From Publishers Weekly
Skillfully blending memoir and social science, Alvarez (How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents) explores the quinceañera, the coming-of-age ceremony for Latinas turning 15. She spent a year researching and attending quince celebrations, finding out what rituals are favored and what they mean to the girls. She researched what the gowns and photo sessions cost. She interviewed people working in the quince industry, from party planners to cake bakers. After all, with more than 400,000 American Latinas turning 15 every year, and with the average quinceañera costing $5,000, the financial, if not the cultural importance of the quince should not be underestimated. Alvarez structures her book around one particular girl's ceremony, from the dreamy planning stages through the late hours of the actual, dizzying affair. By intercutting the party narrative with stories from her own youth, Alvarez reminds herself—and readers—that at some point we were all confused, histrionic adolescents. Both sympathetic and critical, she doesn't dismiss the event as a waste of hard-earned savings or as a mere display of daughters for the marriage market; nor does she endorse it as the essential cultural tradition connecting Latinas to their roots. Instead, Alvarez wants readers to focus on creating positive, meaningful rites of passage for the younger generation.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Best-known for her best-selling novels How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents
, Julia Alvarez draws on her past to create a hybrid sociological study, memoir, and cultural critique. Reviewers praise her open-minded exploration of this treasured fairy-tale ritual, but they note Alvarez's mixed feelings about quinceaeras
. Do they bring immigrant families closer together and provide a valuable cultural reference point? Or is the excessive cost too burdensome on families, especially considering that the money could be spent on higher education instead? Alvarez's lively bits of family history illuminate the challenges of the immigrant experience, and while she doesn't reach any firm conclusions, she raises many questions worth asking.
Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc.