Customer Reviews

The Myth of Pope Joan

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

It is a joy to see this finely researched volume on a topic of such mythic proportions. I have read several other books on the topic, but it is difficult to find writers who are interested in historical reality when it comes to Pope Joan. As a Roman Catholic theologian concerned with the all-male prerogative regarding clerical service and power, I would be thrilled if there were some credible evidence for this event. Alas, none can be found.

Still, many (Romans and reformers alike) believed it factual. For them it gained credence from ritual and iconic evidence such as the birthing chairs used in pontifical ceremony that were supposedly necessary because a testicular examination had to be made of newly-elected popes after the fraud perpetrated by "la popessa."

Yet, Boureau doesn't seem interested only in writing an authentic history of the legend. He seeks to get behind that legend. So he looks closely at the relationship between the increasingly imperial-minded papacy of the Middle Ages and the psychological and personal rift that developed between the Bishop of Rome and his flock.

Detailed and exact, this fascinating book will assist its readers in understanding the possible source for this persistent myth. Like all myths, it lacks historical accuracy but it is full of truthful insights about sacramental power, the nature of Christian service, ecclesiastical authority and the persistent prevalence of patriarchalism. Because of its beautiful attention to detail, it is a weighty volume and may be difficult for those who are just delving into ecclesiastical history. But for those who enjoy swimming in this particular Tiber, it will be rewarding and enjoyable.

This is not the book you want to read if you are looking for a quick or easy read. It is thoroughly researched and and reads much like a textbook - or how a textbook SHOULD read. The author paid meticulous attention to detail. I've read a few other books about "Pope Joan" and was disappointed in the lack of authenticated details and information. I'm not Catholic, in fact I'm an atheist, but I can't see how anyone could fail to be fascinated by this myth and impressed with the author's research.