3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An intellectual analysis of the essence of Mysticism, March 7, 2005
Scharfstein is a writer and teacher in philosophy who has written one of the most informative and interesting books in philosophy that I know, his book on the lives of the great philosophers. In this work he admits to being no mystic examines accounts from a wide variety of traditions and comes up with eleven characteristics of Mysticism. As I am no mystic myself I have difficulty judging the validity of what he has done. I can say that this work is filled with insightful remarks.
The eleven quintessences of the mystical state as Scharfstein defines and calls them are :" sameness; separation; uniqueness;inclusion;familar strangeness;depletion;aggression; conscience; mirror-rversal; humor; Reality, as the critical characteristic is put last. To a mystic, it may seem to be the only one worth emphasizing, but he inclined , after all , to dismiss many of the more interesting features of his experience, his own no less than ours."
I suggest the reader make an effort to understand each of these quintessences, something I did not really manage.
Despite Scharfstein 's rigor in analysis, I still am mystified about mysticism- perhaps indicating that in this realm of experience as with so many others if one has not experienced it for oneself one simply cannot really understand it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No