Customer Reviews

The Mystery of the Third Lucretia (Kari + Lucas Mystery)

5 star:		(21)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

If you're looking for a new book series to love, try this one! Mystery of the Third Lucretia stars Kari and Lucas, two funny, smart 14-year-old girls. They see a creepy guy up to no good in an art museum; and when they try to figure out what he's doing, lots of trouble starts. It's a really funny book -- I laughed on almost every page -- and really good action, with cliffhangers at the end of every chapter, so it's hard to put down. And there's interesting stories about art and travel, especially about Lucretia, the woman in the painting that started it all. My favorite part, though, is Kari and Lucas, and Kari's Mom Gillian. They're really funny and interesting and seem like people you know in real life - like a best friend. By the end of the book, you can't wait to read about what they do next. Definitely read this book!

After reading a glowing review of The Mystery of the Third Lucretia, I knew I wanted to read it. When it came in for me at the library, I first read the author's biography, which begins "Susan Runholt shares a love of art, travel and feminism with her teenage heroines." I would add reading to the list, but I'm proud to share the other three with Ms. Runholt, Lucas and Kari.

The Mystery of the Third Lucretia is the first (of many, I hope) Kari and Lucas mysteries. Kari and Lucas are best friends who live in St. Paul, Minnesota (a town I also happen to love). Kari's mom has one of the coolest jobs ever: she covers fashion and international culture for a teen magazine (if such a job exists, I would gladly apply for it.) Kari, who sees her father a few times a year, and Lucas, whose parents are eager to spend money for her to experience culture, often get to go along for the ride. The book takes place in St. Paul, London, Paris, and Amsterdam. The girls happen to find themselves trying to solve an international art mystery.

I cannot say enough positive things about this novel. I wish it existed when I was younger, but I still loved it as an adult. I laughed out loud often, learned things (in a delightfully unpreachy way) and eagerly awaited the mystery being solved. Kari and Lucas are both real girls and inspiring to women (and men) of all ages. I am eagerly awaiting my turn to read the second Kari and Lucas mystery, Rescuing Seneca Crane, which came out in August 2009. I wish I knew more young women so I could give this book to them; I know it would have meant the world to me as a younger woman. Happy reading, feminists, art lovers and mystery fans of all ages!

Kari's mother works for a magazine that sends her to Europe at least once a year to write stories. Usually, they manage to bring along Kari's best friend, Lucas. Together the girls sometimes play tourist while Kari's mother works. Occasionally, they help her with her articles.

One trip to London proves to become a very different sort of trip than any of them imagined. While at the National Gallery, Kari and Lucas see an artist working near a Rembrandt painting of Lucretia. Before long, they become certain that they've seen this man before, only looking completely different.

They saw him in the art museum near their home, also next to the other Rembrandt Lucretia. The man's covering up his easel so no one can see his work. He also has a distinctive growl when anyone gets too close.

Kari and Lucas devise a plan to spy on the man, while changing their own appearances. In doing so, in order to understand what he's painting, they paint the objects they uncover by carefully sneaking glances at his work.

During their next trip to Europe, they hear about a discovery of a never-before-seen third Rembrandt painting from the Lucretia series. Kari and Lucas begin to add up the clues and discover that this painting is not an original work, but who would believe them and what evidence do they have for proof?

The first book in a series written in the first-person conveys the narrator's uncertainty about how to tell the story - there are many different possible beginnings, but Kari's voice rings true. While the reader can grasp the exact mystery from the beginning, they have fun solving the how and the why along with Kari and Lucas.

Reviewed by: Jennifer Rummel

The Mystery of the Third Lucretia is one of those books readers of all ages and genders want: a story that will immerse you in character and the world that lie within the pages. It's the first in a new series by a new writer, and I was totally blown away by how well Susan Runholt created her teen sleuths and plunged them into an art-based mystery while keeping the suspense tight and the chuckles at regular intervals.

Officially, the Kari + Lucas series are for the YA crowd, I'm thinking more for the aggressive 9-12 year old readers. The serious YA crowd is looking for vampires, brand names, and sexual tension. You won't find those things in this book. Instead, there's a great story, teens that are of this generation that stay focused on friendships, exploring their world, and the mystery they've inadvertently stumbled onto.

I love the two characters. Kari (our narrator) is a down-to-earth fourteen year old who enjoys the simple side of life and lives with her single mom, a magazine writer. Lucas (took me a while to get used to that name on a girl) is the daughter of rich, inattentive parents. Lucas is also the feisty one ready to dare anything while Kari likes at least a moment to weigh the risks before her curiosity and Lucas drag her into anything.

The plot revolving around Rembrandt's two Lucretia paintings was awesome too. I wasn't familiar with them and I liked discovering the sad story that were behind them. Runholt does a lot with the Lucretia story, sticking up for women's rights, but she does it without throwing it into the reader's face.

I had my willing suspension of disbelief bumped a few times with how events turned out. The fact that Kari and Lucas arrived at two different museums and saw the same guy there (in disguise) copying Rembrandt paintings was hard to take, but Runholt's story is so good you want to believe it and do. Then you get immediately swept up in the puzzle of why Gallery Guy (the girls' nickname for him) is copying the paintings.

Although the plot is relatively simple, the progression of the mystery is well done. Runholt incorporates a lot of the surroundings of London and Amsterdam, and it's obvious the author has spent considerable time in those places. Kari and Lucas have to act to pursue the mystery rather than just hanging around waiting for it to unravel itself.

One of the most charming things about the novel is Kari's first-person narrative. The words read so easily, and Kari's thinking and attitude come alive on the page. Runholt has a second mystery in the series coming out, Rescuing Seneca Crane, and has more coming. School librarians and parents wanting non-threatening kid-lit for mystery lovers would do well to pick up this series.

I've been a voracious reader since I was a little girl. I never leave the house without a book & it's a great big crisis if I finish my book before I have to do something like ride BART. I like a lot of the same kinds of books now that I did when I was kid - fantasy, fairy tales, & mysteries.

One of the hardest things when I was growing up was finding books with strong heroines. I can count the number of books that fit that bill for me on one hand: Harriet the Spy, From the Mixed-up Files of Mrs Basil E. Frankweiler, The Egypt Game, most anything by Judy Blume. It just seemed like girls never got to have big scary adventures that were also well-written & relevant. It sucked.

I was really pleased to get a review copy of The Mystery of the Third Lucretia. This was a really fun read & it featured not one, not two, but three heroines (two teen-aged girls & their Mom). That it combines art history (reminding me of From the Mixed-up Files of Mrs Basil E. Frankweiler) & foreign travel & mysterious adventures & is very well-written made me very very happy.

This is a really fun book & a great read for anyone! I pretty much loved it! Get it for the little girls & boys (11 & up) in your life - they'll love it, too & should have a shot at reading something other than Harry Potter!

[...]

This book is about two 14 year old girls who are best friends, Kari Sundgren and Lucas Stickney. It starts off with the girls at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts Museum and they first notice a man with an easel painting a Rembrandt painting. Kari being the curious one leans in for a closer look and the man shouts go away. His actions frighten her and intrigue her at the same time. His nickname becomes Gallery Guy.
Kari's mother is a reporter for The Scene and the girls get to accompany her to London and to Amsterdam. While they are in London, they spot the same man who was in the museum in the states and once again shouts go away. Lucas has a photographic memory and she is an excellent painter and by making multiple trips to spy on gallery guy in disguise, she is able to reproduce what he is painting. With the help of Kari's mother they find out the identity of the gallery guy and are able to form more pieces of the puzzle together.
Once the trio arrives in Amsterdam, they discover in the newspaper, that a lost Rembrandt painting that has never been seen before shows up here. The girls start to wonder if something illegal is going on her. Once again with Kari's mother's extensive investigation expertise, they finally track the true identity of the Gallery Guy. His name is Jacob Hannekroot. The deeper they dig for proof of this being an illegal scheme and find out the Third Lucretia is a fake, the more they get into trouble. Kari's mother catches them red handed in an area of town that they are clearly not supposed to be in. The girls are grounded at the hotel and the mother has Tony, one of the hotel staff bringing the girls sandwiches and keeping an eye on them.
Jacob finds out that the girls are on to him and kidnap Kari's mother and Lucas. In the end, Kari figures out where he is keeping them and enlists Tony for help. An article ran in the local Sunday paper praising the girls on their findings and showing that the Third Lucretia is a fake. The girls get their fifteen minutes of fame and return to the states. I thought this was a very cute book, even though the reading audience is geared for pre-teens ten to fourteen years old. It was a very quick read and reminded me of the Nancy Drew Mysteries I used to read when I was younger.

