3.0 out of 5 stars
An Adequate Survey with a fine Intro, January 10, 2011
This review is from: Native Americans of the Southwest: The Serious Traveler's Introduction To Peoples and Places (Paperback)
Although this book has an impressive anthropological introduction, and gives an adequate survey and descriptions of the primary tribes of the Southwest, it must remain relegated to the category of "travel lodge information," rather than be considered certified Native American history.
Of particular interest (and I found it to be very useful) was the map appearing on page 16, of the boundaries of the primary pre-historic cultures giving rise to the tribes and nations of the Southwest; viz, the Mogollons, the Hohokams, the Anasazis, and the Hakatayas. However the descriptions of the respective cultures, can only be considered the stripped-down version as the details are skimpy and formulaic. And even though the authors tried to provide at least minimal historical context, a lot was still left to be desired. For those interested only in a summary glimpse of what the Native American tribes of the Southwest are like, this book must certainly be considered a useful introduction.
However, for a more in depth look, I suggest the very readable and lavishly illustrated "500 Nations," by Alvin M. Josephy, Jr.; or, Colin F. Taylor's "The Native Americans." In this same class interested readers may also want to consult: Duane Champagne's "Native America: Portrait of the Peoples." Each of these references covers the same terrain as this book and much much more, and in quite a bit more depth.
And finally, as either a first or last resort, one cannot do better than Frederick E. Hoxie's "Encyclopedia of North American Indians." Again, all of the Southwest tribes are present and discussed in nearly as much depth as in the present volume. Three stars
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No