Customer Reviews

New Surrender

5 star:		(33)
4 star:		(12)
3 star:		(8)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I want to make this as simple as possible for Anberlin fans. This album is not 'Cities', but then again you'd have to compile a damn near perfect album to surpass their last effort. For a first release on a major record label, I'd expect a more pop rock sold out sounding Anberlin, especially since they softened up "Feel Good Drag" from 'NTFP.' Setting aside the God awful Maroon 5 sounding "Retrace" and the somewhat catchy but sugarcoated "Breathe", you're getting almost exactly what you've bargained for with this band: beautiful melodies, soaring vocals and hard rocking anthems.

Tracks Worth Noting:
1. "The Resistance"
2. "Breaking"
5. "Feel Good Drag"
6. "Disappear"
11. "Soft Skeletons"
12. "Miserabile Visu (Ex Malo Bonum)"

The final track mirrors their previous closing efforts ("Dance, Dance, Christa Paffgen" and "(*Fin)"). It's a beautifully structured song, once again running well over 6 minutes and closing the album in style. You don't need a fine tooth comb to break this one down. Anberlin is a band that thrives in every sense of the word Rock, whether it be hard hitting riffs, amplified ballads or unplugged melodies. Their ability to speed up and slow down the album track to track is unparalleled and done with such ease and flow.

'New Surrender' may get scrutinized as it draws comparisons to 'Cities', but any way you look at it you're paying $10 or less for 12 well written, unique and diverse songs. This band never leads you to a dead end. I'm glad I found them.

Grade: A-

Anberlin's last record, "Cities" was one of the best records of last year. Not a flawless record by any means, but a strong collection of songs that showed that Anberlin was one of the few groups that were not willing to sit in and stay with a chosen formula, but were willing to build on it and make it stronger.
"New Surrender", the eagerly awaited followup to that record, is, oddly enough, the opposite. Though not a terrible record by any means, "New Surrender" may very easily be the weakest overall Anberlin record so far in their still young career.
What's funny about "New Surrender" is that, with the exception of a not so much bad as worthless re-recording of "Feel Good Drag", there is really nothing bad here. All the songs are fine enough, performed with vigor and talent, and nothing here feels false or boring.
But on the flipside of that, there is also nothing here that I could remember after hearing the record through a few times. There are no really clear, strong melodies here, and the lyrics, though themselves never bad, aren't interesting enough or clever enough to really, truly grab your attention.
"New Surrender" is not a waste of money, nor is it a sound investment. The record is perfectly good background noise, well produced and played, but it is never more than that.
And knowing that these guys can do so much better than that, it's hard to see "New Surrender" as anything but a disapointment.

A year and a half after the release of the monumental Cities, Anberlin is back, backed by a new record label, and are eager to introduce you to New Surrender. The release of their compilation project, Lost Songs, in November 2007 marked the end of their contract with Tooth and Nail Records- the band's label home since the early days of Blueprints For The Black Market. Now, they are partnered with Universal Republic, and their evolution is evident.


New Surrender initially doesn't seem to reflect the "Anberlin" sound fans have come to know throughout their past three albums. However, that doesn't mean the quality of this music is anything less than what they would consider their best. Every song on this album has a beautiful story to tell. The opener, "The Resistance," is one of the more solid rock songs found on the album and serves as a really great introduction to the album. "Breaking," formally known as "Bittersweet Memory," follows. Our first glance of this song was through the acoustic videos and the digital download package that was available at Warped Tour. It was promising as an acoustic alone, and in this electric format, it doesn't fail to deliver. "Blame Me Blame Me" is a very up-beat tune reminiscent of "A Day Late." The chorus sings, "Blame me, blame me, blame me for mistakes you make but you can't own. Hate me, hate me, hate me for every honest word that you postpone. Leave me out of this; lights on sinking ships are gleaming, gleaming, gleaming for mistakes you've made but you can't own." This is definitely a highlight of the album and is sure to stand out among fans. After "Blame Me Blame Me," the album takes a more mellow turn for "Retrace" - a sweet love song which displays Stephen's clearly matured vocals and, lyrically, his ability to create amazing imagery. Next up is the new, yet not completely improved, "Feel Good Drag." This song first made its debut on their sophomore album, Never Take Friendship Personal. At first listen, the song sounded drastically different. However, with each listen, the differences between the two seem to disappear. It still has its edge, even though they have discarded the screaming vocals. Lyrically, this song is all about angst and is really emotional. New Surrender's version doesn't seem to capture that intense emotion like you were able to hear and feel in NTFP's.


