Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not the End of the World, January 3, 2007
If you're looking for a slavish retelling of the Bible story about Noah and the Flood, this book isn't for you. If you're hoping to read a book about pretty rainbows and obedient doves, this isn't for you. But if you want a story that will grip you from the beginning to the end with a realistic cast of human and animal characters, a plot that will keep you on the edge of your chair, and a setting that is both horrific and fascinating, then you must read this masterful book. Timna, Noah's daughter, is the main character and hero. What? You've never heard of her? Was she just another invisible woman from the Bible? Timna herself realizes the truth: " `Shem, Ham, and Japheth: sons of Noah.' They are the only ones who will be mentioned a hundred years from now when people tell our story. I know I won't figure" (p. 2). You must read until the very end to discover Timna's fate. Timna isn't the only narrator in this book. Her three brothers, their wives, her mother, and even some of the suffering animals tell the tale from their various points of view. Each voice is expressive; each voice has a different cadence and leads us to a deeper understanding of the catastrophe of the Flood. Interestingly, Noah does not tell his side of the story. The author portrays him as a religious fanatic, a monomaniac. She leads us to question whether he is as "blameless" as the Bible story would suggest. Almost all the people on the Ark are cast in an unflattering light. After all, Noah's family saved themselves while thousands of people drowned: "The water boiled with people. They were swimming, or clutching hold of logs, doors, cartwheels. Animals, too, were swimming among them--dogs and horses, cattle, goats. The sky was full of displaced birds, circling, circling, with nowhere to land" (p.11). However, the family's faults--large and small--make them seem more human. Not likeable, but human. McCaughrean tells this story through powerful language and imagery. The sensory world engulfs us. "Below us, in the bowels of the ship, along its entire length, beasts squealed and shrieked and keened, scrabbling with claws and talons and tails for some purchase on the rolling world . . . . Huge mounds of hot dung slid about the decking, dislodging small creatures in their path" (p.6). What did we expect? That all these animals would quietly behave themselves during the forty days and nights and all the claustrophobic days thereafter while they waited for the waters to recede? The Flood was not a pretty sight. Touches of humor and irony occasionally relieve the tragic events. Timna states: "No shortage of jobs for any of us. The end of the world is a busy time if you mean to outlive it" (p. 5). Without giving away the ending, let us say that some small hope sustains the survivors (and the reader). And perhaps even a grain of faith. In our time of natural disasters--hurricanes, tidal waves, earthquakes--the ancient story of Noah and the flood hits uncomfortably close to home. Highly recommended for ages 12 - 18. Reviewed by Anne Dublin
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Need Read, December 19, 2005
Every teenager raised in a religious world, whether you're christian, jewish, or anything for that matter, should take a day to sit down and read this book. I myself am a huge fan of religiously themed books, and when I picked this one up at the library I wasn't expecting what I got. Luckily the book is very quick read and I feel it is intended for those mature enough to understand death and religious themes, probably 15+ though I am sure some exceptions can be made. It is interesting to view Noah's Ark in a different light as we are all so used to the Christian happy story of people and animals living harmoniosly* in a boat for a few days... with sunshine and all that jazz, but this puts a very real spin on the everyday tale puts it in the perspective the way I feel the story was meant to be told, even though not completely factual. I suggest this book to anyone who is interested in religion or raised religiously and wants to delve deeper into their origins.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Beyond flannelgraph, January 8, 2007
I have often wondered how we can raise our children with a knowledge of the Bible without presenting its people as one-dimensional flannelgraph characters. I know I've struggled all my life to see God's people as just that, people. While some people are not willing to entertain fictional retellings of Bible stories, I can see from reading this book that it is an exercise that can enhance your faith rather than destroy it. No, you will not get a theologically sound version of the Bible story here. Stop looking for it. What you will get is a very real sense of a disaster of this proportion. You'll experience the claustrophobia, the pettiness, the annoyances, the hardships, the revulsion, the agonizing split-second decisions that characterize daily life, wherever it happens to be unfolding. While the characters too often are painted as black-and-white, all good or all bad, some nuances are evident, especially in the character of Noah. Our society too often depicts devoutly religious people as unsavory fanatics. Noah's faith and trust in God is not mocked here, but rather presented as a rock-solid moral compass. The members of his family may view that compass differently, some scorning it, but it is not in itself dismissed. I appreciated that. I think what surprised me most was that this book, in the children or young adults category, is a gripping read for an adult, too. I haven't found that to be the case for many YA books. It has broadened my view of the Bible, helping me to imagine the very real people in its all-too-brief stories. You may not necessarily think that's a good thing, but I would say, read it for yourself before deciding.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
book review
The tidal wave came, and just as soon as it came, it passed. Timna, and her father Noah, her mother Ama, her brothers Japheth, Shem, Ham, their wives Zillah, Bashemath, Sarai, the...
Read more
Published on January 13, 2006
|