Customer Reviews

Neil Young

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is a terrific album, and now that it's been newly remastered in pristine HDCD sound, I hope that it will be rediscovered by legions of Neil Young fans who may have overlooked it as one of Neil' as earlier efforts. In style, it's transitional between the rhapsodic, if slightly spacey, Neil Young who appeared in Buffalo Springfield classics like Broken Arrow and "On the Way Home" (written by Young, but sung masterfully on Buffalo Springfield's final album by Richie Fury), and the rockin' in the free world Neil who would emerge in glorious full plumage with his next album, the timeless "Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere" in which he teamed with Crazy Horse. In his later solo efforts as well as his inspired collaborations with Crosby, Stills, and Nash, Young would go on to display a kind of mastery of taut, rock rhythm and soulful melody that hadn't quite gelled at the time he laid the tracks for this album, but which still can be seen just below the surface and some of the more accomplished tracks, such as "What Did You Do to My Life," "I've Been Waiting for You," and others. Still, this inaugural release was a wholly individualistic and inspired effort, which laid the path for Young's later individuality and iconoclastic career as a rock star who challenged so many of the boundaries and conventions of the genre.

The history of the mixing and mastering of this album is quite unusual. The first LP release was quickly withdrawn from circulation by Young, because he didn't like the sound quality, and he was right. I have the original Neil Young LP, and the sound was muddy and thin. The subsequent LP release (you can tell the difference because it has "Neil Young" in block letters at the top) was a big improvement, but frankly, still left a lot to be desired, certainly compared with Young's later LP and CD releases. The mastering of the first 1990 CD release, which is still in print and still offered by Amazon (at a higher price!) was a typical disaster of the early CD era, and appears to have used a hissy LP master of indifferent quality. For this release, Young and his team of dedicated engineers have gone back to the original master tapes and remastered all the tracks in pristine HDCD, a high definition format that I personally prefer to SACD, and which has the advantage of not requiring a special player to get improved sound. (Although, those with HDCD players, such as those made by Denon and Mark Levinson will notice even more improvement.) It sounds great, with Young's voice moved up closer on the soundstage, and with greater definition to the background vocals and fascinating instrumentation from producer Jack Nietzsche.

That said, I do have one little quibble with the remastering. Although it is a huge improvement overall, like most CDs today, this one plays extremely loud, which requires you to adjust the volume constantly if you're using it as part of a compilation on your iPod or on your CD carousel player. But no big deal, this is a great album, that should finally get its day in the sunshine as a notable, if early, contribution of Neil Young's magnificent, long career oeuvre.

This past weekend I purchased and listened back-to-back to the newly remastered and restored versions of Neil Young's first two solo albums, Neil Young and Everybody Knows this is Nowhere (the latter recorded with his backing band, Crazy Horse.) This was a great experience not only because of the wonderfully improved sound quality of these reissues but also because it afforded me the opportunity to reacquaint myself with all of the material--some of it undeservedly forgotten--on both of these albums. In the case of this album, Neil's first solo outing after his three records with the Buffalo Springfield, The Loner is the only track that has proven to be immortalized, which is unfortunate as it is only one of many strong songs on here. The most consistent thing about this album is the strength of the melodies-- not one of them is a clunker and the majority is likely among Neil's strongest ever:

The first track, The Emperor of Wyoming, is a pleasant country-tinged instrumental that grows rapidly on the listener. It is a catchy melody and one of the most upbeat and completely happy-sounding things Neil has ever penned. Not so much a gem as it is an unjustly neglected trinket, Emperor gives gives the album a characteristic quirky edge right off the bat, being absolutely nothing like what follows.

