Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent, October 14, 1998
This review is from: One Day of the Civil War: April 10, 1863: America in Conflict (Paperback)
This is a well-researched and very well-written book. I think you will enjoy it if you have any interest at all in history. I am not a Civil War buff, though I have read a few books on it, but found this one terrifically interesting. The author gets into the details of soldiering -- picket (sentry) duty with its long periods of boredom and tedium interspersed with moments of attack and terror, garrison life, drills, train raids, naval maneuvers, and makes it all come alive. Unlike a lot of worm's eye only books, this on does also get into higher strategy among the generals and even Lincoln and his cabinet. If you like this book, you'll like "The Long Surrender" and vice versa. I was fascinated by the soldiers on each side sending toy sailboats across rivers, taking tobacco one way and real coffee the other, and also exchanging newspapers and catcalls between the Yankees and the Rebels. A really fascinating slice of life, and an interesting contrast, for me as a former soldier, in how America's armies fought wars in 1863 and 1968.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A day in the life.., May 25, 2001
This review is from: One Day of the Civil War: April 10, 1863: America in Conflict (Paperback)
April 10, 1863. No major battles were fought. No generals died. The summer's major offensives had not yet begun. So why did Robert Willett choose this day to write about? It was the day the Civil War was half over. The beauty of the book is that without the complex nature of battle we get to read what few others detail -- the complex nature of men at war. And it works! He quotes heavily from personal diaries (a refreshing break from authors who think that rewriting the Official Records qualifies as research). One lengthy quote describes, for example, the election of a Confederate officer by his men. Another, a letter from a suitor to his girlfriend. Other pieces of non-war life abound throughout. And just because there were no major battles, there is plenty of action. Skirmishes, a siege, and the deadiliest enemy of all - disease. I have read many Civil War epochs, and there are many good ones, but Willett's choice of a quiet (relatively) day gives the reader a chance to get to know the men who were fighting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One day, like most others, which may be as interesting as any, October 25, 2005
This review is from: One Day of the Civil War: April 10, 1863: America in Conflict (Paperback)
When I first saw this book my initial thought was this is the kind of book you should expect on a topic that has been written about in a thousand different ways and where there are no new ways apparently to look at it, so come up with a gimmick. And Willett's gimmick was to simply pick the exact midpoint on the calendar of the Civil War, which turns out to be April 10, 1863, and then to relate as much detail as he could find regarding events on that day. Not that that day might have any significance over April 9th or May 5th, etc., just that it's the half-way point. A convenient nail to hang one's hat on.
But I was wrong, and as I began reading the book I saw the gimmick worked, and Willett was able to make something meaningful out of it. On April 10th, a sharp engagement took place at Franklin, Tennessee, when Confederates under Maj. Gen. Earl Van Dorn attacked Federals stationed there (unsuccessfully); this is Willett's major event of the day: he devotes a full chapter to it (nothing about it appears in BATTLES AND LEADERS and Shelby Foote doesn't mention it in his 3-volume narrative history). Willett, of course, gives almost an hour-by-hour account, along with its after effects up through the 12th. For all its details and minutiae (included are excerpts from soldier's letters of that day, newspaper accounts, and, of course, official reports) he makes it interesting.
Willett truly leaves nothing out. He describes what was going on that day in Washington, Richmond, with Lincoln reviewing troops at Falmouth, on the seas and the Mississippi, in the Far West (Humboldt and Cottonwood, Kansas), and scores of other places. He relies on letters to make events human and personal, for participants as well as the folks back home. Certainly unique is his inclusion of an appendix that records every casualty of that Friday long ago.
So this book deserves a spot on the shelf of respectable works on the Civil War, and not on the ever-growing pile of superfluous tomes it's title might imply. Well done!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|