Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best, most thorough, insightful Goddess book out there!,
By A Customer
This review is from: The New Book of Goddesses & Heroines (Paperback)
Patricia has created the best Goddess reference book I have seen, and I have collected shelves of such books. I turn to this book first for research, for many years and through several editions. It gets deeper and better and bigger! Patricia's writing is clear, poetic and concise. It is well organised, the cross-reference tables are indispensable, the stories are a delight. A must for anyone interested in learning more about the Goddess's many manifestations.
49 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Don't Look for Historically Accurate Celtic Info Here,
By Francine Nicholson (New England) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The New Book of Goddesses & Heroines (Paperback)
My area of expertise is Celtica so my comments pertain specifically to those entries in the book. If you are looking for a book with wonderful pictures and beautifully written descriptions, then you may enjoy this book. However, if you are looking for accurate information about the Celtic goddess figures named here, please look somewhere else, such as Mac Killop's _Dictionary of Celtic Mythology_ or, better still, read the myths--the Ta/in (as translated by Thomas Kinsella) or the Mabinogi (as translated by Patrick Ford) for yourself. In addition, Monaghan makes significant errors or repeats notions that are not accepted by recent scholarship. For example, Monaghan conflates several distinct figures into one without justification, such as presenting the figure of Bridget as a pan-Celtic goddess of primary importance when she was probably only one of many local deities. Some of her statements are essentially speculative, such as "Some rituals and legends suggest that Brigid's history may date back even beyond the era of the Celts." Monaghan's etymologies of "Celtic" goddess names are sometimes incorrect; for example, she gives the meaning of Bridget's name as "'bright arrow' or simply the 'bright one.'" In fact, the name means, "high one." "Sheela na gig" does not mean "hag." In her description of Morgan le Fey, Monaghan confuses various theories--such as one set that associates Morgan with an earlier figure named Muirgein vs. those that associate Morgan with the medieval figure of the Mo/rrigan. More importantly, Morgan le Fey is a figure of late medieval tales, not a goddess figure. My largest criticism of Monaghan's work is that she works on an assumption that is widespread among modern Wiccans but doesn't seem to reflect pre-Christian attitudes or practice; this assumption views goddesses in various cultures as variations on a handful of themes. For example, Monaghan repeatedly lumps together goddesses from several cultures. In doing so, she glosses over the differences that make each goddess--and the culture who venerated her--unique. She also lumps together Irish and Welsh figures as if the two cultures were a single "Celtic" group, ignoring the unique histories and approaches of these two groups. In the process, I think her approach leads to misunderstandings of the figures and the cultures. This approach almost certainly does not reflect belief and practice in pre-Christian Celt cultures.
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Most Comprehensive Out There,
By Erin O'Rourke "Gwytherinn" (NY, United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The New Book of Goddesses & Heroines (Paperback)
I could read this book over and over again. (And if I didn'thave to keep getting it out of my library, I would! Amazon has anorder on the way...) Whether I was looking something up or just opening the book to a random goddess/heroine, it was always entertaining and informative.Goddesses and Heroines far surpasses what is commonly known of the goddesses and heroines which is what really makes this book special. Rather than just recounting a myth you may have read several times, there's always a piece of information you probably don't know. I especially loved the way she describes well known Biblical figures. It really gave me a new way to look at things. At the bottom of each entry it gives you other names and/or figures related to the deity which I found to be really helpful. It heightened my understanding of what I had looked up originally and expanded the myths, showing me how things were interrelated. In short, this was a book I *always* enjoyed reading. I know I'll refer to this book a countless number of times in the future to learn about new Goddesses and Heroines, to research, or to just reread myths I love.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|