The Loner is by far the most well known song on the album and one of Neil's strongest rockers, with a driving melody and some of his most intense and brilliant lyrics ever, centered on themes of isolation and loneliness. I've loved this song since I first heard it and am delighted that it now sounds better than ever, the awesomely powerful rhythm section rocking harder than a sailboat caught in a storm at sea while Neil's guitar bursts through the melee with new crispness. (Needless to say, the people behind the restoration did a good job.) Continuing one of Neil's most effective album sequences, we segue into If I Could Have Her Tonight. Once again, the remastering job has done wonders-- I've always thought that musically it's near-perfect pop but for the first time, I'm aware of just how underrated this short song is. It's a direct and emotional story of romantic yearning, told in the eminently relatable manner it seems only Neil can effect-- the listener is completely convinced that everything being sung is real, that's it's based on true events. I've Been Waiting for You is even better, an absolute work of art by an artist in a determined search for the love. While the rhythm section (highlighted by George Grantham's excellent drumming) propels this second heavy rocker, a swirling mist of keyboards and guitars wraps itself around the listener, steadily building through the verses as the desire is expounded upon, building to a crescendo at the chorus as the artist's fantasy of meeting his greatest love is envisaged. Young's guitar soars once again during the instrumental break with an epic passionate solo.

Ending out a superb side one is The Old Laughing Lady, a rambling song about vice. Musically, it is a deceptively gentle, lulling ballad. Lyrically, it is as restless, conflicted, and mournful as most of the songs on here. Verses one, two, and four are especially excellent, particularly with the line "you can't have a cupboard if there ain't no wall", whereas verse three ("see the drunkard of the village') states the theme almost too literally and directly as compared to the subtlety and poeticism of those around it. The song has one of the album's more complex arrangements, with intricate string sections by co-producer Jack Nitzche (who also produced Neil's Expecting to Fly on Buffalo Springfield Again) and backing vocals from several female soul singers, apparently signifying the titular character. The number ends with a hypnotic repetition of notes as the Old Laughing Lady does her thing...

The String Quartet from Whiskey Boot Hill and Here We are in the Years act as a sort of suite. String Quartet was written by Nitzche. In another context, I think I'd really enjoy this but here, it's the least interesting track in sight. Still, with its quaintness and tranquil tone, it leads well into Here we Are in the Years-- which has really grown on me over the years that I've listened to it. Them most interesting thing about it is that it features almost no repetition of melody. It coasts from tune to tune at mid-tempo carried by atmospheric piano as Neil atmospherically describes the beauties of the countryside and laments the fact that it seems that some are working to destroy it, one bit at a time. One of my favorite Neil Young lyrics can be found here: "Time itself is bought and sold. Spreading fear of growing old contains a thousand foolish games that we play"--so completely true and so well-stated.

The next two songs also seem to go together: What Did You Do to My Life? and I've Loved Her So long. The former, another mid-tempo, also seems connected to I've Been Waiting for You, showing the flip side of that scenario with an equally infectious melody and unique, electronically-based arrangement. The lyrics again are brilliant. I quote one of my favorites, from the chorus, in my title: "I don't care if all of the mountains turn to dust in the air", with a buzzing synthesizer portending this disaster. Neil's vocal as he demands, "What did you do to my life?" behind these words is equally haunting. I've Loved Her So Long, by contrast, is an impassioned slow balled for a lost partner--not haunting so much as melancholy. Melody and lyrics are uniformly strong, with Jim Messina providing a particularly strong bass line and the refrain especially memorable. The song's one possible weakness is a slightly overwrought reappearance of the choir from Old Laughing Lady, effective in the background of the verses but just a little to close to wailing at some spots in the chorus, Nitzche apparently trying to turn it into a '50s soul record, which works to some degree but not entirely. There is an acoustic performance of this song which is just as good, if not better, on Live at the River Boat from Archives 1. In both cases Neil's passion for the song and for his lover--even though she has left him--come through.

The final track, The Last Trip to Tulsa, is nine and 1/2 minute opus that could itself be the subject of an entire review. It is unique among Neil's other long numbers in that it features only he and and he accompanies himself on only the acoustic guitar. The result is a unique, great-sounding song, especially with the great remastering job here. The melody remains the same, but varies compellingly throughout from a serenely relaxed, almost meditative tempo to desperate agitation, with Neil hitting the strings so hard at some points, you're surprised not to hear one snap off. The lyrics are completely bizarre: great imagery but nonsensical for the most part. The narrative is semi-coherent, moving between waking and sleeping, as well a dead and living, states throughout. During the sleeping portions, the songs seems like a collection of a night's worth of dreams-- brief and not at all related to one and other. There are some interesting passages that one suspects may just hold deeper meaning. For one, I wonder whether the "Two men eating pennies" mightn't be Charles Green and Brian Stone, the managers of the Springfield, with whom Neil did not get on very well. They are apparently strong businessmen if nothing else. This fits in with the autobiographical nature of some of the other verses: "I used to be a folk singer..."

