Customer Reviews

Observer

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This album, with a quite bizarre conceptual theme for a rock album (mostly sung descriptions internet dating), turns out to be one of their best. The songs are mostly quite catchy; the guitar playing is impeccable; and the singing as stronger than ever.

I have followed Mecca Normal since their inception. Although occasionally flawed with atonal rants, their folk-punk has always been inspirational. Most albums have been a single guitar (somewhat similar to early Billy Bragg, but with greater virtuosity, edge and attitude) and one set of female vocals - with an occasional fill of piano and additional guitars. Nevertheless, their presence is more stirring than many of the best full scale rock bands.

I have read in fanzines about Mecca Normal since the 80s, but I always felt they were a little more arty and sophisticated than the hardcore I used to be into. Wow! I was right! Now that I am a little more sophisticated in my tastes, Mecca Normal is right on time...Amazing, profound music that really speaks to me, I look forward to getting the other 11 albums over the next few years...I'm psyched! This album is a stunning and progressive creative statement. Listening to this was like the first time I listened to punk rock, opening up a totally new and different world.

I haven't listened to this CD in close to 2 years - unfortunately for me the band's music is now permanently tied to a negative vibe. C'est la vie.
That being said, I was reminded tonight of the track, "Attraction Is Ephemeral" and felt like I wanted to add my endorsement to the woefully under-represented numbers (two) of reviews here.
Quite simply, this record is a magnificent achievement. It resonates sonically and lyrically to a depth and with a persistence that is beyond rare.

I miss listening to this and, once you hear it, you'll understand exactly why.

So why 4 stars and not 5? Because I'd like to believe that this strange and long-standing partnership can even exceed this work in the future. And perhaps, after a moment's annoyance, that will evoke a wry smile on Ms Smith's lips....you never know...