Customer Reviews

Okinawa's Complete Karate System: Isshin Ryu

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Mr. Rosenbaum has certainly done his research. This book covers all aspects of the development of Isshin-Ryu Karate. He outlines how chinese martial arts, kobudo sytems and the budo systems of japan influenced okinawan karate. This book also provides detailed information on the philosphy of Isshin Ryu and its growth in the united states. If you're looking for a how to book look somewhere else, but if you want an outstanding book on the history of an effective martial art look no further.

As an Okinawan Karate practitioner with over 20 years experience, (most of it in Isshinryu) I find this work very detailed in its history of the system. The author gives credit to many of the early Isshinryu pioneers that have not been made mention of in previous works like Don Bohan, and others who did much to futher Isshinryu but have recieved little or no written credit. The author also delves into other aspects which have previously not been covered like the hard/soft aspects of this system and the various roles of kata in training. His exploration of the political infighting that abounds in this system is bound to have some very unkind comments sent his way, but he should be given credit for casting light on this "skeleton in the closet" anyway. This is far from being a how to book, its true value is its historical approach, and insightfullness into the system. I highly recommend it.

The author takes a different route in this book in that he explores Isshninryu not so much from the standard party line of it being the greatest martial art the world has ever known. Instead he sets down before the reader a great overview of the system and its early pioneers, most of whom were Americans, and tells how and why this Karate System evolved without trying to debase any other systems of karate. He does however take a different viewpoint towards the effectivness of modern day sport based systems and is quite quick to point of the differences between Japanese Styles and Okinawan Styles of Karate.

There are very few pictures in this book except for the sketches done of famous Isshinryu practitioners however he does a wonderfull job of exploring the body mechanics of the system, its hard and soft elements as well as its internal and external elements all explained in a rather matter of fact viewpoint. Nowhere does he delve into quasi-mystical elements as is so often done in many martial arts books attributing this or that to chi, ki or anyother unseen element. Intead he presents facts to the reader and lets you determine what is real and what isn't. Also he takes the same approach in his presentation fo the system itself. He is however, and rightly so, pretty harsh on modern day ranking it's abuse and the good ole boy politics found within many styles of karate, Isshinryu included. Over all its a good book, not to deep, just to the point and factual.

I'm all for any book on my style of Karate, but there really isn't much in this book that isn't found in other isshinryu books. Not only that but there are some errors that give away the fact that one the author's reference were obviously older isshinryu books that are know to have said errors. Also there are no techniques in this book, its purpose is more aimed at just giving the history of Isshinryu. However with errors, like the founder's birthday being the wrong day and year, it could use a little bit more work.

This purchase was one of the best I have ever made. The small black dot on the side of the book they described in no way impedes the reading of the book. I would buy from them again from them without reservation. Speedy shipment also, it came in half the time they said.

I've been hearing people talk about this book for the past year but, just got down to reading it recently. It's well written, very informative about not just Isshinryu but Okinawan Karate as a martial art in general. In fact it should be made recommend reading for Isshinry practitioners. THere are a few areas where I disagreed with the author, in particular his views towards tournament karate but over all it's got to be one of the best I've ever read on Isshinryu and thats after 15 years of practice.

This is an easy to follow history on the roots of modern day karate and kobudo as well as a detailed description of the past and present influences and aspects of the Isshin Ryu system.

He shows a clear understanding of the distinction between practicing karate as a sport and as a way of life. There were many times that questions would arise (what does he mean, how does he justify that) only to have them answered by the next page. Very informative in it's historical detail and very refreshing in it's perspective.

This book is not just for the martial arts expert. It is for those of us who are interested in looking at history,philosophy and a way of life. Once I started reading this book I could not put it down. This book is a must read.

This book provides a very good history of the Okinawan combative arts and the influences upon them. Its true message however is pointing out the pitfalls that have become us today due to over-inflated egos and undeserved promotions. Look out you paper tiger masters and over night black belts this man takes no prisoners. If your doing martial arts for the sake of doing martial arts this book is for you. If it's your ego that motivates you or that next promotion look else where.

Mr. Rosenbaum did an excellent job of researching the rich history of Isshinryu karate. His book includes details about Okinawan history, the influences on Tatsuo Shimabuku, kata description, and the personalities involved with the development of Isshinryu in the United States. His writing style is obviously considerate of the new karate-ka (student) and provides a general overview of Isshrinyu without spending too much time on any one topic. I have applied Mr. Rosenbaum's information to questions presented to me in the dojo by my sensei, so the topics Mr. Rosenbaum covers are very applicable.

The major fault with this book is poor editing. Typographical errors that are common to any author are present and this book would benefit greatly by a professional editor reviewing the text prior to the next edition. But the errors are not so abundant as to distract the reader.

I appreciate Mr. Rosenbaum's attitude about the political issues between different Isshinryu organizations. His respectful tone and hope for a stronger Isshinryu community are good examples for the rest of us.

Another strength to this book are the simple illustrations of the major contributors to Isshinryu accompanied by brief biographies. I would like to see more of Mr. Rosenbaum's illustrations in a future edition.