Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant, March 14, 2005
Of all the books I have read on Napoleon, fact and ficiton, this is the best by far. Max Gallo has spectacular insight into the real person, not merely the legendary Emperor. This book perfectly captures the personality of Napoleon, constantly conveying a sense of restlessness - each time Napoleon achieves something he rejoices only briefly before he turns his gaze to the next task, never content, always driven to go to new heights. Gallo's writing style is unique, talking in present rather than past tense, as is the convention for novels. Nonetheless this is actually quite a bonus - it gives everything a sense of urgency and draws the reader in so one can feel that they are actually living the life of the emperor. A must read, whether a fan of Napoleonic history or not.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What History is All About, April 13, 2006
The review is for all I-IV of the Quartet:
If Napoleon could write his own memoirs in real time, this is what they would sound like... one really gets into the head of Napoleon. That is the gift of Max Gallo. Pulling this off in a quartet is something next to impossible -- and in translation?? -- well Gallo has done it! If you are interested in knowing how great people think, this is as close as one can come. The Napolean we meet is one of both human and mythic in equal proportion. His overriding sense of justice and the new age that he brings sometimes gives rist to excesses, but at other times one is amazed at his ability to apportion justice, forgive and see himself in humble terms.
The book offers a look at the life of the man, so we spend about as much time thinking about things as Napoleon did: there are no long treatises on Austerlitz, Wagram, Leipzig or Moscow. These were pivotal events in the life of the world and influences Napoleon, but one must realise that the amount of book space allocated to Austerlitz is about 15 pages of about 1500 in the total quartet -- probably about the same amount of time that Austerlitz occupied in Napoleon's life.
So if you are looking for an over-emphasis on the military events this is not so much the book to read. The real strenght is in the ability to marvel at the thought processes of this great historical leader -- how he reaches conclusions, right or wrong on important issues.
I have read 3 of the 4 so far. They have not dissapointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gallo + Napoleon = Dynamite!!, March 27, 2006
Well, this is another rare 5-star novel which I HIGHLY recommend for everybody who enjoys reading history or historical fiction books. Actually, it is a MUST-READ book.
In this novel, Napoleon is alive and well. He became of what he became because of partly circumstances and his own nature. It started with Napoleon at 9, and already France's army general at his early 20s. His fondness (or craziness) of Josephine is also blossoming.
His early campaigns on France's neighbors are excellent. If Gallo had detailed those campaigns, I would think the book's pages will certainly double. Gallo is a story teller like Bernard Cornwell and Simon Scarrow. He did a bit of strategic warfare telling in this novel, but not close to Steven Pressfield's detailed war strategies. However, Max Gallo's style is actually preferrable, rather than going into too much detail on an issue.
A highly recommended novel for everyone. I will get the remaining 3 novels on this Napoleon quartet by Gallo at all costs!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|