Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Napoleon's Master, March 31, 2008
This review is from: Napoleon's Master: A Life of Prince Talleyrand (Hardcover)
A sympathetic biography of a statesman who was involved in French politics during the more interesting periods of that nation's history: the ancien regime, French Revolution, Directory, Napoleonic era, and restoration. Charles Maurice de Talleyrand (1754-1838) was a controversial figure (arch betrayer or practical patriot, depending on one's viewpoint) who served his country in a diplomatic manner during the tumultuous periods listed above. David Lawday's book provides the English reader with the relevant facts presented in a basically chronological manner. Many of Talleyrands's bons mots and anecdotes are included, and Mr. Lawday captures some of the statesman's style in his own prose. Other books, such as those written by Duff Cooper (Talleyrand) and Crane Britton (The Lives of Talleyrand), deal with the life of the statesman, but Lawday's book focuses on the pivotal relationship he had with Napoleon Bonaparte. Talleyrand helped to foster the career of the young Corsican, encouraged Napoleon's autocratic leanings, but ultimately opposed the emperor's expansionist foreign policy. The dispute over France's place in European affairs eventually led to a conflict where Talleyrand supported Napoleon's foreign adversaries. Furthermore, after Bonaparte's military defeat and exile, Talleyrand encouraged the restoration of the Bourbon monarchy as a preferable alternative. Yet Lawday emphasizes the mutual respect and admiration that both men had for each other throughout their interwoven lives. Napoleon's Master is a well-written, well researched book that can be enjoyed by those interested in French history, biography, diplomatic history, and political intrigue. Paul W.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not quite there, April 25, 2008
This review is from: Napoleon's Master: A Life of Prince Talleyrand (Hardcover)
I have been fascinated with Talleyrand since reading Duff Cooper's biography on Talleyrand when I was in college. I look forward to a new biography on Talleyrand because Cooper's biography is a bit dated. I have to admit I was disappointed in Lawday's treatment of Talleyrand, not because he was overly harsh; rather he seemed to have lost his objectivity concerning the subject of the biography. Talleyrand was an opportunist, slimy and lacking a moral compass. He was guilty of high treason, even though he claimed, to be a patriot protecting France from Napoleon. It is still treason, why, because he was serving in the Government. He refused no monies or awards offered to him by Napoleon. One interesting aspect is that at one point, Talleyrand was soliciting funds from Alexander I. Could you imagine the uproars if a former US Secretary of State was soliciting fund from Putin to pay off their debts. Read "Rites of Peace" by Adam Zamoyski to obtain an unbiased view of Talleyrand. Is this a bad book, no, it is a very entertaining read. In the final analysis Talley was not the patriot. Lawday makes him out to be, nor was Napoleon the buffoon that was portrayed in the book. I anxiously a wait "Talleyrand: Betrayer and Saviour of France" by Robin Harris to see another version of Talleyrand's life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fabulous book, January 28, 2008
This review is from: Napoleon's Master: A Life of Prince Talleyrand (Hardcover)
I am writing this review on a fantastic book, and I'm not finished reading it. I expect to finish it within the next 24 hours, and can hardly put the book down. For years I've been intrigued by Talleyrand, but never bothered to delve further into his life. I concentrated, like many others, on Napoleon. However, this book changes my opinion of Napoleon, and turns Talleyrand into less of a "rascally fellow," but rather an astute politician diplomat who shaped the world from the French Revolution to today. The author quotes from primary sources (Napoleon and Talleyrand's words) and both have a contemporary feel. In fact, I've been making notes on Talleyrand's advice and social skills as he managed in difficult diplomatic times There are many scenes that the author includes--Talleyrand's putting up the deposed Spanish Royal family, and trying to get the young princes to "read," and his intriguing trip to America and a backwoods trip to upstate New York. Talleyrand was everywhere and saw almost everything. Even Napoleon regretted not taking his astute advice. Yet, at the heart of the man was his love of France, concern for Europe's balance of power, and peace.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|