5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Funny and surprisingly inspiring, July 11, 2005
This review is from: Nasty: My Family and Other Glamorous Varmints (Hardcover)
This book is incredibly funny--the kind that makes you laugh out loud. (Some lines were so great, I had to read them out loud to my husband). I think it is Doonan's funniest. What's really surprising about this book, however, is how touching and inspiring it is. Without a false note, Doonan's hilarious memoir is also a loving portrait of his strong, brave, (and yes, poor and crazy) family. In the end, the story is incredibly inspiring. Doonan is one of the most creative minds working in fashion and design today and this is the story of how he got there in spite of many odds against him. It is a fascinating and very freeing portrait of creativity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
29 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
More Gay Than Nasty, June 10, 2005
This review is from: Nasty: My Family and Other Glamorous Varmints (Hardcover)
When I fell upon my very first comedic memoir, "Naked" by David Sedaris, I thought it was very funny. He wrote his essays with a mock sarcasm and an intelligent enough wit that his being homosexual was always an afterthought. He puts his story first, above all else, and never seems like he's trying to be funny. When you do something well and make it look easy, that's talent. Now I know why so many readers love to compare Sedaris with all the other resident gay memoir writers. Because he's top tier. He's the best thing going.
Several rungs down is Simon Doonan, author of "Nasty: My Family and Other Glamorous Varmints." Doonan bills it as a sort of indictment of strange upbringing by even stranger guardians. Well, it's not about that at all. He lightly...so lightly touches on his insane grandmother, lobotomized uncle, devil-may-care alcoholic parents and various family friends that come into and out of his life. In truth, the subtitle to his novel takes the backseat in lieu of the real deal: numerous celebrations, anecdotes, misgivings and stories about being gay. Every single story is basically about gay Doonan who does this and that, as long as we understand that he's always playing for the "other team." Really, it's like a funny, gay porno without the sex.
Wait, did I say funny? Heck yeah, it's funny. A great deal of his more humorous tales just wouldn't fly without all the prissy overtones, so sometimes I understand where he's coming from. When he gets arrested for drunk driving, the best parts involve jokes about his hilarious drag outfit. And the gut-busting chapter where he compares his "nelly" self to his manly, tough-as-nails grandfather is pricelessly appropriate to his "theme." Still and all, a good 60% of these pages don't have to be, "By the way, I'm a homosexual and I just happened to fracture my aunt's skull one day! And I'm gay, too!" You get the gist.
Funny or not, I'm not a fan of his style of writing either. He will introduce new ideas and scenarios right in the middle of his story, and sometimes won't even return to the main point before the chapter ends. I kept feeling like his chapters should have been more compact, tighter. Let's see if I can make it clearer...
Imagine reading a story about an ant. And because ants like breadcrumbs, you end up getting a story within a story about how bread is made. And then a man makes a sandwich. The end. And the end won't always be in English either. Let's not forget the constant phrases in French, a la "Lolita." I always found this practice to be very pretentious. To all you writers out there, let's just write our books in one language okay? Just in case the whole country was kidding about being bilingual.
Doonan, (did I mention that he's gay?) has no interest whatsoever in topping off his essays with any sort of satisfaction. You're laughing about a really funny situation he'd gotten himself into and then, nothing. Half the time, there is no great resolution, just a boring exit. It just doesn't do justice to the scenario if you don't give it a nightcap with a kick. Seal the deal! Would "Vacation" had been funny at the end if Chevy Chase and his family finally made it to Wallyworld, had a great, problem-free time and just went home? No. If Doonan wrote all the endings, Keyser Soze would've kept limping, Babe would have lost the sheephearding contest and Darth Vader would never have had any kids.
Actually, I wouldn't put that past Sedaris either. But he'd at least have made the ending funny.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No