Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worth waiting (about 30 yrs) for..., June 15, 2009
This review is from: No Certainty Attached: Steve Kilbey and The Church (Paperback)
The Church now bears the distinction of being one of the HANDFUL of artists who've successfully endured a decade (in this case, longer) of commercial disfavor...during which time they continued to progress.
The reasons for the stalling of their commercial career are, ostensibly, the usual stuff of rock bios - addiction, poor decisions, etc.
But what's singularly inspiring about the story of Kilbey & The Church is how intransigently DOGGED they've been about carrying on.
Comebacks/re-inventions are one thing for artists established on a more substantial scale - usually, upbeat pop musicians.
But carrying on is quite another matter when you're a maestro in the subsets where melancholia and psychedelia overlap.
Not exactly commercial.
Best known to the general public for "Under the Milky Way," The Church crested with their mid-period Arista recording (Starfish, 1988). Fortunes began declining shortly after this "breakthrough moment." But Kilbey/The Church managed to persevere, eventually accumulating a remarkable catalogue spanning solo releases, collaborations, session work, & production credits.
A testament to purist pursuit of a singularly uncompromising vision. Maybe the public will catch on.
Meanwhile, supplement the reading of this book with Kilbey's weblog - [...]- probably the most deprecating, challenging, & insightful daily glimpse at the psyche of an unjustly overlooked industry veteran available anywhere, published or virtual.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Disenchanted Portrait, August 12, 2009
This review is from: No Certainty Attached: Steve Kilbey and The Church (Paperback)
Robert Lurie's book on the Australian band, The Church, is welcome for those us with more than a passing interest in the group and its bassist, lyricist and lead vocalist Steve Kilbey. It required a determined fan to take on the project, as the band are not a popular enough subject for a by-the-numbers journalist to tackle. They passed the point long ago when their story could be perceived as a surefire check waiting to be cashed. So who will read this? People like me, that are obsessed with the music and the myth of Steve Kilbey and wanted an in depth examination of the history--the rise, the disintegration and the resurrection of my favorite musical group to emerge in the 80s, and their unique, mysterious and haunting musical offerings.
Vacillating between a fan's ernest attempt at an objective but sympathetic biography, and an ernest fan's need to elevate his random opinions of albums, songs and lyrics to published status, the book both illuminates and frustrates. His persistence is admirable and the access he was granted to Kilbey and Peter Koppes, one of the bands guitarists, does make this a valuable document. Photos and reminiscences from friends and associates do give us a reasonable glimpse of the brilliant and purposefully enigmatic Kilbey. He does not shy away from the sensationalistic aspects of the story or dwell excessively upon them; they are essential to understanding the erratic course of the band's tenure.
It is his insistence upon subjecting the reader to his evaluation of particular songs, albums and lyrics (usually ones he can't abide) that undermine the virtues of his research, and drag the book down to the level of a fan's chat room. We really don't care how little he likes Michael Stipe and REM, but it is when he offhandedly dismisses a major album like Uninvited Like The Clouds, while relentlessly examining a minor one like Seance, that he fails utterly as a rock critic. There is no discography, something the vast Church canon truly requires--official albums, bootlegs, side projects, solo works etc. It would have served the fans well to have this information in printed form.
As a biography I give it 4 stars, his writing is not particularly strong, but works well enough considering he is really a musician and a fan first. As a critic he gets 2 stars for inconsistent and arbitrary analysis of the music. I do recommend it to any die hard fan of the group, we may never see another thorough study of the band's origins and career. As to whether Kilbey really is captured here, it does seem to pull away a couple layers of his mystique, and present the man and artist honestly. You do get the feeling, however, there is much more that will never be told.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One certainty: this is a great read!, June 17, 2009
This review is from: No Certainty Attached: Steve Kilbey and The Church (Paperback)
This is a great read for both fans of The Church OR fans of rock & roll history in general. Of course the long time fans will be eager to read this - but unlike many rock-biographies, I believe this book would be an enlightening & enjoyable read for a much broader audience.
This book covers so many facets of Steve Kilbey's life (and the band's as well). It explores the early formulative years & experiences which helped shape the artist, the early encounters that allowed the musician to grow & the band to form. NO CERTAINTY also gives brilliant insights into what went on behind the scenes during the tours, the demoing & studio recordings of the albums, the hardships & struggles. It gives insight into the creative processes, the lyrics and the evolution of the band as well as the artist.
Well written, fascinating to read and full of thought provoking narrative that will keep you turning the pages! I have missed sleep three nights in a row over this book :-)
GET IT!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|