There is also the priest who, in the absence of his congregation, would rather not "play the fool", a clear blow at hypocrisy and the lack of integrity all-too-often present in leaders.



Then there is the "death section": the narrator dies after being shot through the nose with an arrow by a Native American and then somehow comes back to life at some point during or just after examination by an apparently friendly coroner. Some have read racial meanings into the manner of death. Most likely, however, Neil, who has for years been fascinated by Native American culture, was examining the duality he often found in himself. He may also have been bemoaning racial disharmony of the day. The connection isn't all that improbable when one considers this was the age of Martin Luther King Jr., and the African-American equality movement.

Whatever the case may be, after some further bizarre but captivating ramblings about, among other things, a brilliantly nightmarish filling station with yellow servicemen and green fuel and opening up a person's mind (with the great line, "if you guarantee the postage, I'll mail you back the key"), Neil summarizes the whole thing by saying all of this happened on "my last trip to Tulsa, just before the snow." This is just a guess, and it certainly doesn't explain why he chose Tulsa, OK, but when talking about this particular place the narrator apparently goes to regularly, Neil may have been speaking of the mental state that forces an artist to create, that part of their mind all creative people have that feeds them ideas and from whence all of these vignettes were conjured. That would certainly explain where all the bizarre images come from.

The song, and album, end on one of Neil's more memorable verses, as insant karma is exercised when a friend won't help chop down a palm tree the narrator's been working on "for 87 years" and the tree lands on his back when finally cut down, presumably killing him. It's cold; sardonic; ironic; and completely Neil, and also a great, if random, note to end the album on.

The only reservation I have with this album is that, even in the days of vinyl as primary format, it could have easily been longer than it was. It works great as is and is a complete work of art but one wonders whether tracks like Slowly Burning, a Springfield instrumental just released on the Archives, Whiskey Boot Hill (also on NYA1) and Birds-- a version of which was recorded at the time--might have fit with the songs on the album and really added to it.

Bearing all of this in mind, this would probably be a four-star album under most circumstances, but I felt that because the remaster was so strong, this release warranted a fifth. Like Everybody Knows this is nowhere, the clarity is wonderful and adds a dimension to the album, coming after the inferior 1990 release. I personally also prefer the cover without the "Neil Young" plopped on top of it. This lets the beautiful portrait of Neil--and the surreal pro-environment background showing cities and pollution gradually taking over the countryside--be visible without obstruction. (And that's not even mentioning the original "Neil Young of the Buffalo Springfield" sticker on the shrink-wrap.) So another point for the reissue there.

I'd recommend, especially if you don't already own "Neil Young" on CD, that you pick up this reissue. It's a great album and sounds brilliant as can be in its reissued form. This is a beautiful piece of work and, like the entire Archives concept, a testament to how much Neil cares about his legacy.

This is a remaster that as soon as you put it on , you go oh my god this is done right. In Fact of the first four solo's this one gets my vote for best sound, You really have to hear it to see what I mean, good show Neil :)

I was already a Neil Young fan in 1977 but had somehow never listened to or purchased his debut. Until I heard "The Old Laughing Lady" in my girlfriends dorm room one winter's night and was quite frankly blown away. The melodic and lyrical brilliance on this first album are undeniable.

He was young (no pun intended), romantic and these songs reflect youthful themes of alienation, unrequited love, and deep compassion. Jack Nitzsche's production (and the strings) has always seemed appropriate for these songs. The "Godfather Of Grunge" was still a few albums away (see "Tonights The Night").

"The Loner" or "The Old Laughing Lady" are much more than folk, or country rock, or pop... During his first "Decade" (1969-1979) Neil Young was the most vital, important, and consistently interesting artist making music, and it started with this album.

