2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Solid environmental history, December 17, 2011
This review is from: Nature and Empire in Ottoman Egypt: An Environmental History (Studies in Environment and History) (Hardcover)
After reading a series of dull and uninsightful monographs on environment and on the Near East, I found this book with enormous relief. It's a really good, solid, documented study of Ottoman Egypt. Mikhail covers irrigation and food in particular, and is well aware of the important recent literature on irrigation management in traditional societies, not only in the Near East (think Dan Varisco) but in Peru (Paul Trawick...), Spain, and even California (Elinor Ostrom and others). Egypt supplied grain to the Empire; the Ottomans supplied wood, from Syria and Anatolia. This somewhat ran down the forests, but Mikhail knows from J. R. McNeill's work (and presumably other sources) that a surprising amount of forest survives in Anatolia. Meanwhile, the Ottomans made a brave try to grow native trees in Egypt--a fascinating section of the book describes this. As Karl Butzer showed for ancient Egypt, early-modern Egypt could not be an "Oriental despotism" with a monarch controlling the water; irrigation has to be locally managed to work. The Ottoman regime could, however, build long canals, maintain peace, and do surveying.
There is also an excursion herein into bubonic plague history; the plague occurred on average every nine years, a horrific burden for society and economy. The Ottomans did what they could, but, in the absence of bacteriology, they could not do much.
Mikhail sees a steady progress of bureaucratization during the period in question, and sees it getting rapidly worse after Egypt became (nominally) independent. This he deplores, finding that it progressively distanced the people from their land and their traditional management strategies. True, but I am ever the optimist, and might note that at least the Ottomans kept the place peaceful and prosperous (outside of famine years) for a couple of hundred years, no shabby achievement.
My only complaint is that I would have liked more statistics--maybe there aren't many more, but at least the levels of flood of the Nile should have been covered, with some comparative material from early periods; also more on food, foodstuffs, food production. I have always wondered where and how Egypt raised all those beans (the national dish) and the spices for them.
Minor problems, considering that this is a pathbreaking book--there is amazingly little literature available on the environment of the eastern Mediterranean in the early modern period. One must welcome a good book that ventures into this amazingly uncharted water.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No