5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
flawed, January 16, 2009
This review is from: The New World: Book Three in The Age of Discovery (Age of Discovery Trilogy) (Paperback)
Rather than review this final volume in the series by itself , I will review the trilogy as a whole.
I felt there were some good sections in this trilogy, with some fascinating, well fleshed out characters. Stackpole creates a fantasy world which is initially believable and quite interesting. I liked the idea of Jaedun, a sort of magic that comes to some who attain total mastery of their craft or skill. The interplay between the bureaucracy and the rulers of the nine kingdoms was also a nice idea with some fine moments , such as Grand Minister Pelut Vniel's attempts to out maneuver Prince Cyron .
Unfortunately, there is a great deal of odd terminology , which , even after nearly 2000 pages , I found to be confusing at times. There were also so many characters it was difficult to keep track of who was who until nearly the end. The series would have benefited by a glossary. This was only a minor annoyance for me , the real problem was the "gods". We find characters such as Keles and Jorim/Wentoki , who start out as believable characters, turning into gods . This begins to give the whole story a cartoonish character as they bring down moons , raise mountains , travel through time , rise from the dead etc..The gods , we are told , exist only because people worship them . This makes no sense to me. The struggle between the minor gods and Nessagafel, the first god , struck me as a poor imitation of Greek Mythology. The rules of the game were unclear , what the gods could or could not do in relation to each other was never clarified . This left me uninterested in a struggle I could not really follow.
Jorim and the Maicana seemed too much like Cortez and the Aztecs , and Jorim's journey through the nine hells was too much an imitation of Dante's Inferno.
If only the author had kept the magical elements of this trilogy subtle , left out the gods entirely and concentrated on the struggles between the principal , human characters, I would have given it 4 stars. As is, it becomes too much a silly cartoon. A shame.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good - but a little too much, too fast., November 13, 2007
This review is from: The New World: Book Three in The Age of Discovery (Age of Discovery Trilogy) (Paperback)
Remember the last season of Buffy? There were so many characters going through so many things - and so much backstory - that trying to explain it to anyone who wasn't already a fan usually ended up with handing them sets of DVDs.
You'll be just as enthralled with these characters - and drawn along through the vast problems they face - due to thier wonderful and vivid characterization. And there are a LOT of problems. And that's my gripe.
This book should have been two. Or three. Don't get me wrong, it's a fine book, and worth reading. Its presence as the capstone of a good series definitely makes it worth the time to find out what all happens - and a LOT happens.
And that's really the problem. Stuff happens a little too fast. Whipsaw changes in characters - and the world - are fascinating, but they're piled on thick and furious. All of them are consistent with the world and the characters themselves - there are just so damn many that it becomes hard to keep track.
I'm sure that, due to the publishing world, he was locked into a three-book contract. I just wish he'd been able to make this arc span out across a fourth book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Loses Steam, May 30, 2008
I loved the first two books, but this one doesn't hold my interest. A little too much deus ex machina and the story gets muddled due to all of the plots Stackpole has going. I do love his imagination, but i wished he would've kept it a little simpler in this final installment. Overall, a great series though and would recommend it to friends or anyone else who loves fantasy with a twist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No