"There Ain't No Mainstream"
by Brad Linaweaver
J. Neil Schulman, Victor Koman and I have know each other for many years. This collection of short stories is what one would expect of Neil, since he has the same problem that Victor Koman and I have.
J. Neil Schulman is a writer.
What this means is that he can write anything. That's what it means to be a writer.
By way of explanation, I will relate a personal experience because I know that any writer will understand. I'm a member of both the Science Fiction Writers of America and the Horror Writers Association. I've been on panels with horror writers who dismiss my opinion because I write science fiction stories and, no surprise, I've had science fiction writers do the same thing with me because I write horror stories.
As he points out in his introduction, this is not a very long collection. But the variety is worthy of an encyclopedia. No surprise when you're dealing with a writer.
Schulman does not make the mistake of some writers who are identified with a particular genre. He doesn't deny that he's written science fiction. Nor does he deny the other genres on display in Nasty, Brutish and Short Stories. If he ever produces a Gothic Romance, he won't deny that's what he's done. Let him produce a novel set in the old west with lots of horses and gun play, and he won't feel the need to fabricate an outre label.
But he understands right down to the marrow of his bones why someone who has written science fiction might want to deny it. That's because genre writers are treated abysmally by the publishing industry even in the best of times.
These are not the best of times.
It is perhaps worth noting that science fiction writers are treated the worst of all genre writers. That's because a writer who wants to say something about the future of mankind in these dangerous times will naturally want to talk about the big picture. Such a writer is not thinking that the bigger his thoughts, the smaller will be his pay!
There are real people in these stories. That limits Schulman's effectiveness in genre writing.
There are real ideas here. That rules out any hope of his being taken seriously by the literati who like real people in fiction only when those "real people" are bereft of ideas. Try finding anyone that empty in real life and you'll see the problem with most fiction that Gore Vidal accurately describes as "written to be taught."
The mind that produced this collection of stories is uncomfortable with the artificial barriers thrown up between commercial fiction and literature. No wonder he's so fond of The Catcher in the Rye.
Can you imagine how tolerant he is of the barriers thrown up between different areas of genre fiction, as in my example of SFWA vs. HWA?
I am proud to have played a role in two of these stories coming out through conventional New York publishers. Neil relates in his introduction how I bought his story "Day of Atonement" for the anthology I co-edited with Ed Kramer for Tor Books, Free Space.
The other case was my keeping after him to dig "The Repossessed" out of the trunk and give it another chance to see the light of print. I'd placed a story of mine with Carol Serling's Adventures in the Twilight Zone and it occurred to me that here was Neil Schulman, author of one of the best episodes of the new Twilight Zone television series, and shouldn't he at least submit a story to her book? I made certain that the TV credit was not forgotten when the story went in. Co-editor Richard Gilliam was impressed, another enthusiast for "Profile in Silver."
Carol Serling led off the collection with "The Repossessed." For me, this kind of makes up for the series not producing the other Schulman script, "Colorblind." (That script and the whole story of that true adventure in the Twilight Zone is told in Profile in Silver and Other Screenwritings, the book, also from Pulpless.Com.)
The only other story where I remember doing some cheerleading is "When Freemen Shall Stand"; but I played no part in its final publication in a nationally distributed magazine, Liberty.
As Neil says, I'm always trying to get him to write short stories.
Read this book and you'll see why. There is no bad story in here. A lot of these tales would have found a home in slick magazines for short fiction back when there was a mainstream.
But there aint no mainstream today.
And the genres are dying.
That's why the world needs more books like this one and a company known as Pulpless.Com!
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brooding not brutish ...,
By John Dechancie "Vegas Lizard" (Littlerock, California USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Nasty, Brutish and Short Stories (Paperback)
A tasty smorgasbord of fictional delights:"Benny Rich is Dead" has an especially ironic twist. "When Freemen Shall Stand" is a bold political statement. "Day of Atonement" is an unexpected off-center view of Judaism. "The Second Remove" is a Salingeresque look at a troubled teenager. All in all, a fair sampling of Schulman's talents in the short story form.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tag this product(What's this?)Think of a tag as a keyword or label you consider is strongly related to this product.
Tags will help all customers organize and find favorite items. |