3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Intriguing novel, September 15, 2008
This review is from: One Extraordinary Day (Hardcover)
"One Extraordinary Day" is a dramatic work of fiction that reminded me of so many other projects such as "Phenomenon", "The Twilight Zone", and "The Shack". The alternate universe concept was a bit confusing. Was the main character encountering himself? I usually enjoy tales of supernatural influence making someone's life better. But this book didn't grip my attention as I hoped it would.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
One Extraordinarily Bad Read, November 12, 2008
This review is from: One Extraordinary Day (Hardcover)
In my quest for quality fiction at my bookstore I picked up this book by Harold Myra, who was at one time editor of Christianity Today. I figured it would be at least good. I was wrong.
I was severly disappointed in this book, and I struggle to find sufficient words to describe it. I feel as if I didn't even read the book. It's short, just over one hundred pages long, but short books can be well written.
I just don't understand the point of this book being written. It is basically the conversion experience of a man named David, who goes to the woods to relax. While at a cabin in the woods he has an encounter with what is possibly an angel. Over the course of a day the angel shows him that David lives his life in fear, and eventually for some reason David decides to surrender his life to God. The problem I have with this plot is that it all happens too fast. It seems contrived and forced. There is never really any insight into the inner workings of David, other than stale phrases that describe generic people. His character is never developed.
Myra is a good writer, but I just didn't like this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Distraught, downtrodden...dull, September 16, 2008
This review is from: One Extraordinary Day (Hardcover)
Meet David - distressed, distraught, downtrodden and seeking decompression. With his career on shaky ground, tensions have mounted, and his emotions are close to boiling over. His wife Marcia has recommended a get-away, a time of relaxation - spend some time in nature, kick back and forget about work. This novella opens with David doing just that, spending time at the lake while striving to put his worries behind him.
Unfortunately putting his worries behind him is easier said than done. David stews in an emotional turmoil of his own making, mulling over the past, magnifying the significance of minor confrontations, holding grudges. The intrusion of an unusual stranger in David's life not only disrupts his plans, but also permanently disrupts his perception of reality and God.
When the opportunity became available to review this book there was little information available on the internet about it. All blurbs were excruciatingly short, the reviews vague, telling nothing of the story line beyond the first chapter. Unfortunately that is because there is little story to be found. Essentially a work of Christian speculative fiction, the author seems to have based his work around this question - "What if an unbeliever met an angel from another world, another dimension?" This does sound like a fascinating premise, but after the first two chapters the initial intrigue and mystery fade away.
This angel or celestial - named Michael by David - plays the role of a spiritual mentor and teacher. Unfortunately some of his teachings are either based upon wild conjecture, such as his own origins, or is slightly off doctrinally. Thankfully the presentation of the Gospel message presented by Michael is sound. If nothing else I can hope that the message of hope and reconciliation with God will impact someone's life, somewhere.
Normally an unusual premise and doctrine that is marginally erroneous fails to bother me in a work of fiction. In this case I'm bothered. One Extraordinary Day reads like teaching fiction, fiction with a message it wants to express in an open and obvious way. Similar to The Celestine Prophecy or Ishmael (only Christian of course), the reader is left with the strong impression that certain spiritual truths are being taught and conveyed. In my opinion speculative fiction and teaching fiction do not make good bed mates, particularly in this title.
Myra seems to be pushing his writing hard for significance when there is little to be found. Despite this rather apparent striving, his writing skills are technically adequate. The only other fault in his writing technique is that he failed to involve me in the story. As a result of that failing I found this tiny volume, approximately 90 pages of text with wide margins, rather dull.
Due in part to the brevity of this work, I failed to emotionally engage with either of the main characters. After the initial curiosity passed, the rest of the read fell flat. Myra seemed about to pull off an ending that generated a warm cozy feeling, but then came short of the goal at the last moment. Sadly One Extraordinary Day has proven to me that not all tales exploring the theme of redemption and hope make for worthwhile reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