This book was so fun to read, I just couldn't put it down. "Just one more PAGE," I kept saying to my husband. The Mystery of the Third Lucretia is the story of two fourteen year old girls who see a strange man copying a Rembrandt painting in the art museum near their home. Then they see the same man in London copying another of Rembrandt's works. The just know something fishy is going on and they make it their mission to uncover The Mystery of the Third Lucretia.

Susan Runholt has done a superb job of mixing together travel, art history, culture and women's rights into a novel that I would be happy to read to any child for bed time. She includes a few risque topics like the dangerous part of Amsterdam, but she explains the thing that go on there in a way that informs and educates children with out giving them too much information. Also, quietly tucked into the novel is a genius part about anger,

" She calls anger a "covering emotion." She says that almost all the time when people get angry they think they're just mad, but mostly, with out knowing they're doing it, they're covering up another feeling, like fear or hurt or guilt or grief. "


Additionally, I applaud Runholt for such a dedicated use of tone and diction throughout the story. The voice of the narrator, fourteen year old Kari, sounds the way a fourteen year old should sound. There is a youth and a innocence to the way the story is told. It is also evident that Runholt is a big advocate for women and the power that they can have. The women of this novel are up front and center, each with their own strengths and weaknesses which help to strengthen the whole.

I would recommend this book for any child or parent but especially little girls and women, since Girl Power is a central theme. I read another review that said this would be a great mother daughter book club choice, I fully agree!

Two smart and spunky girl heroes, disguises, international travel, art history, and a compelling mystery to solve - what's not to love? As one who craves chances to get lost in adventures and learn along the way, I found this a fun and fabulous read. I heartily recommend it, especially to girls who love to read! Kari and Lucas enter the world of intrigue through the story of Rembrandt's Lucretia paintings, and it's wicked good fun from there, as their adventures take them from Minneapolis to London, Paris, and Amsterdam. They keep their cool as they race from art galleries to the mean streets of Amsterdam's red-light district, to find their quarry and solve "The Mystery of the Third Lucretia." Better still, for those of us who hate to let go of fun characters, there's more to come in "Rescuing Seneca Crane," sure to be on my 2009 summer reading list!

This book has everything I love, and then some -- likeable characters and a suspenseful story, with lots of adventure and international travel built in for good measure. Kari and Lucas may turn out to be for today's girls what the Hardy Boys used to be for boys -- brave, clever sleuths who are easy to identify with, and a perfect compliment to one another, too, Kari with her strong intuition and Lucas with her quick brilliance. I love discovering a new series and that's what this promises to be. Ms. Runholt (the author) clearly believes in "grrrl power," and she obviously loves art and travel; and she conveys these passions in a way that helps you love them, too. I laughed out loud, I learned some interesting things about art, and in the end I cheered for Kari and Lucas. This is a really fun book, with more titles to look forward to!

"This is the story of how two teenagers from Minnesota lived a tale of adventure involving a woman from ancient Rome, a seventeenth-century painter, forgery and murder, abduction and rescue, disguises and deductions, two continents, three museums, four countries, a criminal hideaway, and two nuns from Amsterdam's famous Quarter."
-The Mystery of the Third Lucretia by Susan Runholt

I was intrigued by this book from the start. Books with museums, child detectives, art fraud and adventures have always come through for me, ever since I stumbled upon E.L. Konigsburg's The Mixed-up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler.

I don't want to reveal too much about this book and think that the passage above tells you everything that you need to know. If it intrigues you, then I recommend that you get yourself a copy of The Mystery of the Third Lucretia. I'll limit myself to two sentences. The writing, characters, and adventure will not disappoint. I promise. That's it.

If you're not drawn to the book, then it's likely not a fit. No worries - there will be plenty of other books for you and plenty of readers for these Kari + Lucas mysteries. I hadn't mentioned that The Mystery of the Third Lucretia is the first in a series, but it is! I love series books because I can get invested in the characters knowing that even if the book ends the adventures don't. The second of the series came out on August 20, 2009. The third is still in the works.