10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Horribly, Painfully, Fatally Overwritten, October 28, 2004
This review is from: The Normals: A Novel (Hardcover)
I bought this book without ever having heard of the author, on the basis of the premise alone, which I thought was terrific. I knew I was in trouble on page one, when he referred to a small stack of boxes as a Frankenstein's monster. Uh-oh. A Clever Guy. He knows how to use metaphors, he just doesn't know how to use them well. It only gets worse from there; one can actually watch the author struggle to bend the prose around in order to describe things for which he's thought up clever things to say. Trouble is, the many, many, MANY descriptions, always weighted down with surprisingly terrible metaphors, don't provide any insight, only distractions.
I found myself almost shouting at the book at times; for example, the sentence: "Mirages from earlier times-bakeries and butchers mostly-float between handbag boutiques and restaurants. "Really?" I thought. "The bakeries and butchers FLOAT?" But fine, I'll overlook that one too if we can just get to the plot. Maybe when he has to make the character DO something, he'll stop doing that. I don't know if he ever did get around to writing the actual book or if I quit it with several hundred more pages of leaden adjectives yet to come, but I gave up on page 46. I just couldn't take it. Shame, too. It's such an interesting premise. Somebody should write a book that uses it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
All Dressed Up, But No Place to Go, December 5, 2005
This review is from: The Normals: A Novel (Hardcover)
I discovered David Gilbert's THE NORMALS by chance and picked it up with delicious anticipation based on its story premise. Billy Schine is a drifting and disaffected young man, as distant from his Asian girlfriend as he is from his parents, college educated but working as a temp, buried under $60,000 worth of student loans - a "normal"GenXer. In a misguided effort to evade a knee-breaking collection agency, he enrolls as a human guinea pig in a paid pharmaceutical research project for Hargrove Anderson Medical (HAM). Along with a dozen other people, Billy commits to a paid, two-week study in which the physical and psychological effects of an unspecified drug will be carefully monitored to establish its baseline impact on the unsick, the "normals."
Given this premise, an infinite range of possibilities blossoms before one's eyes. Could THE NORMALS be another ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO'S NEST, with every subject saner than Randall McMurphy (Jack Nicholson's character in the movie)? Could it be an exploration of the irrelevance of the concept of normalcy in modern society? An attempt to redefine it? Or maybe it could be an examination of the role of pharmaceuticals in a grossly over-medicated society? Or a treatise of the ethical quandaries of drug testing, or their misuse and manipulation?
So many choices, none taken. Mr. Gilbert, inarguably a gifted crafter of cutting sarcasm and a wonderfully clever wordsmith, opted instead to surround his Everyman with a carnival sideshow of dysfunctional characters and a bizarre plot twist that moves his story from comic cynicism to outlandish science fiction. Billy Schine's "normal" colleagues turn out to be freakish stereotypes: a lone female striking a nymphomaniac's pose, an religious zealot named Jay ("Do") Rami who suffers from violent impulses and refuses to bathe, a pair of thuggish droolers named Ossap and Dullick who ultimately reveal a bizarre political agenda, a self-styled acting genius named Lannigan who shaves his entire body, and a misfit named Frank Gershin whose hobby involves paying exorbitant sums to have gunshot wounds inflicted upon himself (body piercing and cutting apparently having given way to stronger stimuli). Billy befriends a black version of Nurse Rached who, like all similarly stereotyped black women, really has a heart of gold (her name is Joy, naturally) beneath that gruff exterior. He also discovers that the doctor in charge of monitoring and administrating these studies, Honeysack, is also an absurdly unlikely researcher into cryogenics who is looking for a volunteer. Combine all this with the simultaneous saga of Billy's father's imminent plan for a double suicide of himself and his Alzeihmer's-afflicted wife, and the entire brew makes the cast of characters from Gilligan's Island the The Addam's Family look like "the normals."
The dissolution of Gilbert's premise and plot line is particularly disappointing when set beside his estimable writing talent. His prose is sparklingly pyrotechnic, filled with wonderful observations and memorable turns of phrase that make you want to dog ear every page and highlight for future recall. Gilbert's writing alone makes this book a worthwhile read, and it promises the hope for deeper and more meaningful things to come.
Good satire can be entertaining and funny when it has a point. The problem with THE NORMALS is that it's only point seems to be that there is no point, that life is simply too absurd to take anything seriously. This is fine as the world view for an eighteen-year-old adolescent, but it's simply not the stuff of good literature. The book's paperback cover cites an irresponsibly lavish quote from Publisher's Weekly, "Gilbert writes in the vein of Vonnegut, Heller, and Kesey, updated for the 21st Century." If THE NORMALS is 21st Century Vonnegut, woe betide us for the next ten decades. Readers in 2099 will still be celebrating Mr. Vonnegut's genius, but by then, THE NORMALS will have faded to dusty yellowed parchment -- or its digital equivalent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
disappointing, November 19, 2004
This review is from: The Normals: A Novel (Hardcover)
Gilbert is a very bright and able writer. I had read the reviews for "The Normals" and liked the premise very much - overeducated New Yorker, up to his eyeballs in debt, decides to get out of town and participate in a risky drug study.
The problem is Gilbert feels compelled to describe everything in copious detail. This gets so bad that it slows down the story. Some of his observations are dead-on and I laughed hard. However, most of the time I felt he was trying too hard.
The ending was terrible and I skimmed the last 40 pages.
I hear good things about "Remote Feed" and will try that next. Gilbert needs to relax and just let the story flow a bit more. Hopefully the next novel he writes will be his "The Russian Debutante's Handbook" or "Motherless Brooklyn." He certainly has the talent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No