Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A tawdry betrayal......, January 22, 2004
This review is from: Natalie Wood: A Life (Hardcover)
For me at least, this book is a huge disappointment. Who could possibly be interested in reading about Natalie Wood's gay male secretary Marty Crowley's sordid encounter with a call boy? Or page after Page of cruel unsubstantiated attempts to character assassinate and "out" Scott Marlowe - an actor the young Natalie Wood was in love with, who is not alive to defend himself? Gavin Lambert, who has written about his own homosexual affairs, goes to extreme and transparent lengths to try to establish that his friend Robert Wagner (for whom I believe, he wrote this book) is a virile heterosexual - even including a sleazy account of a supposed encounter between Wagner and a (Japanese?) prostitute. Who are they kidding? There are innumerable tasteless and pointless disjointed incidents of Natalie allegedly drunk and "swishing her tail" in front of men - a nasty ruse by Lambert, on behalf (perhaps?) of Robert Wagner, to try to shift the blame to Natalie for her horrible drowning and to deflect attention away from Wagner's suspicious and disgraceful behavior that night. What kind of "friend" of Natalie Wood's - as Lambert claims to be - would write a book about her to make a case that her father, who she loved dearly and who looks just like her, was not her biological parent? Lambert also trashes Natalie's mother and her sister Lana with tacky family gossip apparently provided by Wagner. This book is a disaster: ditto its ghost writer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Flop, January 12, 2004
This review is from: Natalie Wood: A Life (Hardcover)
As a devoted Natalie Wood fan (she was my childhood hero), I looked forward to reading a bio filled with new information and written by a friend who enjoyed a "twenty-year friendship" with Natalie. What a disappointment! The book is a bore from start to finish. There are far too many stories about Hollywood wannabes and an endless rehash of details about her mother, father and sisters. There are no meaningful insights, no interesting details revealed. Lambert's writing is so awkward frequently had to reread the sentence page. Paragraph transitions are disjointed as well, and there are many disconcerting examples of odd word useage such as: "Everett Sloane...had sounded authentically Hebrew in the small part of a rabbi in Morningstar." Authentically Hebrew? His numerous inaccuracies are disturbing as well. One wonders whether Lambert actually watched Natalie's films before writing the book. The premise of "Marjorie Morningstar," for example, concerns a wealthy Jewish girl's dreams of breaking away from family tradition. Marjorie's lover, played by Gene Kelly as the the son of highly respected Jewish parents (his father is a judge), tries, in his own way, to escape family expectations. Had the author bothered to see this film he would never have written "For Wouk to make Marjorie (nee Morgenstern) Jewish seems more a gimmick than an essential part of her star-is-not-born story, and in the movie the Jewish element is so diluted that it has no effect on her WASP lover, who's only momentarily restive at the Morgenstern's Passover dinner." Skip this one. Suzanne Finstad's "Natasha" is a far more interesting and well written exploration of Natalie's life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Serviceable court biography, February 14, 2004
This review is from: Natalie Wood: A Life (Hardcover)
When Suzanne Finstad's biography of Natalie Wood came out a couple of years ago, RJ Wagner refrained from commenting on it or giving his assistance because (we were told) a more authoritative biography was already in the works. This is that more authoritative biography--an authorized biography, in fact, sanctioned by family and friends. What a disappointment. It is both bland and sketchy. Unlike Finstad, Lambert does not seem to have done any legwork in researching this, other than a couple of phone calls to Mart Crowley, Natasha Lofft, and a few other frequently quoted supporting players. The result is a book a plodding book short on revelation and telling detail. I feel gypped by this book. We were led to believe it would set the record straight about the breakup of Natalie and RJ's first marriage (the Finstad book says it was precipitated by RJ's homosexual sidetrips); that it would give the final word on Natalie's mysterious drowning, in which RJ was a suspect; and maybe it would shed some light on the suggestion in Finstad's book that Kirk Douglas, or somebody like him, raped Natalie when she was a teenager. So what news here? None at all. But be of good cheer, Gavin Lambert! You need never fear you'll be scratched off the Wagners' "A" list. Gavin, why did you bother? Being a social friend of Natalie and RJ's does not qualify one to write her biography. If anything, quite the opposite--it curtails one's honesty, since most of the principals are still alive. Better if you had made this a personal memoir--"Natalie as I Remember Her"--and avoided the trap of a full-scale bio.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|