Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This one's a must read, May 5, 2001
This review is from: One of the Guys (Paperback)
I just finished reading "One Of The Guys" and have to say that I thought it was smashing. The little blurb on the front of the book describes it as a "service comedy" and I've read several comments by people saying how hard they laughed. To be quite honest, I didn't think of it as a comedy at all and only laughed once near the end but when I did I howled. I did, however, think that this story was full of irony and biting wit and those are the qualities that made it such a wonderful reading experience for me. There was so much truth in the story: the truth of human nature, the sad truths about the things humans do to other humans and then excuse those actions by dehumanizing the ones whom they abuse and the hopeful truth that even though a human being hits bottom there is always the possibility that he/she can begin anew and become a different person. Not quite the way Miles did it but as a metaphor it was the perfect plotline. And, contrary to what some extremist organizations would have us believe, I think it is important that people know about the terrible and unforgiveable things that are visited upon people in countries as poor as those cited as sex ports in the story. The only way to rid ourselves of immoralities is to look at them straight on and say that this isn't right and it has to stop. To stick our collective heads in the sand and pretend that such things don't exist is not only cowardly but it debases us all. I can understand why the Navy is upset by this book. It tells too much of a truth to be palatable to them. And to anyone who has ever had to deal with a 19 year old male, I say multiply that one young man by a ship's complement of 600 and try to imagine what you would get. I think, upon reflection, one would have to agree that you would get what is described in this book. To believe that the United States Military is what is portrayed in movies like Operation Petticoat is so naive as to be laughable. Perhaps in the real world things aren't quite as lax as described in this story but I would be willing to bet that Robert Young's account isn't too far off the mark. If I had to characterize One Of The Guys in one sentence, I would say that it is the story of a man who has been lost for all of his life who, despite running away from what is left of his life and discarding his identity, finds in himself the man he always wanted to be. This is one great story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent book by a new author, May 5, 2000
Superb piece of modern American fiction, in the best traditions of the likes of early John Irving. The story suerbly develops the main (and subsidary) characters, and you really want to know what is going to happen at the end. It is both humourous, touching, bitter sweet, and yet has an edge and a newness to it, which makes it interesting
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
One of the Guise., April 9, 2001
This review is from: One of the Guys (Paperback)
This is a most unusual novel. You've got Miles Derry, who begins the book cleaning up the glory-hole video booths at a porn shop. He's an ex-addict, ex-drunk, a father of one child out of wednlock he has never really gotten to know, and has spent his whole life feeling like he is just not "One of the Guys." Well, in one of said booths is a dead naval chaplain, who bears more than enough of a passing resemblance to Miles that Miles can assume his identity. Shipping out with the Navy as a Chaplain, Miles has what I can only call a somewhat surreal journey, which, regardless of a few bumps along the way, kept my interest throughout. Despite some really foul language (even I was blushing at parts), and a few very tired stereotypes (gay priests yet again, anyone?), the book was very good, and I enjoyed it. It is cynical, and in places outright repulsive in the vivid prose used to describe what is going on about, around, and to our pseudo-chaplain. I also have no grasp at all on the US Navy and its workings, but imagine that Young's representations were extrapolated: driven to an extreme to really show the sides he wanted illustrated. I'm above the 49th parallel, though, so I found a lot of the Navy rules, regulations, and acronyms stupefying, making it much easier to walk this novel hand in hand with Miles. I caution against reading this book too seriously. I laughed a lot, when I wasn't swallowing a wince or a queasy feeling, and even though I'm finished, I still can't decide how I feel about Miles. It's a thought-provoking book, if you can get past the coarseness and gore. I'd reccommend it, just beware the sea-sickness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|