From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3 The author of
Smog the City Dog (Chronicle, 2002) introduces readers to another canine protagonist on the receiving end of a life lesson. Napoleon, a seafaring pup, discovers a tropical paradise. When he lands on shore, he meets Bear, Crab, and Bunny, who welcome him with a special dinner and offer to help him build a home. Napoleon, who has big plans for his abode, takes advantage of his new friends' hospitality, barking orders and bossing them around. Before long, the self-crowned King and his enormous residence overtake the tiny island. Fed up with the dog's selfishness, the other animals decide to find another haven. Napoleon discovers that being alone isn't fun and persuades them to return by repairing the damage done to the isle and demonstrating his ability to cooperate. The cartoon artwork reflects the island's ecology; when everything is in balance, the dominant colors are verdant greens, but after Napoleon destroys it, gloomy dark clouds rain on his gray, imposing dwelling. The characters are expressive and interesting. Children will recognize the dog's mistakes and empathize with the other animals. In the appropriate ending, a seafaring cat sets her sights on the now-restored paradise, pointing out that ecological conservation is an ongoing challenge. Teachers will find this non-didactic approach to the themes of respect for the environment and for others an enjoyable vehicle to encourage discussion.
Carol L. MacKay, Forestburg School Library, Alberta, Canada Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
K-Gr. 2. While exploring, a dog named Napoleon discovers a paradise island, but three friends--Crab, Bunny, and Bear--arrived before him. No problem for this can-do canine. He simply moves in and takes over, persuading the three agreeable amigos to help him build his dream house. Since this little dog has big ideas, the house quickly turns into a castle, and Napoleon proudly proclaims himself king. Talk about abusing hospitality! Worse, there's now no room for Crab, Bunny, and Bear, who set sail for a nearby island. There they do some proclaiming of their own: there's no room for Napoleon! No, this isn't the end of the story. In a neat touch, the tale continues onto the back endpapers and promises more adventures to come. Meserve's light touch makes for a gently humorous book about friendship and sharing.
Michael CartCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
