|
|
39 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Says some common things in an uncommon way!, June 4, 2002
I believe it was actually here on Amazon.com that I read someone's assesment that this book looks like an infomercial. Whoever said that... was right! You will be impressed by Schwarz's graphics and charts-- although some of them will take a bit of deciphering to comprehend. And, you'll like the easy lay out of this book (in five parts: here's what we're talking about, here's when to do it, here's how to do it, here's why... now, do it this way...My only negative critique of Schwarz is that he starts off by pummelling the church growth movement-- and its highly pragmatic orientation (which he caricatures like "do this and your church is guaranteed to grow by x amount of people in the next year"). I have no problem that he takes this approach to the movement at the outset of his book (we could stand to look at the issue from many perspectives, and I think there does need to be some balance here), but Schwarz's theories CAN come close to being just another pragmatic approach, if not read and implemented carefully. His work is invaluable in that it causes us to stop, step back, and look at the issue of QUALITY growth as opposed to seeking out QUANTITY growth. Of course, I'm not so sure that many church growth books would actually disagree with this idea. Schwarz's conclusion is that if you get the quantity, quality will happen (see-- this can quickly sound like pure pragmatism, if you're not careful). I think, however, he is aiming at a more organic view of growth-- than a managerial or business model. In this, his comparison in the middle of the book between a robot and a human is helpful. Sure, you can create a robot (or a church) by doing this certain thing. But, it can't change, can't adapt, can't maneuver, can't reproduce itself. On the other hand, sometimes humans are messy... but they can adapt... they are living... and so should be the Body of Christ, the Church. The way Schwarz lays out his eight "biotic" (life giving) principles is helpful, especially in how he illustrates how they affect each other-- and the idea of the minimum factor, the idea of interdependence in the system, etc... In this, those charts ARE helpful. Much of what he writes is not new. What is helpful, though, is that there has been a comprehensive survey going on behind the scenes of this book-- and Schwarz lets you in on the preconceptions he had, what he thought he might find out but didn't, where he was wrong in his initial gut takes, etc. In other words, the most helpful aspect of this information is HOW he says it, and how you can work through it and apply it. Much of what is in this book I have read (in different ways) in Callahan's book on "12 Strategies of Effective Churches," in Aubrey Malphurs book "Planting Growing Churches," and others. An interesting study might be to chart all of these out side-by-side, and see what the commonalities are... Just a thought. If you're only going to be one of those books, though, get this one. The way in which the information is presented (graphically and linguistically) places this at the top of the list.
|