4.0 out of 5 stars
A heady stroll through Nietzsche..., September 5, 2007
This review is from: Nietzsche: The Great Philosophers (The Great Philosophers Series) (Paperback)
This small essay takes a stroll through Nietzsche's life and thought. Using literary style as a sort of glue for the sporadic discussion, the book examines how "Nietzsche's voices" helped shape his thinking. An ominous and rhythmically pounding passage from "The Gay Science," where a madman announces the "death of God," appropriately opens the book, preceded by the statement: "Unless you believe in God, you cannot believe that God is Dead: an entity which never existed cannot die."
Not surprisingly, the text soon conjures up the voice of Zarathustra, Nietzsche's most prolonged literary device. Long sweeping passages from this famous, and potentially misleading, work pervade the entire book. First off, Zarathustra is scrutinized as a parody or self-referential voice for Nietzsche's deep religious upbringing. His father was a Lutheran pastor. At this point the book goes in several directions but it remains anchored in the question and utility of literary voice. These disparate directions include: Nietzsche's physical ailments, his aphoristic style, the comparison to Oscar Wilde's prose, Wagner as hysteric, the absence of God, the Dionysian, self-division, the illusion of truth, his rejection of Christian morality, his abortive run-in with Lou Salomé, philosophy as biography, Christian morality as "slave morality," the ascetic will, his attacks on language and logic ("Logic is an attempt to comprehend actuality by means of a scheme of being we have ourselves proposed"), his dismissal of the law of contradiction, the late works, and his eventual descent into madness.
The book argues that Nietzsche's fiddlings with voice provided him a playground and a tool for expressing unconventional ideas as well as doubt about the shaky foundations of language. Regardless of his unique beautiful prose rife with alternating tones and mood, the book claims that "Nietzsche failed to break the habit sanctioned by over two thousand years of philosophizing - the habit of worshipping the truth." Was Nietzsche then also writing a "confession" and his own "involuntary unconscious memoir?"
As the discussion segues towards that most famous of topics, Nietzsche's madness, the book seems to blame his highly unconventional thought for the onset of dire megalomania followed by incoherence. Venereal disease as a prognosis comes up only very late in the book. But the author then argues, "it is improbable that the delusions of grandeur or the breakdown had anything to do with syphilis." Does this imply that Nietzsche's first phase of "madness" was brought on by mere thinking and isolation? Such claims run the risk of romanticizing Nietzsche's ailments and philosophy, though no one really knows what caused this famous malady.
Lastly, the book questions Nietzsche's very questioning of the fundamentals of our existence, such as language, truth, and the self. The final page insinuates that Nietzsche may have gone too far, as alternates or answers to these challenges have not appeared over a century later. It all ends there, leaving the reader to ponder the implications of digging gopher holes beneath our everyday assumptions.
Though this sliver-sized book packs a mere 58 pages, it takes on a multitude of topics. The argument also meanders in and out of digressions, long quotes, biography, and exegesis. As such, beginners may find the road a rough and turbulent one, though perseverance will pay off. As a snapshot of one element of Nietzsche's philosophy, the book succeeds in combining many diverse and interesting topics into a coherent whole. Along the way it also peels back a small layer of Nietzsche's literary side. He definitely used voice to the utmost.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
VERY GOOD BOOK!, July 28, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Nietzsche: The Great Philosophers (The Great Philosophers Series) (Paperback)
If you don't know much about Nietzsche, then you should read this little book. I'm still reading it and I'm enjoying it very much!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No