17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good information, but has some shortcomings, April 21, 2008
This review is from: NASA: Ultimate Collection From Orbit to Beyond (DVD)
NASA: THE ULTIMATE COLLECTION is a 6-DVD set that is lots of good information about the history of the American space program, from Mercury to the Space Shuttle, and seems to all be documentaries done by NASA from the 1960s through the 1980s. Still, I'm a little disappointed with it. I had hoped that this would contain all the films about the Apollo Program that are contained on the DVD set called
Moon Race: The History of Apollo, but NASA: THE ULTIMATE COLLECTION leaves out Apollos 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, and 12. This makes no sense to me, since this set does contain films on astronomical topics like the planets Mercury and Mars, the Universe, and so on that are badly outdated since they're from the 1970s. I mean, films about flights of exploration are timeless because they're of historical events and so are interesting from that standpoint, while films on astronomical objects are mainly of scientific interest and so need to be recent. When I got this DVD set in the mail, I was shocked that the FIRST disc makes it all the way through Apollo 11, so there's not a lot here on Mercury or Gemini either. Also, I believe there's another imbalance here, namely, the overwhelming focus on human exploration rather than unmanned probes. In my opinion the probes have actually been NASA's greatest success story.
Another aspect of this DVD set that is rather disappointing is the picture quality, which varies a good deal from bad to fairly good. At the beginning of each disc, St. Clair Vision says that they have digitally remastered the films, but explains that films do deteriorate over the years. I would expect this for films of the Mercury Program that are 50 years old, but a few of the films about the Space Shuttle from the 1980s look almost as bad! However, several of the films on this set do look markedly better than the average. And overall I think the picture quality here is watchable, but just don't expect to be wowed by these on your new high definition TV.
I should note that this 6-DVD set is also available as 2 separate sets called
Nasa Collection-Volume 1 and
The NASA Collection, Vol. 2. Also, there's a 5-DVD set called
NASA: 50 Years of Space Exploration!, but I don't know exactly what those contain so I don't know if they have more on the Apollo, Gemini, and Mercury programs, nor do I know about their picture quality, but several reviews on that Amazon page complain about the picture quality, so my guess is that it's about the same as here. Then there's the great DVD sets from Spacecraft Films, but those are mostly original footage and usually not documentaries, so they're really a different kind of thing. And of course there are more recent documentaries like Public TV's terrific
NOVA - To the Moon and Ron Howard's new one
In the Shadow of the Moon that I hope to see soon. In sum, I gave NASA: THE ULTIMATE COLLECTION 3 stars because I subtracted one star for leaving out a lot on early space exploration, and subtracted another for the fair picture quality. Still, there is a lot of great information here, so if you're not mostly into the early years of space exploration and not too picky about image quality, these should be worthwhile for you. OK, here's the exact content of this set:
DVD 1 - First Years of Exploration
- Freedom 7 (Alan Shepard, 1st American in space)
- The Voyage of Friendship 7 (Mercury)
- The World Was There (Project Mercury summary)
- The Four Days of Gemini IV
- This Is Houston, The Flight of Gemini VIII
- The Legacy of Gemini
- Apollo 11: The Eagle Has Landed
- Research Project X-15
- Bonus: Earth from Space
DVD 2 - Deep Space Discovery
- The Moon, Old and New
- Apollo 13: Houston, We've Got a Problem
- Apollo 15: In the Mountains of the Moon
- Apollo 16: Nothing So Hidden
- Apollo 17: On the Shoulders of Giants
- Skylab: The First 40 Days
- Skylab: The Second Manned Mission
- Images of the Universe
- Bonus: NASA Launches
DVD 3 - Advancing the Dream
- Four Rooms, Earth View (Skylab summary)
- The Mission of Apollo/Soyuz
- The Time of Apollo (Apollo summary)
- Houston, I Think We've Got a Satellite (1992 Space Shuttle STS-49)
- The John Glenn Story (80 minutes)
- Bonus: Planetary Snapshots
DVD 4
- Jupiter Odyssey (35 minutes, Pioneer 10)
- Mercury: Exploration of a Planet (35 minutes, Mariner 10)
- The Universe (30 minutes, 1976)
- New Look at the Old Moon (30 minutes, 1979)
- Bonus: Space Exploration Timeline and Radio Bonus
DVD 5
- Planet Mars (35 minutes, 1979, Mariner 9 and Viking)
- Opening New Frontiers (30 minutes, 1982, beginning of Shuttle Columbia)
- Space Shuttles (35 minutes, 1982)
- We Deliver (28 minutes, 1983, Shuttles 5 through 8)
- Bonus: Solar System photos and radio episode
DVD 6
- NASA: The 25th Year (55 minutes, 1983)
- Launch and Retrieval of Satellites (30 minutes, 1984, Space Shuttles)
- Space Shuttle Challenger Accident Investigation and Return to Space (70 minutes)
- Toys in Space (30 minutes, 1986)
- Bonus: Satellite Images and Interview with John Glenn
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
