I'm pretty sure that if even if I hadn't ever heard of the Decemberists, I would really love this album. A lot of the press was quick to dismiss it as amatuerish or 'for die-hard Decemberists' fans only; however, I'm pretty sure there's a wider market for Tarkio than even the Decemberists. The sound is less centralized on Meloy's affection for 18th or 19th century British literature and far more a direct product of classic indie rock, like the Smiths or early R.E.M. Tarkio may be more diverse and less blunt in its intentions. The Decemberists excel in melody and production.
The album is a collection of Tarkio's two LPs, and, I believe, an EP, as well as a 4-song radio appearence. It's difficult to pick out a few songs I like above the others, but if I had to, I'd say the opener, Keeping Me Awake, Tristan and Iseult and maybe Sister Nebraska (I'm probably missing a few worthwhile tracks here). An old version of "My Mother Was A Chinese Trapeze Artists" appears here. Interestingly, they sound more and more like the Decemberists as the album progresses. The liner notes contain written memories from the band members and a number of old photographs.
One thing is for certian, that this isn't just for Decemberists fans. It's a treat for them, but even those who find the Decemberists a bit annoying ("indie bedwetters" is the popular putdown) will find Tarkio far more digestable. They were an excellent indie pop band in the Smiths tradition that probably would've made it on their own had they been signed. This is a great album, highly recommended for all music fans. I was tempted to give it 4 stars, but as I'm listening to it, I'm enjoying it more than most of the albums I've bought recently.