Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great reference but a little dull for nano-experts, October 22, 2003
This review is from: The Next Big Thing Is Really Small: How Nanotechnology Will Change the Future of Your Business (Hardcover)
If you've heard a little about nanotechnology and wonder about possible impacts on your business or your life, this is the book to read. Those who have already read widely on the subject will find little additional value in the book, other than its function as a comprehensive compendium of current development efforts and potential business impacts. The writing doesn't shine and sometimes has a oddly 1950s feel to it - see the chart on p.24 and the old-fashioned language on p.33 for examples. Despite this, the book performs well if you approach it as a current reference guide to the potentially enormously disruptive group of molecular-scale technologies called "nanotechnology". Authors Uldrich and Newberry devote an unnecessary amount of text to convince the reader than nanotechnology is not science fiction. Those who think it is won't be reading the book, and those who do read it won't need convincing. The upside of this strenuous defensiveness is a wealth of facts and figures for the reader to assess each area of emerging and potential nano-business. The authors draw a sharp line between the more common microtechnologies of today (such as the MEMS sensors that deploy your airbag) and nanoscale technologies that operate at the level of one billionth of a meter. Some approaches to nanotechnology, such as Drexler's vision of self-assembling and replicating nano devices fit this characterization better than many of Uldrich and Newberry's examples yet, oddly, Drexler's name appears nowhere in the book. Ever since IBM scientists woke up the mainstream to the potential of nanotechnology by writing their company's name with 35 xenon atoms (a minute size that would allow "IBM" to be written 350 million times in the space of a single printed period), developments have come ever faster. This book does a good job of showing both how broad and disruptive are the potential applications, and in outlining the probable sequence of developments. They divide the nano realm into nanomeasurement and nanomanipulation, and the latter into nanofabrication (or nanoscale engineering) and self-assembly then explain why the scale of the technology can affect potentially just about every product and industry including health care, materials, energy, inventory management, computers, agriculture, sensors - anything whose products and processes will be changed by the ability to made precise atomic manipulations that affect physical properties of strength, conductivity, and optical, magnetic, and thermal properties. At the end of each chapter you will find a summary of the "nanopoints", including general but helpful prompts to get you thinking proactively about this technology. Toward the end of the book, the authors speculate about nanotechnology's affects on the world past the year 2013. For the long-range perspective they recommend tracking NASA, since its needs for stronger and lighter materials, self-repairing systems or materials, low-power equipment, and so on, would all be met by nano advances. For the next decade, however, I would instead recommend keeping an idea on DARPA (the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency). DARPA's model of innovation and its current areas of interest seem far more promising than that of the embattled and backward space agency.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
This Book Is Really Stupid: How To Irritate Your Readers, March 29, 2004
This review is from: The Next Big Thing Is Really Small: How Nanotechnology Will Change the Future of Your Business (Hardcover)
This book feels like an avalanche of "wow!" stories about these fancy new applications of nano technology. The authors seem not to be interested in at least trying to appear credible. They show too obviously that they have no knowledge whatsoever of how real business works and only want to name as many examples of possible products that will impact almost all companies around, and of course also everyday life. In the beginning of the book, one will feel like forgiving these enthusiasts, but as soon as it is clear they only want to tell their fantastic stories, one just cannot take them seriously any longer. And do not think it will get better in the later chapters, because they are all the same. Uldrich and Newberry love to tell you how much the annual revenues are in all sorts of business segments and then scare all those working there how much these markets will be impacted by nano products. Just some basic laws of economics and common sense do not seem to come to their minds. If their logic would be true, we will see an enormous decline in economic growth, because everything around will soon be replaced by nano products all costing a mere fraction of existing products, lasting many times longer, etcetera, etcetera. Even if such products will be available, they will not be priced very cheaply. Let's make a comparison with computers. These have become thousands of times more powerful than one or two decades ago, but they still cost a lot of money. The authors like to be dramatic, they almost want to scare you what will happen if you do not consider to develop your own nano products. To me, their attitude has rather made me very sceptic about the impact nano technology will have on society. Alright, I believe many things will change in a couple of decades. But come on, be real, and stop claiming there will be all these "disruptive" innovations in these coming years until 2010. Ever heard of the internet bubble? As a final example I would like to illustrate their way of making so to say convincing calculations: "... Macy's spends $250.000 a week just to change signs in its stores..." I don't know how many stores they have (Uldrich and Newberry at least don't bother to mention any such relevant information in any of their comparisons), but checking Macy's website, I think I am safe to estimate the number to be at least 500. That would mean a maximum of $500 per store per week. But perhaps this could be even as low as $100? The authors want to convince us that it would be logical for Macy's to replace all their in-store displays by electronic billboards using nano technology. They do mention all the advantages of such screens (like always up to date information), but "forget" to make a cost comparison. My guess would be that such screens would have an economic life span of 3 years. That would mean Macy's could spend something between $15,000 and $75,000 per store on such screens. I really have got no clue how much these would cost (how many screens are we talking about? how much will be the costs for the devices themselves, the electricity to operate them, the information system to create and distribute all the real time information, etcetera?), but my guess is that it is doubtful Macy's would really be cheaper off. Perhaps they will be 2010, but today? If I were Macy's, I'd wait and see for some more years. The book reads as a superficial article in a magazine for a broad audience, written by a mediocre journalist that seems to find it very important to entertain the reader with very many lively examples, without spending any effort to go into substantial detail at all. The worst thing is that it is way too long. I wouldn't have minded if it was just a couple of pages long. If it had to be so superficial, it could have triggered me with some interesting thoughts about the near future, as long as the authors kept it short and left the fantasizing up to me. But because they just keep going on, the authors leave me with a mixed feeling: in stead of making me a believer of all the possibilities of nano tech in the coming years I have only become sceptic. In that sense, I suppose those who really have an interest in the success of nano tech aren't too happy that Uldrich and Newberry wrote this book in such a poor way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The authors don't contribute any kind of insight., February 25, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: The Next Big Thing Is Really Small: How Nanotechnology Will Change the Future of Your Business (Hardcover)
It's just a book of factoids on nanotechnology. If the book does anything at all it leaves you full of questions. Which I would imagine the one author hopes will lead you to his consultancy (Nano Veritas Group). Which is carefully placed at top of the "Resources" section and gives the following description: "A comprehensive nanotechnology website dedicated to providing the general business reader with relevant nanotechnology news." ... Check out the website to see how "comprehensive" it is and that will give you an idea about the book. :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|