At the half-way mark is "Disappear"- the first song we were officially introduced to by the band in mid-July. It speaks of the homeless and the neglected, and out of the whole record, it sounds the most like the Anberlin we know. It is one of the most memorable tracks, by far, especially with its unique subject matter. "Breathe" is a light, romantic song. It is simplistic in structure, but completely fits the tone and direction of the song. "Burn Out Brighter," "Younglife," and "Haight Street" are all less memorable than those previously mentioned. However, they are pleasant and tend to reminisce on care-free days and one's youth. "Soft Skeletons" is a beautiful song about a girl who doesn't seem to have the strength to carry on a fight against pain and addiction. Stephen's vocals are spot-on, sounding almost like melodic whines and cries, as he sings, "I just wish that I could heal all the hurt you feel tonight. There's life in your veins. These needles are chains to hold you down. How can you expect to win this war when you're too afraid to fight?" It's become a tradition for Anberlin to close their albums with an epic, exceptionally prolonged, finale. New Surrender's "Miserabile Visu" is no different. Though it lacks the intensity of "*Fin," its beauty seems to test the boundaries of eternity with intimate vocals and electric guitars.


The overall quality of the songs is very strong and demanding. This is a new chapter for the band, and while there are obviously still elements of the old Anberlin, the new ones will undoubtedly have a powerful reign. Some might notice vast differences; some might think they are pretty subtle. These changes could be their evolution or, simply, Universal Republic's generic influence on them, unlike Tooth And Nail's indie fashion.


Musically, it seems they were more conservative with this debut on Universal. It is evident the immense talent they've portrayed in the past isn't completely made known. A lot more keys are involved, hence the addition of a new keyboard player from the late band Acceptance. Stephen Christian's voice improves more and more with each album. This was most evident with the release of the acoustic videos of "Breaking." Yes, this album might be more produced than the past ones, but when you hear him all stripped down, he still has a very powerful, smooth voice that demonstrates his remarkable abilities.


The lyrical quality has also seemed to have improved tremendously. As a whole, it definitely deals with similar themes found throughout their previous albums, just in new approaches. "Miserabile Visu" is a lyrical highlight, and the growth in Stephen's writing is very noticeable. The amount of spirituality seems to decrease with each album, however, two songs highlight this theme to a very respectful level. "Burn Out Brighter" deals with wanting to live your life not for yourself, but for "something higher than myself." Also, the closer, "Miserabile Visu," is filled with spiritual references from Revelation - from mentioning the antichrist, to the mark of the beast, and even the second coming of Jesus through beautiful symbolism and an intense amount of detail.


Much respect is deserved and given to Anberlin for making the always-risky move to a major record company to further their music career and, ultimately, reach and move larger audiences with their music. This was the tell tale sign if they could stand up with major record labels and still maintain their integrity. Through the differences you will find, you will see these changes are not necessarily negative. At the heart of this album, you know it's still Anberlin. And I think that says a lot about their dedication to their fans and the integrity of their music.

- Review date: 9/28/08, written by Lindsay Wiseman

As a fan of Anberlin and owner of the original release of New Surrender, I can't seem to find any reason why fans should spend another $15 - $20 on this Deluxe Edition. The B-Sides are great, one of them, you can find on another of their albums, while the other's, mostly covers, are enjoyable and almost worth the cd purchase. Unfortunately in these days, you can buy the songs invidually for mere pocket change, rather than purchase the entire album. The day of forcing customers to purchase re-releases for a few new songs are over.

The dvd is mildly entertaing at best. You watch it once and never watch it again is the simplest way to sum it up.

Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy Anberlin, all of their albums are great, and I most definitely be there for the next release. I just can't help, as much as I try to justify my purchase, there is just not enough here if you already own, New Surrender. My advice buy the B-Sides individually, save yourself 10 bucks.

So, is this how it's going to be now that Anberlin is on a major label? Is the band going to re-package their albums with very little new content and expect us to buy again? I wouldn't be as disappointed if the additional songs were great, but they're not. "True Faith" is awesome, but I bought that as an individual song when the band first released it. I also already own the original release of New Surrender, so I basically paid $17.00 for 4 mediocre songs and a less than stellar DVD. I am a huge Anberlin fan. I have purchased all of their albums, and for the first time I'm extremely disappointed. The DVD is basically a joke. Why can't they just show us a real live performance? All of the live footage is overdubbed with studio tracks. Does the band suck that bad live that they can't even show us a legitimate performance? If you don't already own New Surrender I would say buy this set, but if you do I recommend skipping it completely.

