Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Not a Stick Hardcover – December 26, 2007
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
From Publishers Weekly
More About the AuthorsDiscover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.
Top Customer Reviews
While the book is fine on its own, it's too slavishly similar to "Not a Box." Whether it's the author or the publisher making that decision, I don't know. I do know that my boys, who loved "Not a Box"--and rightly so--they like this just fine, but it's nothing special. The original has been read ad infinitum in the last year, and to this day. This has been in the house for less than a week, and it's already passe.
Even without "Not a Box" for comparison, I've got to say, the pig just is not as engaging a hero as the bunny. It's a fine book when you read it in the store, but would you really want to read it over and over and over? Some of the phrasing is awkward--"look where you're going with that stick," likely done to avoid overusing the word "watch," which is in the very next line--and the lovely sound and rhythm that came from pairing "not" and "box" is lost here.
The similarly creative, and creativity-encouraging, "Harold and the Purple Crayon" books each build on the previous and go to new places, new worlds. Right now, I'm afraid of the same repetition that hit the "if you give a blank a blank" books. Or even "The Very Adjective Insect" by Eric Carle. (Blasphemy, I know.) I don't want to see that happen, because based on "Not a Box," I think Ms. Portis may be better than that.
That being said, I know I wouldn't be buying "Not a Ball," "Not a Chair," "Not a Sock," "Not a Hoop" or "Not a Blanket." We get it. Please, show us something new, something more.
And then... Not A Stick arrived in our bookstore! Thank you! Thank you! Ms. Portis. The pig is adorable, my girls are happy, they yell "It's not a stick!" just like the refrain from Box. We're all enjoying the fun new drawings of the pig's imagination.
Not A Stick, Not-A-Moment too soon!!!
This charming sequel to Not a Box is a treasure in it's own right. An ode to those who find the world more interesting than the plastic schlock that's mass-produced for them to play with, Not A Stick is perfect for the imaginative child in your life, or the college kid who thinks outside the stick. Move over Wilber, Portis' piggy is an adorable addition to the pantheon of ovine literary heroes.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
While this book may be fine for young children it will likely not be of that much interest to most older children and adults. I get the point. Read morePublished 4 days ago by 1234
My students loved this book. The illustrations are lovely and the kids live listening to the imagination at work.Published 2 months ago by Emerald knit
Great kids book. My boys absolutely enjoy it. Nothing like a stick (or not a stick) to provide endless hours of imaginative play - maybe a not a box.Published 3 months ago by Eric
Super cute book! Great way for children to learn how to use their imaginations!Published 3 months ago by Megan G.
After giving my oldest grandson Not a Box - I had to give this to the next grandson. And the 2 year old loves it!!Published 5 months ago by Debra A. Murray