32 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Important Contribution, October 3, 2005
This review is from: The Older Testament: The Survival of Themes from the Ancient Royal Cult in Sectarian Judaism and Early Christianity (Paperback)
I'm pleased to see this remarkable book back in print. As Barker explains in her introduction, "What I have done is to select from a wide range of material sufficient to formulate a theory which brings together many problems in this field and presents them as different aspects of a fundamental misreading of the Old Testament. This misreading is one which has been forced upon us by those who transmitted the text." (Barker, 1).
The principle transmitters to whom she refers are the Deuteronomists and their heirs.
To look beneath their work, Barker's describes her approach this way:
"We have to find something appropriate for a group of Galileans, relevant to their needs and aspirations, but sufficiently coherent (and even recognizable) to draw the hostility of Jerusalem Judaism, as a threat to the Law ... Our task is to reconstruct a background quite independent of New Testament considerations, appropriate to the world of Jesus' first followers, and known to exist as a single set of ideas which threatened the Law ...
"In order to reconstruct such a background, it is necessary to dig deep, and to work back through the writings of several centuries. I shall begin with the pseudepigraphon known as 1 Enoch (Ethiopic Enoch), and shall then devote the rest of this book to establishing the antecedents of this work, which is known to have been used by the earliest Christians ... This mythology underlies the creation theology of Romans 8, the exorcisms and miracles of the Gospels, the heavenly archetypes of Hebrews, and the first Temple imagery of the Fourth Gospel. It is the imagery of Revelation, Jude and the Petrine Epistles, and the song of its angels became the Sanctus of the eucharistic liturgy. Little of this is derived directly from Enoch; the process rather has been one of following the Enochic stream to its source, and seeing what other waters have flowed from it. (Barker, 6-7)"
Following her introduction, subsequent chapters in the Older Testament survey the Book of Enoch (the longest chapter, 72 pages long), Wisdom traditions, Old Testament passages using the title "The Holy One," "Isaiah of Jerusalem" (that is, the chapters from 2-36, which are generally dated to the time of Ahaz and Hezekiah), Deuteronomy, The Second Isaiah (chapters generally assigned to an Exilic writer, with her focus on 40-48), The Era of the Restoration, The Third Isaiah ( chapters 57-66, which she sees as critical of the returning Exiles and Deuteronomy), chapters on the Menorah and Eden stories, a study of the divine title Elyon, a study of Job in light of her hypothesis, and finally, a concluding chapter that lays our her view of the Older Testament, a mythology that was suppressed by the Deuteronomists and their heirs, but which was retained and used by those who became the Christians. As she explains:
"The life and works of Jesus were, and should be, interpreted in terms of something other than Jerusalem Judaism. This other had it roots in the conflicts of the sixth century B.C. when the traditions of the monarchy were divided as an inheritance among several heirs. It would have been lost but for the accidents of archeological discovery and the evidence of pre-Christian texts preserved and transmitted only by Christian hands." (Barker, 7)
This is rewarding and challenging study. It sets out the foundation upon which her subsequent books are built. It ranges over an astonishingly wide range of sources, but demonstrates an uncanny ability to discern important patterns, and make plausible connections between those sources. She can write beautifully, but also where necessary gets into the very close readings in the original languages of her source materials, at times quoting the Hebrew and Greek, comparing telling variations between the Masoretic Hebrew, the Septuagint Greek, the Aramaic targums, the Dead Sea Scrolls, a wide range of Midrashic and Talmudic traditions. She also shows a firm grasp on a range of scholarly interpretations. She is able to relate evidence from close readings to larger movements and patterns, and from larger movements she finds a context for the tiny details. Compared to her recent Temple Theology, which summarizes her views for a general audience, this is more detailed and challenging, more akin to The Great High Priest which requires an academic temperament and serious effort to fully appreciate. Nevertheless, I find it richly rewarding to study and re-read. There is more here than can be grasped with a glimpse and a sip. This is a feast for the mind and spirit.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Barker's new book-, March 3, 2007
This review is from: The Older Testament: The Survival of Themes from the Ancient Royal Cult in Sectarian Judaism and Early Christianity (Paperback)
The Older Testament is an excellent book.
If you like Barker's books, you may want to obtain four of her papers that were placed in book form under the title of: "The Hidden Tradition of the Kingdom of God" - ISBN - 0281058466 - available at [...]
Paperback: 128 pages
Publisher: SPCK Publishing (1 Jan 2007)
The Hidden Tradition of the Kingdom of God was developed from four lectures given for the Temenos Academy in London in January 2006. It traces the origin of the idea of the Kingdom of God to the high priestly traditions of the holy of holies in the temple. The book covers: the rejection of the second temple and the hope for the restoration of the true temple in the time of the Messiah; the angel kings of Jerusalem; the role of Adam; the Enoch traditions and the rewriting of the Hebrew Scriptures; the belief in mystical ascent and theosis - becoming divine; the Servant of the Lord and the Wisdom of the Kingdom; Melchizedek as an ancient name for the Lord; Aaron; Miriam; the Book of Revelation as the earliest Christian text; the Kingdom as a vision; Jesus's visions recorded in the Book of Revelation; how the Church adapted the original vision of the Kingdom; how the original vision is relevant today to issues of politics and environment.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No