From Library Journal
"Do you have a soul?" asks the first sentence of this book, and at the end the reader is still uncertain how the author answers that question. Based on the book's title, one guesses that Kristeva (The Old Man and the Wolves, LJ 12/94; Strangers to Ourselves, LJ 4/1/91) would answer in the affirmative. But what are these new maladies? There's nothing new about the psychiatric illnesses discussed in the first half of the book?obsession, perversions, and depression have been around for quite a while. The second half, entitled "History," rambles around world literature, with cryptic references in Lacanian doublespeak to the Bible, Madame de Stael, James Joyce, and the women's movement. A more appropriate opening might have been "Does this book have a point?" Large academic and research libraries whose patrons have postmodernist inclinations will need this book; others can skip it.?Mary Ann Hughes, Neill P.L., Pullman, Wa.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
Kristeva offers a challenge for psychoanalaysis to open itself up again: to break down from its position of the one who is presumed to know. --
International Journal of Psycho-Analysis