Everything others have said about this album is true: it is an excellent album from Neil's phase when he still sought memorable, original melodies and sounds. All I can add is that what may pass for slightly quaint conceits now (although no less listenable for that), such as opening the album with an instrumental, countrified thing, or letting Jack Nitzsche go to town on String Quartet From Whiskey Boot Hill with a contemporary (read: occasionally atonal) chamber music interlude, was innovative at the time of its creation, and made everyone feel like there was still hope for the progress of rock.
Now on to my little annoying thing. The good news is that this remaster is truly a remaster, a warm, "round"-sounding one well worth the money, unlike the myriad remasters where you sit dumbfounded and wonder where the difference with the previous release is, and where your money has gone. The one teensy thing that bothers me is that the loudness levels don't seem to be equal from song to song. Right off the bat, you'll want to hear The Emperor of Wyoming louder than The Loner, which follows it. Granted, the first one is soft and leans toward violins, the second is a pretty hard rocker with a typical Neil-fuzzed electric guitar and the killer 60's organ; they are naturally different-sounding songs, but I'd have thought that was precisely what remasters were for: to find the best possible balance for all songs on the album (among other things).
I don't know if this is the case for all four in this initial series of remasters: I started at the beginning, we'll see where this leads, but I do hope the levels are more consistent on the remaining albums.

I'd bet many people who consider themselves avid Neil Young fans don't know this album even exists. They should. Not only is it an important milestone in his career, but it's completely unique. There's simply nothing else in his catalog that sounds remotely like it. Leslie-ed guitars? Growling B-3 organ? Gospel choir? Jazzy electric piano? Bright, chiming guitars? Instrumentals, and leading off both sides of the album at that? This is Neil Young? Well, yeah, it is, and mostly, it's pretty interesting.

The record isn't without familiar NY traits --- fuzzy guitars, and Neil's quirky voice and cryptic lyrics. But it's the things mentioned above that get your attention. Neil had a pretty nice backlog of songs built up for this record, which he started even before the last Buffalo Springfield album was released. At times he seems unsure of just how to arrange some of these songs, and maybe that's what led to these arrangements being so uncharacteristic of his subsequent work. But it pretty much all works.

"The Emperor of Wyoming" could be a movie theme (and wasn't it originally intended to be?). "If I Could Have Her Tonight" is bright and Beatle-esque. "The Old Laughing Lady" is notable for its jazz/gospel interlude. And for me, "I've Been Waiting for You" is one of Neil's best rockers, remarkable given that it was recorded in several different studios in different cities.

The only real clunker here is the closer, "The Last Trip to Tulsa". It's funny, because back in the day, this Neil-Does-Desolation-Row tome was considered the album's highlight. But it hasn't aged well, and you might find yourself skipping it upon repeated listings of the album. Everything before it is quite worthy, however.

After this album's release, Neil complained publicly that he didn't like the sound of it, and had it remixed and remastered. I preferred one song from the original. "Here We Are In the Years" had a more interesting (if muddy) mix, and more importantly, ran to its natural end, a glorious descent to a full stop rather than the wimpy early fadeout of the remaster. The fadeout was a bad decision on Neil's part, robbing the song of its momentum at the end.

"Neil Young" is clearly transitional, but fascinating nonetheless. NY fans who don't have it will find it a surprise, and a worthwhile investment.

A footnote: it was while recording this album that Neil acquired his "Old Black" 1953 Les Paul. He swapped one of his Gretsches to Jim Messina for it. Messina, who plays bass on this album, later labelled the trade a mistake on his part.

Many fans don't know this exists !!! If you are one of them, GET THIS ALBUM.
By far his greatest work.
Actually, one of the greatest albums.

Neil's an established artist, so i'm not going to spend a whole long while blabbering on and on about this album. To put it simply, if you like(not even love) Neil Young, than you should own this album. It doesn't have a weak track throughout and is great late sixties, Young at his finest.

Don't hesitate to grab, especially the newly remastered version. It sounds great!

Neil Youg left the SPRINGFIELD (B.S. ruled the west coast music scene) to start a trend of members leaving their previous bands to go solo.
In my opinion this disc still holds up better than any of the schmaltzy matieral that came later in his career.
If you're a Mr. Young fan, listen to his best! T.A. Stephenson

Neil Young (self titled): This album has his great songs, "The Loner" and "The Old Laughing Lady". The rest of the album is nice, but there is not enough here to give it five stars.