Customer Reviews

Oliver Twist [VHS]

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This version of "Oliver Twist" is a scant 74 minutes long, but contains much more of the book (including a portion of the Rose Maylie sequence) and retains a highly Dickensian flavor when viewed alongside other adaptations.

If you are new to silent films, this could be a good one to whet your appetite. If you are already a fan, give this one a try. The film is primarily a vehicle for Jackie Coogan, which proves to be just fine, as he is delightful in the title role. His expressive face and tiny stature are dead-right for Oliver, and he has more spunk than most exponents of the role, which helps to allay the saccharine nature of the character.

Fans of Lon Chaney may be disappointed with the little screen time he is given, but he makes the most of it. Subtle touches Chaney adds (such as gently laying a hand on Bill Sikes' chest) give a wealth of subtext and nuance to his performance, and adds immeasurably to our understanding of Fagin as petty thief.

The rest of the cast is good, with a fine performance from Gladys Brockwell as Nancy. She is another aspect of the film which rings true to Dickens: she is less the "hooker with a heart of gold" than a complex, hardened woman who has grown up among criminals yet retains her conscience.

Mention must also be made of the fine production design. Many scenes look as though they were lifted from the original Cruikshank illustrations (especially the meeting at London Bridge) and the men look particularly appropriate for the period. Some of the women retain the '20s look in makeup and hair, which is typical of Hollywood period movies through the 1970's.

The title cards also are well-done, either quoting directly from Dickens or retaining his authorial flavor.

All told, this is a winning adaptation of a perennial favorite.

It is certainly interesting to consider that this 1920 version of "Oliver Twist," the classic novel by Charles Dickens, was intended as a vehicle for Jackie Coogan. Of course, today they put Lon Chaney on the box to pique our interest, but while his Fagin is a commanding presence in the film, he does not pop up until halfway through. Coogan later told the story of how he was first introduced to Chaney in full make-up on the set and was immediately terrified. We have heard about the magic Chaney could do with spirit gum and greasepaint, but notice how impressive his FINGERNAILS are in this film. Having worked with Chaplin in "The Kid," Coogan certainly recognized Chaney's star quality. Coogan's performance is certainly stronger than it was in "The Kid," and you have to appreciate the way he underplays the part, something you would associate with neither kid actors nor silent film stars. George Siegmann makes a memorably monstrous Bill Sikes, Gladys Brockwell is Nancy, and Edouard Trebaol plays the Artful Dodger. Scottish born director Frank Lloyd is usually not recognized as one of the greats of the silent era, but he did make over 100 films and won three Oscars ("The Divine Lady," "Cavalcade," and "Mutiny on the Bounty"). More importantly, he had a love for Dickens that comes through in this film. I amazed at the fact this is only a 74 minutes film; clearly a lot is cut out, but it captures the spirit of Dickens. This was the fourth silent version of the Dickens tale and actually was not topped until the 1948 film with John Howard Davies as Oliver and Alec Guiness as Fagin. Of course, in 1968 the musical version won the Oscar for best picture.

They sure get some adorable kids to play Oliver Twist. "Despised by all and pitied by none." Hooey. In 1922 Jackie Coogan owned Hollywood, and the hearts of Americans all over the world.

Well, the Kid could act, and don't let the cover art or p.r. department fool you. This is Coogan's movie, and Lon Chaney is definitely a secondary character. This 1922 silent movie is well done, and doesn't feel much more dated than the story it tells. Lon Chaney, who must have been wearing some (probably terribly uncomfortable) contraption plays Fagin as a bent, wizened, sharp-nosed wheedler.

I enjoyed LIGHT OF FAITH, the 32-minute add-on movie, more than OLIVER TWIST. Chaney stars in this one, sans cumbersome make-up, playing a street tough who falls for a young woman who moves into his tenement building. The woman, as they were wont to do back then, is failing from a broken heart. The distant object of her affection found the Grail Tennyson wrote of in his Arthurian tales. The Grail, she tells the impressionable Chaney, glows with an inner light and has remarkable curative powers.

So, the girl's dangerously declining, her old beau has the Grail, and Chaney has a larcenous inspiration. Director Clarence Brown delicately handles the material, and Chaney gives a subtle and nuanced performance.

The main feature on this disc, 'Oliver Twist' (1922), is a pretty decent adaptation of the well-known Charles Dickens novel, though, as just about all movies based on books are wont to do, it naturally can't cover everything from the book. The sets bring Victorian England to life pretty well, particularly the settings in the orphanage and in Fagin's house. Life was no picnic for the poor in Victorian England, with no system of social welfare as yet set up, and many poor people were forced to either go to an almshouse, or, if they were desperate enough, to turn to a life of crime like Fagin and his cohorts. However, since it is based on a novel, it doesn't always work very well as a silent. While there are some great silents adapted from works of literature, this one seems really chatty and like it could have been even better as a talkie. There also isn't enough character development, particularly of Fagin (Lon Chaney), who, though he's great in all of his scenes, just doesn't have a lot to do. This was a starring vehicle for the adorable Jackie Coogan (in spite of Lon's picture being on the DVD cover), so it seems natural that the producers would have wanted to emphasise his title character in the storyline, even though at times it seems more like a showcase for Jackie instead of a showcase of the Dickens novel. There could have been more meat on the plot and greater character development if they hadn't done this; as cute and talented as Jackie was, he wasn't the only important character. The print also is a bit worn, though since it was considered lost until 1972, one can't expect too much in terms of print quality. However, I wish there had been a more elaborate score beyond an organ.