Anberlin had already established themselves quite nicely PRIOR to the release of their previous album, "Cities." But it was on that release when they broke the mold, as they upped the ante on both melody and scorching alternative-rock riffs. They are far too accomplished (and sophisticated) to be lumped with emo bands, as they run endless circles around bands like Motion City Soundtrack and Dashboard Confessional. They are too passionate and immediate to be compared to bands such as REM and Travis (besides, Anberlin can actually rock out). They have established a nice little niche for themselves, and although a follow-up to "Cities" would be difficult to improve upon its predecessor, this year's "New Surrender" comes very, very close. With acoustic ballads like "Younglife" and gutsy, hard-hitting rockers such as "Disappear" and "Breaking" they pick up right where they left off. Also noteworthy is the track "Haight Street," which might just be the huge hit this band needs to reach platinum status. All in all, in a world full of carbon copies and cookie-cutter bands, Anberlin pushes the bar further, creating an album that is as good or even better than "Cities." When taken on it's own terms, this is impressive enough - but when you compare the quality of the music this band makes to other bands in the genre, it is clear Anberlin is now the best band of it's kind. Another reviewer of this album mentioned the word catharsis when describing the immediate tone of the songs....well, I listened to this album immediately after listening to the new Plain White T's album. Talk about a catharsis! There was no comparison. None. This band's got the goods, and are on the rise big-time.

Keep in mind I consider Anberlin one of my favorite bands, and while my first impression was not too great, it is growing on me. So forgive the harsh criticism to follow.

This is overall not the effort I would expect from the band that brought us Never Take Friendship Personal and Cities. The music itself isn't all that different, even with the addition of Acceptance's guitarist Christian McAlhaney. In general, I'd say this album is a testimony to the importance of good vocal melodies; Stephen Christian's singing is still amazing as always, but the melodies themselves are sadly unimpressive.

While the re-recorded version of "The Feel Good Drag" is still enjoyable, it is not by any means superior to the version recorded on Never Take Friendship Personal. It appears to be a transparent attempt by the band to ground the album with at least one extremely well-written song. In my opinion, it simply is an blatant indication of how Anberlin's song-writing abilities from the past two albums overshadow the effort of New Surrender.

The biggest problem with the album is how the choruses don't sound nearly as uplifting or catchy as they were on previous albums. The first track is a weak opening for the album, in spite of it's heavier sound, because of this.

Another disappointment is the band's failure to recapture the same magic heard in songs like "Inevitable" (from Cities) and "(the symphony of) blase" (from NTFP). The two ballads on New Surrender, "Retrace" and "Breathe," fall short of expectations.

The last song, "Miserabile Visu (Ex Malo Bonum)" is the epic song a lot of Anberlin fans are looking for. Sadly, I don't feel there is anything epic about it other than the length.

Where the album shines: Breaking, The Feel Good Drag, Younglife, Haight Street (my favorite song on the album), and Breathe.

That said, the album itself is worth a buy for long-time Anberlin fans, but give it time to grow on you.

New surrender was an album that seemed very different from cities and never take friendship personal.
it seemed to have a more light weight, happy vibe to it, it also seemed that new surrender had more softer toned songs.
I was slightly disappointed with this. I have always enjoyed how Stephan could passionatly belt out emotions through his music. With the exception of Feel Good Drag, this album seems to fall short.

dispite this alberlin never seases to amaze me. I do not regret buying this album. Its not my favorite amberlin album, but is still frequently played! :]

It's very difficult to create a masterpiece just as amazing as Anberlin's last album, Cities. However, they have managed to craft an excellent album nonetheless. With strong, vein numbing tracks such as "The Resistance", "Feel Good Drag", and "Disappear", New Surrender delivers its fans with a selection of fast paced, epic tracks. However, this album differs from Cities in that it focuses more so on slower, contemplative ballads like "Retrace" and "Breathe." Overall, the album isn't as strong and, say, "in-your-face" as Cities was, but these songs, as is Anberlin's nature, will find you singing along with them, begging for more.

Creative idea, nice arm band thingie, but really its not worth the extra 10 dollars. If you are buying it for the 'new' remix songs, dont. I love Anberlin to death, but putting their best songs from Cities against a club-techno beat, totally ruins the songs.
If you need to spend 10 dollars on something Anberlin, buy Cities or a poster. Not this.