4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Pointers to Infrastrucure threats and vulnerabilities, October 3, 2005
This review is from: Networks, Security And Complexity: The Role of Public Policy in Critical Infrastructure Protection (Hardcover)
The good news:
This book serves as a great source to locate additional information. In that respect it is second only to Dan Verton's Black Ice and it covers areas Black Ice does not.
There are some excellent nuggets including, the danger of backhoes to the network infrastructure ( that happened to me three times when I used to help provide networks, but I had forgotten just how pesky those can be), a consideration of the vulnerabilities of the power grid ( can't run computers without power) and a fantastic consideration of issues related to fiber.
The author is a product of the University of Florida's legendary Geography program so as you would imagine, the maps in the book are excellent at conveying information.
The bad news:
The book is really a dissertation, there is no developmental editor and it shows. You have to work past bad writing.
There is an assumption the reader has read all of the same papers the author has. I had read all of the government papers, but only a fraction of the rest so it was very hard to follow the author's thoughts.
Technical errors, a few of them concern me, such as the statement terrorist have never used computers to kill people. The hacked PBX in the Madrid bombing, the cyber cafe's in India; it is true that is just command and control, but it is part of killing people. Also cell phones are actually just wireless computers and they are used as part of Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs). Also, the comment about Cisco routers not able propagate an attack concerns me, after all, they are computers as well and it is possible to exploit their processor through flaws in IOS. However, I might be too picky, this might be semantics and since this is a dissertation, people far more educated have reviewed it.
The bottom line, this is not an easy read, but if you are in the risk analysis business, you should consider investing the time to study this book and read some of the papers it references, you can count on me doing the same!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Look at Infastructure Weak Points, November 23, 2005
This review is from: Networks, Security And Complexity: The Role of Public Policy in Critical Infrastructure Protection (Hardcover)
Although it touches on other areas such as electric power distribution, this book is mostly concerned with the fiber optic backbone of the telecommunications industry. It began as a map showing where the fiber goes. Then with 9/11 it became expanded to show where weak points might exist.
To no great surprise, the fiber follows the interstate highways and the railroads. These already have right of ways that cover the distance between the major cities, exactly where the fiber needs to go. Specifically, interstate I-10 running across Texas and the southern part of New Mexico and Arizons, and interstate I-80 from San Francisco across Nevada, Utah, Colorado and Nebraska are where the major pipes run. Note that the Union Pacific railroad has track the roughly parallels both I-10 and I-80. In at least one spot (just west of Elko, Nevada) both UP tracks (each of which has fiber along its roadway) go under an Overpass. A bit of explosives here would seriously hamper truck, rail and information traffic across the middle of the country. I presume similar sites exist along I-10.
This is an interesting look at a little appreciated danger spot.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No