2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
COMPASSIONATE, COMPELLING HUMAN PORTRAITS, January 15, 2002
This review is from: A Nurse's Story and Others (Hardcover)
The stories in this volume are incredibly well-written and moving -- Peter Baida was obviously a talented, caring writer. I was unfamiliar with him or with his work until I chanced upon this book on the 'recent fiction' shelf at the library -- I'm really glad I picked it up.
The stories here deal with people we might consider to be ordinary until we read about them. The love of his characters gives Baida the power to flesh them out fully, to make them whole -- to make us care about them. Mostly told as reflections on their pasts, they depict turning points -- times at which we are given a choice to make in our lives or in our actions. The characters don't always make the best choices -- as in real life, hindsight is much clearer that our 'real time' options -- but Baida passes no judgements upon them. He presents the facts of their lives and allows us to draw our own conclusions. Even those characters whose choices are poor -- even reprehensible -- are not without their redeeming qualities, rather like the human beings who populate this globe.
Baida's narrative powers are immense -- and his characters live and breathe on the pages before us. The title story in this collection was the first-prize recipient of the 1999 O. Henry Award -- and well-deserved. It's a shame that Baida died shortly after receiving this honor. We can only imagine what literary gifts he would have given us since then -- but this volume is a fine testament to his wonderful talent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Modern Morality Tales, December 1, 2005
This review is from: A Nurse's Story and Others (Hardcover)
Summary: A collection of stories about moral and ethical dilemmas and the impact of individual choices on society.
This volume of nine passionately written stories is, if nothing else, a lesson in perseverance.
Author Peter Baida submitted his title story to 22 publications. All rejected it. A more easily discouraged writer might have given up after, say, the 10th rejection, but Baida continued submitting his story. Eventually, editor No. 23, Peter Stitt of The Gettysburg Review, accepted and published "A Nurse's Story."
You can probably guess the rest. "A Nurse's Story" won first prize in the 1999 O. Henry Awards. It was a vindication for the author and an indictment of the 22 editors who apparently saw no merit in the story.
However, this book is more important for its contents then for its history.
Peter Baida's voice is distinctive. His short stories boast a solid moral center, a concern with day-to-day ethics and responsibilities. Baida appears to be an unsentimental Christian whose outlook is similar to that of the Catholic Worker movement. He is clearly for the "little guy" and against the dehumanizing effects of both corporations and unions. He reveals a social consciousness that harkens back to the proletarian literature of the 1930s, but leavened with the irony and ambiguity of the 1990s.
Baida also reveals a streak of mysticism and other-worldliness - in stories such as "A Nurse's Story" and "The Rodent," the dead come back to converse with the living - qualities that perhaps turned off editors more inclined to realism and minimalism.
But Baida's writing isn't screechy and preachy. He writes smoothly and subtly, with humor and some experimentation. "Points of Light," a story of how one's politics change with age, is written almost entirely as dialogue.
Many of Baida's stories don't follow the classic unity of time; instead, they experiment with chronology, skipping back and forth through the decades, covering a lifetime or several lifetimes in a few pages. Baida can show us "the big picture" while still focusing on the details. Not unlike the short stories of Alice Munro, Baida's short stories feature enough character and plot to sustain a novel.
In stories such as "Class Warfare" and "Mr. Moth and Mr. Davenport," Baida comes across as pro-union, but with a jaundiced eye. He doesn't ignore the sincere concerns of management, nor does he ignore the corruption and violence of the unions. "Class Warfare" is a pitiless account of a newspaper strike, narrated by one of the strikers, and tells of deals made with the devil by both sides in the conflict.
Baida knows that all actions - and inactions - have consequences, some of which reverberate through society and across generations. This is what Robert Penn Warren once called "the spider web theory of history": No matter what spot of the web is touched, the entire web vibrates.
Baida also knows that individuals sometimes must make agonizing choices in life, and that sometimes the morally correct choice can still have disastrous consequences for the innocent.
In the heartbreaking "The Rodent," a corporate whistleblower prevents his company from marketing a potentially dangerous drug. His choice saves countless unknown lives, but destroys all he holds dear - his reputation, his career, and his family.
That story's moral counterpoint is "The Reckoning," a tale of how a college administrator's pride and greed ruin the lives of his children long after he has died and they have grown into unhappy adults.
"A Doctor's Story" is also about choices - how a doctor in the Germany of the 1930s chooses his patients' quality of life over their right to life, and thus helps jump-start his society from euthanasia to the Holocaust.
The O. Henry Prize-winner, "A Nurse's Story," is about Mary McDonald, a nurse and union organizer whose humble but principled life has a domino effect. Her choices benefit the lives in her community for generations to come. The story has almost the same virtues as "It's A Wonderful Life," but without the saccharine and treacle.
Sadly, the author's own Cinderella story of winning the O. Henry Award - a story O. Henry himself might have penned - does not have a happy ending. Peter Baida died of complications of hemophilia two months after winning the prize. He was 49 years old.
It was the kind of hard reality that Baida the artist would have appreciated.
Peter Baida's A Nurse's Story and Others is thus a posthumous publication. It is also a worthy memorial to the humanity and vision of its author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
