1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Nickelodeon, December 6, 2008
This review is from: Nickelodeon (DVD)
"Nickelodeon" is a marvelous, underrated tribute to early silent comedies. Set in the years 1913-1915, it follows the fast-paced, anarchic style of the early Keystone (Mack Sennett) comedies of the time. Cartoonish physical comedy and sight gags abound. Charlie Chaplin, Harold Lloyd, and Buster Keaton actually entered movies during the years 1913-1918, and several of the images evoke their visual style. Although the film is not speeded up, the pacing is very brisk, suggesting the breakneck pace of that early, ruthless style of comedy.
It may surprise some that "Nickelodeon" is not shot in black and white, not it is a silent picture. However, it takes advantage of color and sound with attractive visuals and a delightful use of contrapuntal dialogue and music. Pay close attention to the songs that the harmonica player supplies on-the-spot. The pace settles down somewhat toward the end, but so did the movies (a la D W Griffith) at that point.
"Nickelodeon" was not critically appreciated when it was released in 1976, probably because the very early silent comedies were not as widely available as they are now. Modern DVDs have enabled the studious (or enthusiastic) film comedy historian to become much more familiar with (an appreciative of) the relentless comedy style of the 19-teens.
This is knockabout comedy at its best.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"Kathleen Cooke"-An Irresistible Screen Heroine, August 30, 2006
This review is from: Nickelodeon (DVD)
Oddly this is a film that I have always liked and still make a point to watch when it is televised. I say "oddly" because I find Peter Bogdanovich and Ryan O'Neal excellent examples of two people pretty much clueless about their chosen professions. Bogdanovich was a journalist/critic/film theorist turned director (who had the bad taste to be involved with Cybill Shepperd) and O'Neal was a Hollywood personality who occasionally acted (who had the good taste to marry Leigh Taylor-Young).
Jane Hitchcock is the most interesting thing about "Nickelodeon". Hitchcock was a magazine model who Bogdanovich hoped to groom into a star. Bogdanovich historically has had a weakness for beautiful women of marginal talent (Shepherd and Dorothy Stratten's sister come to mind). Unlike the others, Hitchcock was quickly turned off by both Bogdanovich and the movie game-she already had a lucrative modeling career and didn't have to put up with the Hollywood starlet system. Whether Hitchcock would have made it big in movies is hard to tell, but in "Nickelodeon's" "Kathleen Cooke" she found a character she could play with wide-eyed innocence and complete sincerity. While it doesn't hurt that Hitchcock is drop dead gorgeous, her Kathleen Cooke character is more than gorgeous, she is absolutely captivating. Which makes her completely believable as the object of the movie's love triangle and elevates her to the top of my list of the all-time most irresistible screen heroines (even ahead of Fay Wray's "Ann Darrow" and Clara's Bow's "Mary Preston").
But "Kathleen Cooke" is not the only good thing about "Nickelodeon". It has one of cinema's all time funniest sequences. O'Neal arrives by train at a remote shooting location out west. He steps off the train at a watering stop and looks out over the desert to the movie set 500 yards away. The sun is high overhead baking the desert landscape and O'Neal is not enthusiastic about the prospect of walking that far in such heat. A tiny dog with the movie company spots him from that distance and begins running toward him. The dog is making a bee-line for him, as it gets closer we wait for the happy reunion, but when it arrives it immediately bites his leg. The dog hates him so much that it was willing to run that far in the hot sun just for the opportunity to attack him.
It also is an excellent and generally accurate history lesson about the early days of movies and the serendipity that determined who became involved with the new industry. Serendipity is the theme of the film and the source of most of its comedy, as the expanding talent needs of the new movie industry were often met by whoever they happened to encounter at a particular moment and not through any systematic process. Thus Burt Reynolds (in his best comic performance) becomes a stunt man only because at that moment they need a stunt man and he needs a job. A running gag is his boastful declaration with each new job that the job title (whatever it might be) is his middle name. An especially good sequence shows how in those days milestones like "Birth of a Nation" would periodically set the bar higher throughout film history, inspiring those within the industry to stretch themselves to do better work.
Ryan O'Neal is fairly low-key and therefore tolerable. In addition to Hitchcock and Reynolds, Bogdanovich gets excellent performances from Tatum O'Neal (great negotiating sequences), John Ritter, Stella Stevens and Brian Keith.
The main problem with "Nickelodeon" is that the depth and breathe of early film history is too complicated for a small comedic treatment. As a film historian Bogdanovich was dealing with a subject near and dear to his heart. He appears to have borrowed heavily from Fellini's "Variety Lights" and "White Sheik" to construct his company of players but could not integrate the intimate and light-hearted flavor of those films with the huge historical subject he was documenting. "Nickelodeon" is still entertaining and informative but the whole is less that the sum of its parts.
Then again, what do I know? I'm only a child.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
no title, May 17, 2008
This review is from: Nickelodeon (DVD)
I remembered ordering it, when I got it. It was scratched and returned it and got my money back. So I didn't re-ordered it. I don't know how the film is!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