The bonus film, 'The Light of Faith' (1922), is a 33-minute excerpt from 'The Light in the Dark,' a six-reel feature that was considered lost in its entirety until the George Eastman House found it and did a restoration of in 2003. The film kind of starts in media res, but that becomes more understandable when one knows that this is only about half of a longer film, not the entire film itself or the only surviving part of it. A young woman has run away from home and her boyfriend back in England, and finds a room to rent in New York. (She's identified as Elaine in this film, though in the full-length version her name is Bessie.) Tony Pantelli (Lon Chaney) notices how pretty she is and that she's not the type of woman he's used to in his life as a street rogue. When she falls down the stairs one day, Tony thinks it's because she's hungry, but the landlady believes it to be a failing heart. Tony devotedly helps her back to health, showing himself to be a criminal with a heart of gold underneath. One day there's a story in the paper about her boyfriend, who is now in New York with what may be the Holy Grail, and Tony is so inspired by the story Elaine tells him about this ancient artifact and its healing powers that he resolves to break into her old boyfriend's house to steal it, desperately hoping that if she touches it, she will be fully cured. This looks like a pretty interesting film, and probably is even better and more developed in the longer version. As always, Lon plays this social outcast, this person whom one might ordinarily shun or run away from in fear because he's a criminal, with such heart and soul, making him into a sympathetic character whom one quickly comes to feel empathy for. He's also looking like his normal self in this role, without any of the elaborate makeup or disguises he's famous for. Though he wasn't what most people would consider one of the world's most beautiful people, he did clean up really nicely and even seems kind of handsome, in a nonconventional way.

Overall, these are two solid features, even though I wouldn't consider either one to be top-notch silent classics. They're still far from being little more than curios. However, 'Oliver Twist' is very recommendable for seeing Jackie Coogan (who seemed to be terrific in just about everything he did as a child star) and for seeing Chaney's unforgettable Fagin. Still, neither film would be one I'd recommend to someone just getting into Lon's films or just silents in general.

Great silent adaptation of Oliver Twist. The DVD from Image is the best available and also includes The Light of Faith. Oliver Twist has been restored as best as possible and is a joy to watch. The intertitles and main title were reset when this film was restored in the 1970's.

I was pleasantly surprised to find the Alpha version of the 1922 silent version of "Oliver Twist" done in a first class manner. The picture is excellent, along with the intertitles and background music.

After watching brilliant director David Lean's incredible 1948 version of "Oliver Twist," if was hard for me to watch some of the other versions of Dickens' classic tale of survival. However, while I was watching the Jackie Coogan/Lon Chaney 1922 version, it seemed to me that Mr. Lean not only watched this film, but studied it very closely.

It also seemed to me that Mr. Lean may have used the 1922 version of "Oliver Twist" as a textbook example for fashioning his own incredible version of "Oliver Twist." Many visual elements in the silent version seemed to have been enhanced and expanded in Mr. Lean's "Oliver Twist."

Don't get me wrong, in my opinion, David Lean's 1948 version of "Oliver Twist" is still the greatest film version of the Dickens novel. But the 1922 silent version runs a close second. And the silent version is about half the running time of the 1948 version, but still remains true to the book.

Even for those who don't usually care for silent films, I think many viewers will be totally entralled and entertained by this wonderful 1922 version of "Oliver Twist." When the film ended, it left me saying, "Please, sir, I want some more."

Oliver Twist was Charles Dicken's second novel, published in 1938. It was first filmed in 1909 and this was the second version. It was filmed again in 1933, 1948, 1997, and 2005, as a musical in 1968, and was a TV miniseries 3 times (1985, 1999, 2007). This version is notable because Lon Chaney played Fagin and Jackie Coogan played Oliver.

Lon Chaney (1883-1930) was one of the biggest stars of the silent era. Known as "The man of 1000 faces", he was capable of disguising himself completely in service of his roles, which could be as diverse as a hunchback ("Hunchback of Notre Dame"), a legless man ("The Penalty"), an armless man who throws knives with his feet ("The Unknown") or a monster ("Phantom of the Opera"). His life was the subject of the 1957 film "Man of 1000 Faces" starring James Cagney.

By 1922 when he made this film he had already made more than 100 films, although many of his best films ("Hunchback of Notre Dame", "The Phantom of the Opera", "The Unknown", "London After Midnight", "Unholy Three") were still ahead of him. Chaney plays Fagin and it's impossible to detect the actor beneath the makeup.

Jackie Coogan (1914-84) was a popular child actor in the silent era who is most famous for "The Kid" (1921). He's best remembered as Uncle Fester for the TV series "The Addams Family" (1964-6). Coogan is cute as young Oliver. One might find that there are more comedy scenes in this film than would be expected in Dicken's dour classic, and these were undoubtedly inserted because Coogan was fresh off "The Kid" (with Chaplin) and audiences were looking to laugh.

Director Frank Lloyd (1886-1960) was a major figure in the 20s and 30s, nominated for an Oscar 4 times and winning for "The Divine Lady" (1929) and "Cavalcade" (1933). Among his notable films are ":Mutiny on the Bounty" (1935), "Blood on the Sun" (1945), and "The Last Command" (1955).

This is a relatively faithful version of the Dickens' classic. The film stock is not the greatest, but more than 75% is perfect and there is only the occasional problem. The intertitles were restored in the 70s. Performances are uniformly good and the sets are wonderful.

I searched the web for a preview of this film, to see if I want to buy it, and only found this one on Amazon. The problem is that in this 2.5 minute preview, you see only about 10 seconds of the actual film. All the rest is credits and title cards. Who is the genius that posted that? Probably the same people who post the LOOK INSIDE pages for books but only show blank pages, title pages and the index. I wish the folks at Amazon would put some thought into these things so their customers can see what they're buying.

I'm giving the film 4 stars on faith because I can't believe that Chaney would be anything but brilliant.