14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Delightful French Operetta, or Lightweight Musical Comedy, February 18, 2005
This review is from: Not on the Lips (DVD)
Perhaps you want to know something about the star of 'Amelie' first. But facts first. Based on the operetta first staged in 1925, 'Not on the Lips' ('Pas Sur La Bouche!') is a lightweight musical comedy, starring Sabine Azema, Isabella Nanty, Audrey Tautou, Pierre Arditi, Darry Cowl, Jalil Lespert, Daniel Prevost, and Lambert Wilson (the mysterious French character in 'Matrix Reloaded/Revolutions').
So this is a comedy with ensemble cast. Regardless of what you see on the DVD cover, Audrey Tautou's role is not big, but not small. That, however, does not change the fact that 'Not on the Lips' is a fun to watch for the fans of operetta, or kind of silly but delightful, old-fashioned farce with little songs and neat art deco.
The film, which does not hide its stage origin, is divided into three 'acts.' The story starts when George (Arditi) rather pompously tells of his theory about love -- he says, to any woman, the first love is always the best love. Little does he know that his wife Gilberte (Azema) was (fleetingly) married to an American, one Eric Thompson (Wilson), and to her great surprise, Eric is coming to her house as her unsuspecting husband's business partner.
Thus, as the rules of farce, the mistaken (and hidden) identities and door slamming complicate the situations. Things get more confusing (and funny) when starry-eyed Huguette (Tautou) falls in love with the hunky 'artist' Charley (Lespert), who in turn chases Gilberte .... and so on an on. Can't you follow the relations now? It's okay, anyway, you can when you see the film itself.
The film is full of playful songs (sung by the cast), and they are mostly enjoyable, though they might sound repetitous. The problems is not that; it is, probably non-French-speaking audience would not fully appreciate the joy that these songs and dialogus convey. (I must confess that I, being a Japanese, couldn't.) Plenty of puns like 'Cubism' and 'CooCoo-ism' could be heard, but many of them just flew over my head.
And as the film retains some of the now out-of-date values and manners (intentionally, I guess), you may be slightly embarrassed, hearing the phoney 'American' English -- hear Lambert Wilson's 'WHATDDYA SAY' -- or seeing a hunk who looks like Rudolph Valentino.
But the film succeeds in creating the joyful mood, and though the contents are slight, it is great to see the glitteringly gorgeous costumes that none of us would wear today. For someone like veteran director Alain Resnais ('Last Year at Marienbad' and many many others), it must be an easy job. (By the way, he was born in 1922.)
It's a fluff, to be sure, but in a way it's an admirable job, for, even among the recent revival of musicals, no one can and would make a film like this today -- these charming songs you might hear on old LP records, the fluffy clothes, and talk about 'resque' that is no longer 'risque' these days. You may like it, ot hate it. I happen to like it, and charming Audrey Tautou too, that's why 4 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
One of the Year's Best Films, April 23, 2005
This review is from: Not on the Lips (DVD)
Despite not getting a theatrical release Alain Resnais' ("Hiroshima mon amour") "Not On The Lips" is without doubt one of the best films I've seen this year. How sad that the movie will not be opened to larger audiences as this was one of the few films I've seen where I can say I had a lot of fun watching it.
"Not On The Lips" is a throwback to those wonderful comedies and musicals that were made back in the 1930's. Resnais says one of his main sources of inspiration were the Hal Roach comedies. Roach for those that don't know was a comedy producer who had such stars as Laurel & Hardy, Charlie Chase, and Zasu Pitts.
The film is really just eye candy. It is filmmed in bright lavish colors with characters wearing glamorous glowns and tuxedos. And everybody is singing about love. The only other recent movie I can think of to compare this movie to, in order to give you an idea of what to expect is a movie Woody Allen made a few years back called "Everyone Says I Love You". Both films carry a sentimentality of 30's cinema.
Gilberte Valandray (Sabine Azema) is married to Georges (Pierre Arditi) but has a lover, Charley (Jalil Lespert) now is just so happens that Huguette a friend secretly has a crush on Charley and wants to marry him. So the two women fight for his attention. Now Georges is a business man who is about to close a big deal for his company with an American, Eric Thomas (Lambert Wilson). But, what Georges doesn't know is that Gilberte was married before to Eric. Now Gilberte and her sister, Arlette (Isabelle Nanty) must try an convince Eric not to reveal Gilberte's secret. But Eric is still in love with Gilberte. And that's "Not On The Lips" is a nutshell. It's really a broad bedroom farce, though I don't know if that term is used anymore.
I found that I enjoyed most of the musical numbers which come from a 1920's comic opera written by Andre Barde. The last three songs I didn't like especially a song about a key hole.
Now that you know the plot I think it's fairly easy to decide if this is "your kind of movie". If you've enjoyed past films from Resnais, this should please you. If you've never heard of Alain Resnais but like old-fashioned musical-comedies, this just please you as well. I hope many people make an effort to see this gem of a movie.
Bottom-line: One of the best films I've seen this year. A throwback to the musical\comedies of the 1930's. Greatly inspired by the Hal Roach comedies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable museum piece, July 11, 2005
This review is from: Not on the Lips (DVD)
Imagine Woody Allen unearthing a naughty 1920s play, maybe one written by Mae West, with a few catchy patter songs in it. Imagine Woody casting it with attractive stars who can't all sing too well and setting it in a set that is handsome but stage bound, with a mobile, almost dancing camera. Now you can imagine what "Pas Sur La Bouche" is like. As a Frenchman, I enjoyed hugely all the musty puns, the daffy songs and all the silliness. My American wife could not stand five minutes of it. It is all very "boulevard," with asides to the audience and a lot of "Ciel, Mon Mari" situations. If you are in the mood for a French museum piece, you will love this. Otherwise...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
