Most Helpful Customer Reviews
55 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly written, with too many anecdotes and not enough concrete material, December 31, 2010
This review is from: One Good Trade: Inside the Highly Competitive World of Proprietary Trading (Wiley Trading) (Hardcover)
As several other reviewers have indicated, this is "not just another book on technical analysis." While that's completely fine -- there are lots of other good books out there if you want a book on any individual topic, like technical analysis or trader psychology, and I've read dozens of them -- I think this book swings too far in the opposite direction. The book fails to give any but the barest details about how an individual might go about applying the principles and methodologies that have supposedly worked so well for the author's firm. We hear over and over again about trading "stocks in play." What does that even mean? All we are told is that stocks in play are those for which there have been recent news releases, and have "good order flow" and "enough volume." Perhaps I'm part of a dumb minority for whom the meaning of these vague terms isn't completely obvious. However, my claim is that the author simply doesn't elaborate on any of his claims in enough depth to make them useful for the unwashed masses who don't already work in a prop trading firm. He has an entire chapter dedicated to describing what kind of people get hired at firms like his, and yet he somehow manages not to say anything more substantive than "firms look for people who are a good fit for their culture." Wow, what a revelation. Bottom line: I'm not looking for someone to hold my hand through every minute detail of the trading process, but I find it ridiculous that a ~$40 book with great reviews on Amazon would do nothing more than make broad generalizations about how to achieve consistent profitability. The book is reasonably consistent in reminding readers that success is derived from discipline and process rather than gut feelings or even innate trading talent, but there are plenty of other books that convey that message (and do it more concisely and/or more concretely).
My second major beef with this book, besides its lack of specificity, has to do with the writing style. The book is written in a very colloquial style, with plenty of bad grammar, irritating redundancy, and a deficiency of structure. That may not bother some people, and it may work fine if you're presenting in a trading seminar, but I find it cliched and unprofessional in a book with this topic and price point. On a related note, the author spends a lot of time giving sports analogies -- not a problem per se, though they're not terribly original and start to get old after you've read them multiple times over the course of the book -- and generally touting the skills and achievements of himself, his partner, and a subset of the traders who work at his firm. A few anecdotes about real-world traders and scenarios are great to give color to any discussion of trading topics, but I didn't buy this book just to hear about so-and-so and how he joined your firm -- particularly if you're not going to give me any useful guidance about how I can replicate that person's success.
In the end, if you want to read a lot of vague blather about SMB Capital and how a handful of its traders have done well for themselves, go ahead and buy this book. But if you want something a little more focused and relevant for the real world, I'd recommend looking elsewhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
56 of 67 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Book, July 25, 2010
This review is from: One Good Trade: Inside the Highly Competitive World of Proprietary Trading (Wiley Trading) (Hardcover)
I don't often write reviews, but I really liked this book. I read this book in two days. I first heard about Mike Bellafiore through Dr Brett Steenbarger's blog, "Traderfeed".
The title, "One Good Trade" refers to a process as taught by SMB Capital, a proprietary trading firm which Mr Bellafiore owns with a partner. The process entails following the seven fundamentals taught by SMB through the entry and exit of a trade and then going on to the next trade and following those fundamentals again and repeating this process for the rest of your trading life. The seven fundamentals are detailed in the book. Mr Bellafiore's emphasis is on this process. He states that making and losing money on any specific trade is not the focus, but following this process IS the focus and making one good trade after another by following these fundamentals is the essence of good trading. You can lose money on a trade, but if you follow these fundamentals and this process, your profit and loss statement will ultimately take care of itself. He compares this to sports teams and the way they practice the fundamentals over and over and then execute those fundamentals in the game. There are plenty of sports analogies here with the implication that an elite trader must go through the same kind of rigorous and disciplined training that successful athletes go through. Having played sports in high school and college and now trading full-time, I have to agree. The book begins with the explanation of this process and the principles of this process are felt throughout the book. Mr Bellafiore is not here to teach some new technical analysis technique, thank God. He basically states that his firm already knows those techniques. That's the easy part, the difficult part is training traders to FOLLOW and trade the patterns that he already knows are successful. This reminds me of the statement made by Paul Tudor Jones that you can give most people tomorrow's Wall Street Journal and they will STILL lose money. It's the difference between hitting perfect shots on the driving range and then executing those same shots in a competitive round of golf. The emphasis here is on the psychological side of trading which, for me, is really all there is. It doesn't really matter how well you can call markets if you are exiting trades with a .20 cent profit, because you are so exited about being right and making a little bit of money, when the target on the trade was a dollar, The emphasis is NOT on being right in your market forecasting skills, but on building the skills to execute each trade correctly. So Mr Bellafiore is stating that being right in and of itself is NOT enough, the trading process is MUCH more than calling markets correctly. Being right has much more to do with ego and pride than making money. So paying attention to the fundamentals and their execution rather than bragging rights about market direction is, for Mr Bellafiore, the STARTING point. And executing these fundamentals is MUCH more difficult than one anticipates and requires YEARS of dedication, sweat and hard work. No wonder there are so few elite traders or, for that matter, elite anything. It's not that correctly calling markets is not important, it is, it's just that forecasting becomes secondary to skill building and discipline.
The book is sprinkled throughout with stories of traders, both successful and unsuccessful. I found these stories very interesting and I recognize one of the successful traders from Mr Bellafiore's blog. (A blog that, in my opinion, is worth your time). In one chapter, Mike Bellafiore describes the hiring process at SMB and how difficult it is to choose a person that will succeed as a trader. A Prop firm funds traders that they train and the firm makes money based upon the success or failure of these traders.
Later on the author details some of the strategies commonly used by SMB traders. On the surface, these are similar to patterns which I think most traders are familiar with. The difference is in the application of these strategies and for that I think one may need to go through the SMB Training. I started trading before Prop firms became as popular as they are today. If I was just starting out today, I believe this is the route I would take if I was fortunate enough to be chosen. The hiring process is VERY selective. Mike Bellafiore is big on traders getting out there and sharing and exchanging ideas. As most independent traders know, this is a lonely profession. It doesn't have to be, but most traders are in a room full of screens with only their own minds and a few internet feeds. For me, I am happy Mike Bellafiore took the time to exchange his ideas with us. I am currently reading the book for the second time. This is definitely a book worth adding to your trading library.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
31 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Overhyped, October 7, 2010
This review is from: One Good Trade: Inside the Highly Competitive World of Proprietary Trading (Wiley Trading) (Hardcover)
Naturally, after buying the book, I check out the SMB website and they are selling their training for $6000. For a mere $280 or so a month, you can watch them trade every day.
There is some good advice in this book but too many of the macho claims are off the charts. One trader has supposedly made a profit every single day for the past 2 years..and he is not their best trader. How about expanding a bit on how this was accomplished? Some detailed examples of actual trades?
In the beginning of the book we are lectured on trading "stocks in play", one or two every day that are active and volatile. Ok.
Near the end of the book, we learn about another SMB trader who can carry 30 positions at one time. Apparently, they change styles as the market changes. Sounds easy. Anything specific we should be looking for? If I don't know which style I am trading at the moment, what good is this book to me? Guess I have to subscribe to the website.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
