Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I have fun learning Japanese!, May 23, 2006
This review is from: Nakama 1: Japanese Communication, Culture, Context (English and Japanese Edition) (Hardcover)
I think Nakama is an excellent Japanese textbook for a college student like me. It has a total of 12 chapters, each featuring a main topic such as daily routine, family, health, restaurant, department store etc. Yes the book does work better in a classroom with the guidance of a teacher. It has many interesting activities to be done in a group with other classmates. When I just started learning hiragana and katakana, I really appreciate the mnemonic diagrams which are rather funny and therefore easy to remember. For example, it says that the hiragana の looks like a "No smoking" sign and is therefore pronounced as "no". The book also has many pictures which make learning Japanese fun. Besides, it also introduces Japanese culture in the beginning of each chapter.
The workbook is not as bad as described by other reviewers, at least it is great to me. I have been taking Japanese class for 3 quarters (~9 months) and finally finish studying the book and doing the workbook. I can now speak some Japanese and write a short essay with some kanji.
I love Nakama and also love learning Japanese very much. I am going to take more Japanese classes definitely and I am going to buy Nakama 2!! The only bad thing about this book is its price. I bought Nakama 1 for about $80, but considering the knowlegde I gain from it, I will probably keep the book. I recommend this book to everyone interested in learning Japanese.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not a good book - Are there better out there?, January 4, 2006
I think your response to this book depends on how you like to learn a foreign language. Personally, I prefer 'direct method' teaching, which means that you learn a foreign language in that language with very little translation into your native tongue. Nakama is not designed for direct method and in fact is far too laden with English directions, translations, cultural explanations, etc. While this is understandable, to a limited extent, with a beginner level textbook it would be better to at least begin to incorporate the Japanese introduced in the course into the text. I find that all the English limits the rate at which I 'absorb' the language.
The book itself is structured well enough, beginning with simple phrases and hiragana and moving on to katakana then kanji. However, it might make itself more adaptable for classroom use by adding role-plays or other such speaking activities. Basically, the book feels overdetermined and slightly like a cram-school approach to language acquisition.
As for the other materials, the cassettes that accompany the Workbook are terrible quality - so much so that the Japanese members of my family cannot understand what is being said at times. The workbook itself is printed on very low grade paper that really must be photocopied before it is usuable (unless you work on a separate sheet and simple write your answers on the workbook page).
Overall, I don't think the Nakama series presents value for money or education. You will end up forking out ~$200 for the set of books and tapes that really, at the end of the day, don't really give much educational return... Unless you have a good teacher and friends/family to help you - which I did.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Just finished two semesters with this one, and I'm glad to be done with it, January 12, 2009
This review is from: Nakama 1: Japanese Communication, Culture, Context (English and Japanese Edition) (Hardcover)
I literally just finished two college semesters of Japanese, both of which used this text, and it didn't make what was a bumpy ride for me any easier. I was a complete beginner when I started with this, and this certainly isn't the ideal beginner-level Japanese textbook to be using.
As said in other reviews, the book is rather light on explanations. Even the simple distinction between where and when to use "wa" or "ga" is not adequately explained and is a source of confusion. The conjugated versions of verbs are introduced before the infinitives, which is rather strange when you consider that all other forms are derived from the infinitives. Katakana and Kanji are rather kicked to the curb as they only make brief appearances in the text.
What I was really disappointed with was that they were no sections comparing the formal and informal forms of the language. And anyone who knows Japanese, knows that it has a very honorary/hierarchal structure. With different nouns and verbs that are used depending on who is being spoken to. You'll find no information on the informal aspects of the language whatsoever in this book. So if you want to learn how to watch anime in Japanese, read manga in Japanese, or play video games in Japanese, you're out of luck, as those mediums almost always use the informal style.
One last complaint, the audio tapes/CDs really leave something to be desired. The voice actors speak way too fast and I had to rewind over and over again to catch what was being said. For a beginner student, you need things to be a little slower because you need to be able to decode what's being said as its being said.
All in all, if your college is using this book for its Japanese course, go and visit their foreign language department and let them know what a poor book this is, or just boycott. I'm telling you, it's just not worth it, and I just LITERALLY wrapped up two semesters with it. So take my word for it and save yourself the frustration. In fact much of the time, I was reading Japanese Step by Step : An Innovative Approach to Speaking and Reading Japanese by Gene Nishi as a supplement, and it was so much better organized and thorough. I'd highly recommend it over this for beginners.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|