From Publishers Weekly
In a well-rounded plot, the collaboration of Hoffman and Northway has resulted in a truly unified marriage of text and pictures. Nancy isn't old enough to read her older sister's books or young enough for her baby sister's toys. She's also not big enough for a bike and not small enough for a rocking horse; not very tall or very short; not first and not last; but in sort of a no-kids' land. And she's had it. But just as she is ready to assert herself, her parents announce "Happy Birthday" in honor of her fifth year. Northway's interpretation of the text complements and enhances the meaning of the words on the page: in a friendly urban neighborhood, kids are playing, and Nancy is taken upstairs to change, bathe and prepare for her birthday celebration. The successive realistic scenes from the life of a middle-class black family are all in ice-cream colors with the familiar shapes and objects of a warm and secure environment. Ages 4-7.
Copyright 1987 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1987 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1Nancy is the middle child: too young to read her older sister's books, but too old to play with her baby sister's toys; too short for the top bunk, but too tall for last year's tights; neither dark like her older sister, nor fair like the baby. She finds this situation frus trating to the point of rage. Just as she's about to explode, however, the activi ties which have been used to illustrate her plight (bathing, picking up, etc.) turn out to be preparations for her fifth birthday party, and she discovers that the negatives can be positives: she is both old and young; big and small; with her own shape, color, and place in her family. As the book closes, she's off to school with children her age. The text contains a pleasing symmetry of lan guage and structure, and is illustrated with action-packed pastel drawings of a cozy, middle-class black family in a mixed neighborhood. The sentiments are hardly original, but the illustrations are effectively integrated into the text of the story, and the result is entertain ing and effective, if not particularly dis tinguished.Christine Behrmann, New York Public Library
Copyright 1988 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1988 Reed Business Information, Inc.
