Most Helpful Customer Reviews
102 of 111 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Night of Blunders is more like it, October 15, 2008
Stephen Hunter has long been one of my favorite writers but he is sorely trying my patience after his last two releases. His first book or two, back in the eighties, I'm thinking The Master Sniper, were OK, but then he wrote the first Bob Lee Swagger book, Point of Impact, and it, and everything that came after until 47th Samurai, was six star genius. In fact, Stephen Hunter became my favorite writer, even edging out James Lee Burke, and Hunter's novels Dirty White Boys and Pale Horse Coming are two of my favorite books ever. I bought half a dozen copies of Pale Horse Coming so I could give them as treasured presents to my brothers and friends. Then came 47th Samurai, a ridiculous excuse for a book in many ways, and ruined what had been a run of stupefyingly good books for many years. I'll forgive an author, particularly Hunter, for a bad book once, but with the release of Night of Thunder, I have to say I am officially ticked off and offended. This book would have been a three star book if it had been written by a new author, but for a talented veteran like Hunter, this is one or two star fare at best and I can't help but feel betrayed. Why are so many good writers releasing such sub-par books in the last two years? Where is the pride one should have in accomplishment? Is it just about money now? This feels a little like finding Shakespeare cranking out harlequin romances simply because it pays better. Shame on Stephen Hunter for foisting this pap on us. The man who writes Pale Horse Coming should have more pride than to publish a book like this. In Night of Thunder, Bob Lee's oldest daughter is forced from the road in attempted vehicular manslaughter in Tennessee and is in a coma. Bob goes to investigate and ultimately finds a clan of Arkansas criminals trying to commit a heist at a Nascar race. They tried to kill his daughter to keep the plan from coming out so Bob gets to shoot them all by the end of the book. So what is bad about this book? Everything. Bob Lee has gone from a three-dimensional complex and cunning character to a cartoon, the villains are also cartoonish and speak in some kind of argot which is supposed to be Southern but which isn't. They don't use contractions and speak long convoluted sentences beyond their intellectual capability. The plot is direct, simple and ultimately cartoonish too. So no character development, stupid unbelievable villains, lame plot. Can you tell I'm upset? I've purchased every Stephen Hunter novel the day it was released in hard cover for the last ten years. No more. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. If you want a great "guy" reading experience go back to Point of Impact and start reading forward from there. Stop when you get to 47th Samurai and do not read it. It will ruin all the wonderful times you had up until then. Certainly do not bother with Night of Blunders. I think Hunter needs to stop writing about the Swaggers now and move on. I hope he writes a new novel that restores my faith in him, but I will wait for paperback for his next book and check the reviews before I even buy that. This book is strike two for Hunter, and if his next book is strike three then I am done.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 52 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Painful to Read, October 9, 2008
I'd like a refund for this book as well as the 47th Samurai. Never again will I read a Stephen Hunter novel and at one time, he was my favorite author. I've read everything that he has published and unfortunately, his work of late has been very disappointing. He has done a great disservice to both his fans and the great Bob Lee Swagger. Night of Thunder had more holes in it than a Bob Lee target at 50 feet. The plot had potential with a gang of mountain men trying to kill Nikki, Bob Lee's daughter. However, the characters were just plain boring and the dialog was senseless. The local Sheriff was a retired Army Ranger Colonel. The hillbilly gang was from Polk County and Hot Springs, Arkansas. The detective was a champion marksman. How would they have not heard of the Swaggers? References to NASCAR and the Bristol motor speedway were just plain wrong. I'm sure it took me longer to get through it than it did for Mr. Hunter to write it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
40 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Bob is back, just not 100%..., September 27, 2008
Being an avid Stephen Hunter fan since reading Point of Impact, I found the caricature that is Bob Lee to be a fascinating and welcome resurgence to the long forgotten "real man's" hero. Since Hunter missed the mark on the last few books--namely The 47th Samurai--I have been waiting for Hunter to return to his forte, namely the ability to write a tightly woven story intertwined with realistic gun fights. To my surprise Night of Thunder attempts to bring back Bob Lee and all his skills to once again amaze the reader. I don't want to waste your time going over the story but I will address a few points that stopped me from giving this book a better rating. 1) It is very difficult to not compare Hunter's latest books against his 2 pinnacles of achievement: Dirty White Boys, and Point of Impact. Each of those novels contained an excellent story, properly edited, and allowed you to fall in love with the protagonist and antagonist. It just seems that Hunter hasn't been able to achieve that kind of storytelling in his latest books. 2) While Bob Lee has returned in this novel, I felt separated from who he is and what he has become. The author has left holes in the story that the readers are supposed to fill in with what we know of Bob Swagger. I think Hunter needs to return to the basics and write about Bob Lee so anyone can pick up the book with as little confusion as possible and read on. 3) The plot of this book seems a little childish, and the enemies as well as the people Bob bumps into along the way are nothing more than mere words on a page. I do not connect with any of them, and I certainly feel they could have been better written (those of you who have read Dirty White Boys know what I am talking about). Lastly, maybe it is time for Hunter to retire Bob and find another anti-hero. I, along with many of you would mourn the loss of Bob the "Nailer" but I also hate to see Mr. Swagger driven through terrible plot twists that only make sense in the story due to the author placing much of the story telling burden on Bob. Anyway, I give it 3 stars. I wanted to give it 4 as at times I felt like I was reading the old Bob Lee books, but the story lacks any real appeal. I will give Hunter a decent pat on the back for continually trying to bring Bob back; I just keep waiting for a good story to go along with it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|