From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2–Counting sheep has long been the suggested cure for insomnia, but for Sam that's not the problem. He needs to keep track of his herd of 10, but each time he tries to count them, he nods off before he finishes. The sheep conclude that they must be too boring to keep the shepherd alert and that they must find a way to be more interesting. This becomes imminently important when a wolf in sheep's clothing appears at the door on a stormy night. Just as the man is about to let him in, the real sheep insist that he count one more time. They put on a show, and at last he is able to keep his eyes open long enough to count the chorus line. The wolf is left out in the storm, and the sheep and Sam go back to bed. The rhyming text is somewhat inconsistent. Some lines are exact rhymes; others are very loosely rhymed–so loose it's hard to recognize the lines as verse. This and the uneven cadence make the story difficult to read smoothly. However, children will giggle over the comical illustrations. The rounded bodies of Sam and his sheep (on two legs) walk up over the quilted hills, creating their own rhythm. The white sheep with their dark faces and striped stocking caps pull readers' eyes across the pages. Laughter will ring out when the wolf's loud knock literally scares the hats and socks right off them as they slumber. Pair this tale with Rob Scotton's
Russell the Sheep (HarperCollins, 2005) for a wide-awake storytime.
–Carolyn Janssen, Public Library of Cincinnati and Hamilton County, OH Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
One stormy night, Sam leads his 10 sheep home to bed and starts to count them, but he falls asleep at "four."^B Later, a wolf in sheep's clothing arrives, and Sam nearly welcomes him as one of the flock, until the real sheep intervene. The shamefaced Sam confesses that he
can't count them because "It's a well-known fact / that when people count sheep, / it tires us all out / and puts us to sleep." Offended but ever practical, the flock comes up with a plan to keep Sam awake through the count of 10. The rhyming verses roll along smoothly with some very satisfying turns of phrase, while the stylized ink drawings and fine watercolor work give the art real pizzazz. All the characters are drawn with chunky bodies, spindly legs, and droll countenances. When a page folds out for the sheep's onstage debut, children will be ready to cheer (and count) these strange-looking but definitely lovable creatures, whose keen instincts and insistence on arithmetic solve the problem and save the day.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved