help save the teens from a fire set by the thieves, a device that seems contrived. None of the characters is particularly well developed, and the author seems to assume that readers are familiar with them from previous books. Sketches of island landmarks decorate chapter openings. Not a first purchase, but an adequate mystery that might have regional interest.
Janet Hilbun, formerly at Sam Houston Middle School, Garland, TX Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Action, humor, and suspense--plus some Michigan geography make these books good choices for summer reading." --
Esther Littmann, Book Beat--Observer-Eccentric"Enthusiastically recommended reading for ages 10 to 14 who would enjoy a well crafted mystery adventure novel!" --
Midwest Book Reveiw, Children's Bookwatch, Feb. 2002Our son absolutely loves your books. He owns every one and lends them to all his pals. --
Mother of Reader, 13 years oldYoung readers will enjoy this. Action, humor, and suspense--plus some Michigan geography make these good choices for summer reading." --
Book Beat-Observer-Eccentric